TWG CLXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

[roundbox]

Re: TWGXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

I'm gonna he honest and say that I think the only person here who would leave you alive is Manti

this feels like some hard, fierce tinfoil

less sure but relatively likely is my mindset here

does this mean you're thinking wolves saved MML here? just seems to be the natural conclusion granted your townread on fg

---

wv's claim and all the follow-up stuff didn't have anything suspicious to it, I think

what I will say is this: please, please, PLEASE pick your seer choice on your own volition
do not let people's input in thread sway your opinion. people's choice for "how should I do something" has been fucked with in both the Survivor: Newfoundland game and the most recent FE Mystery game. MAKE YOUR OWN CHOICE, it's gonna show up in thread even if you die so who_cares

--

This is definitely not looking good for Manti tbh.

how??? I don't get your logic here, not saying your read is wrong

lol @ the repetition

can you pick some of those posts outside haku's wolf range out

I thought the same thing here but didn't post it
shoot me for making this mindmeld, I dare you

reads

I'm gonna echo myself earlier and think the manti point is a bit of tinfoil
I can step back from my read about his reaction regarding your point on charu/manti history, though. I think this is a very good point

Roundbox, where are you at with Manti and Raeko ?

manti: I need to go back and read his posts again, but I agree with MML that his last post going on funny looks kinda gross. that being said, I can't give you a good answer because I need to ISO him

raeko: if you look at my last handful of games, reading raeko is not a strong suit of mine for many reasons.
looking at the reads against raeko, the two that fell flat on me were mml's and fg's, mostly because they were "gimme reads list or die". sunfan's read on raeko actually has clout. he referenced some reads on how she responds to him in his most recent bigpost, but I'm not sure which ones he's talking about
raeko/fg are never w/w, this much we can all agree on. I agree with dabackpack that fg's vote drop then disappearance is a possible case of wolf abandonment as raeko would have been an easy target to ice.
I don't think raeko's responses have been bad, and I feel like how she's responded has sounded like her town game with people attacking her for a lack of activity
I guess this is a big post saying I really don't know, I'll let everyone else decide. it always feels like fighting a big conflict of interest every time it comes back to my read on her. maybe this'll bite me in a future game, maybe it's already bitten me this game
gun to the head, I'd say she's more towny than not based off of how most suspicion has garnered on her

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWGXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

how??? I don't get your logic here, not saying your read is wrong

Manti didn't really develop on that and Neee just died after so, this wasn't a pursued line.

I was waiting to see if Manti would have some sort of turn around with more descriptive posts to try to help me read him, but so far, it felt like non committal plays and a bit of defensive play.

It makes me feel like he's waiting for town to self destruct rather than try making a difference.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWGXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

also, haku, i think describing my recent posts as descriptive is a bit of a stretch

but this is a more tractable number of people to write more things about, at the very least

I should have worded this differently. The overall point is that your posts feel easy to follow for me and usually extend outside of what I had in mind, but never really in a way that made me question you.

Charu/Sunfan looks the same to me as well. It's kind of locking my PoE considering I have WV as town as well.

[roundbox]

Re: TWGXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

What was fucky?

The sudden push to Funny?

The votes switching to thesunfan briefly?

MML acquiring KitB status suddenly?

my response to you was regarding the post of yours I quoted when you were responding to sunfan. this one:

I think there's a reason for the lynch that occurred. You got people suspicious of you, got people suspicious of mellon, got people suspicious of MML, got people suspicious of Funny.

You see what I'm getting at? Everyone doesn't have a clue since there's really NOTHING to push this game. No info, no nothing. No one has said anything regarding roles, and no one has stated if they did anything.

