TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

Not yet, so much inconclusive evidence.

But your guy's voting patterns are going to be the death of you.

If there's a pattern in my voting, let me know, because I have yet to find one.
That being said, my first "real" vote of the game back by SCIENCE.

Xiz

[cedolad]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

Xiz

I want to know where everyone stands on Xiz. Mainly T-Force, which posts, if any, of Xiz's lie in suspicion with you? As goes for anyone else.

answers are needed

[Xiz]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

tokzic

[cedolad]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

Since we don't have much of a general consensus, may I suggest:

A phase may be extended for 24 hours once if enough users make a request due to unavailability.

Considering the phase ends in less than 6 hours, and a few of us will be unavailable.

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

I'm listening to you, Xiz, mainly because you like to read my mind. I like how yoshl stopped posting after I said he'd been causing too much trouble, and he finally made a post where he didn't accuse anyone.

Also, yeah, you're right Charu, mistake on my part, its unfortunate that that's the only thing, other than Yoshl agreeing that we should focus on catching the wolves rather than making a seering strategy, that anyone has take from what I would say is my first 95% quality post. Shame.

What I will say bothers me Charu, is that you have a strange name-dropping routine in your posts. That's why I was suspicious of you, and why I still am. And I think your response to my post doesn't help you. Its perfectly possible that I'm reading too much into this, like I did with RSD, though.

As for my vote on Xiz, it really bothers me that he's doing everything that I am. Its one of those "it makes too much sense" situations.

[cedolad]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

And now I'm off to work, g'day chaps

[Xiz]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

There's not much more I can really give to the group besides the thoughts mostly nobody has agreed with:


- Make sure there is no seer overlapping somehow. Figure out a damn way.
- I feel funny about Tokzic. I can't put my finger on it. Don't let him slide away. (If anyone cares I'll go more in depth of my thoughts on him)
- I'm realizing more and more how much I'm making myself look like a master wolf lmfao. This is actually kinda how I MIGHT play my master wolf game. I dunno, I change up shit alot.
- Delaying the phase isn't worth it. If you sign up for this game you should be able to participate. If you don't post after the 2nd day, then really look into them. (And I don't mean fluff posts, like actual thought posts that blame / bring out new thoughts instead of posts that people have said in the past)

[Charu]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

This feels like a repeat of last game, except this time I'm not the one voting for Xiz, haha.

I'm hesitant with voting for Xiz this time, because he was exactly like this last game with the same goal in mind. Except this time it might not be as beneficial to be seered because, well... no one will know except for the people that seered you and no outside alliance so they can't come talk to you privately.

Could be a master wolf trying to get that green seer going, or could be just your every day joe trying to clear himself from the getgo from the seer.

Possibilities are there, but there's really nothing we can go by. Lynching him now would be sort of not beneficial I think considering we have the option as well to not lynch anyone on any given day if we spread our votes.

...I think that's how the voting thing can go about, right?

Speaking of that, I say if we don't have any leads by the end of today, we SHOULDN'T vote for lynch, but instead, spread our votes wide.

[Charu]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

Actually, have a plan I guess, feel free to yell at me.

Why not spread our votes so everyone has one vote, yeah? If the wolves want to lynch someone, they would have to vote for that one person.

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

FINALLY, SOMETHING WE CAN DISAGREE ON, THANK YOU

We do NOT need to focus on the seering right now. There is VERY LITTLE chance that there will be an overlap. We need to focus on catching the wolves. And yeah, you're kinda looking like the master wolf, figured you were doing that on purpose to get seered, interesting that you're implying that you're just now realizing it. And yeah, go more in depth into toxzicoeiryuewrhwjer, wanna see if you and I have the same idea about him.

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

I see the thought behind that Charu, but losing a human this early isn't really *too* bad. We might hit a blue, and that would suck, but the odds are more likely that we'll hit a wolf. Odds are more likely than that that we'll hit a human, but this isn't a game of odds. If I'm in the minority here, I agree that its not the worst idea in the world, but we should be trying to get a wolf D1. Maybe we just need to do what worked really well last game where each person posts an analysis of each player, with who they think is red, who they're not sure about, and who they think is green and at least an accompanying sentence as to why they feel that that person is suspicious/not suspicious.

[Charu]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

Hitting a wolf day one will pretty much need a huge contradiction this early like last game. I haven't really seen that many contradictions except for some stunts and some minor errors in some posts.

True, not bad lynching a green this early either (not that we would know), but I would rather keep a green if the game allows it. It's my "conserve ammo" mentality I have, dohoho.

[Xiz]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

My argument against Tokzic really doesn't tread much water, but this is what really stood out to me:

Think about it. If someone's suspicious enough to be double-targetted, both Seers having a green result on that person isn't actually useless information. There's a Master Wolf in the game - if someone is seered green but mysteriously lives until late game and everyone finds them suspicious, either they're the MW or the Seer has a useful point of reference for understanding player relationships.

I just... don't... get this. I mean yeah its not completely useless information, but I still really feel that the more people that get seer'd the better, before one of them dies.

My argument against this would be in the scenario where somehow a seer finds 2 reds, then that's the time they should come out to the thread. Better that happen sooner then later.

Also keep in mind everything he has said has been an echo of YoshL. He has been targeting me, which i'm cool with. But he hasn't brought anything really new to the table at all this game (so far).

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

I didn't understand that particular snippet either, as anyone who survives to late is suspicious for their own reasons. Its far more likely that a person is actually a green, than the master wolf.

As for the lynching, I doubt the wolves are any closer to finding a good lynch candidate than we are. I don't think that we have a "bad" lynch at this point. In fact, if I had to make my list right now, basically one or two of you would be green. Most of you would be ? marks.

[YoshL]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

I would rather keep a green if the game allows it. It's my "conserve ammo" mentality I have, dohoho.

quote: fictionjunction: "stop caring so much"

you can't lynch properly if you don't have any information to go off of. Making a lynch is super if killing that person reveals connections.

The bottom line is WE DONT GET CONNECTIONS FROM LYNCHING PEOPLE

which again, is why i'm saying, sever the weak connections so we don't need to worry about them. It'll give us a better chance in the end rather than blindly picking (restating myself)

The way we'll get connections is through seering people. We have 2 seers, hopefully both still alive. One seering has happened so far, the other one is taking place for this day phase.

T-forc3 where you at