Once people start saying these things, we might just get out of this slump where everyone is null and suspicious and get some solid towns and solid wolves.

fg votes: I'm gonna do the "take my opinion back" on manti's vote, he did call out swapping to fg since haku wasn't happening. never ye mind
haku's vote looks the flimsiest, he walked in the latest and voted without too much context. he posed a "mml or fg?" thought but I don't know if it was sincere based on him saying he'd shake a fg lynch
charu I'm still banking on your claim
I'm townleaning dabackpack, so I'm not gonna go into him
raeko I already went into

MML votes: reading into the sunfan vote is pointless as he never votes fg there with his reads up to that point
neeee is dead and therefore most likely to be town, so there's nothing there
I like indheart a lot, so not gonna look into that
wv is town based off of claim
I'm me


motherfucker that MML wagon looks pure as hell
UUUUUUUUUGH

fuck
is it MML???

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWGXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

5 -- MixMasterLar -- Wayward Vagabond (45), roundbox (43), theknightsofneeee (133), the sun fan (135), inDheart (63)
5 -- Funnygurl555 -- DaBackpack (70), Charu (122), mellon_collie (21), DarkManticoreX2 (39), Hakulyte (82)
2 -- mellon_collie -- Funnygurl555 (30), MixMasterLar (45)

Kitb has occurred!

I'm surprised MML didn't self-pres. That probably doesn't mean much tho.

DBP/Manti were on FG.

At the time, FG was a bigger coin flip than MML for me and I thought I'd be more easily able to discern if MML was town or wolf than FG.

[Charu]

Re: TWGXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

fuck
is it MML???

I'm still of the opinion that one specific post he made 7 minutes pass phase shift where Syhto died still is one of the strongest pieces of evidence to support he's town.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWGXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

Yeah, I tend to believe he's town as well despite the wagon looking "pure".

[roundbox]

Re: TWGXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

haku?

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWGXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

haku?

I don't get the why regardless of how you want to interpret how I look.

[the sun fan]

Re: TWGXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

I'm still of the opinion that one specific post he made 7 minutes pass phase shift where Syhto died still is one of the strongest pieces of evidence to support he's town.

I would like 2 remind u that this is very, very easy to fake

[roundbox]

Re: TWGXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

I don't get the why regardless of how you want to interpret how I look.

looking at the wagons again and their independent voters, I think I'm actually moving more towards the conclusion that fg was a hard miss

I don't think your EOD entrance looks good
I don't think your vote looks good, especially the timing and the justification
you also wanted to pursue neeee even after his replacement into the anti-pearl slot
you've been complaining about not being able to make a good town circle, but you've had some hard defenses of people and have been consistently townreading players like charu and thesunfan

[roundbox]

Re: TWGXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

my brain feels like a ping pong table right now. taking a short break

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWGXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

I don't think your EOD entrance looks good
I don't think your vote looks good, especially the timing and the justification
you also wanted to pursue neeee even after his replacement into the anti-pearl slot
you've been complaining about not being able to make a good town circle, but you've had some hard defenses of people and have been consistently townreading players like charu and thesunfan

Pretty hard to answer this without going into ugly self-meta.

They are objectively valid reasons. They're unfortunately not the reality of this game and I feel like I won't be able to prove that in any way.

Yeah, I feel ya. That sucks.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWGXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

Well, if you can't solve me by tone this game, you're unlikely to solve me because actions do look weak.

I didn't really filter anything in how I played to "appear good". I just had thoughts while reading and thrown them on the table to see what happens.

So, no excuses here. It just didn't occur to me that weaker plays > being wolf vs town.

[mellon_collie]

Re: TWGXXXI - TWGreeD - Game Thread

I’m so so sorry for not being around until now, this game could not have started at a worse time for me.

hey raeko why did you vote fg when mml was a wagon?

i mean this sounds like someone said something that contradicted your read on fg but if you had her as townie i would think that it would take more than that to vote for them over mml who you had in your possible wolf pile.

Realizing that she had parked her vote (on me specifically) did just change my mind that much. I was also worried about not dying myself and the FG wagon seemed more likely than MML when I made my vote.

I’m caught up but if you asked me a question and I missed it, sorry.