TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

[Krauthammer]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

Hey, when you were saying you liked ti sit back and absorb information you really meant it! That is a nice suspicion list.

Alright, after aaaaaaaaaaaall this waiting for BDN, he actually brought a few good points here. I had actually brushed them as...well, musings in the wrong direction, but I'm now seeing them into a new light.

Riot

[pntballa18]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

What's up with this RiotPolice thing? A brand new player makes bad posts and uses logic that makes no sense, how is that role specific? If this was day 1 and the only thing we had to go on was how people word their posts and their shitty/not so shitty plans, I'd probably be down for a RiotPolice lynch. But this is Day 2 and we have behaviors and reactions to specific situations to make our judgements on.

Specifically, I'll explain my vote for thesunfan.

The first red flag was you pushing YoshL to reveal whatever secret he was holding before he was ready to. Never did you (publicly) consider that he could be a blue, and that there were very good reasons for him to not reveal that information right away. He becomes suspicious of you, and after he is killed you become the lead detective on the YoshL murder case. In post 729 you say that YoshL was CLEARLY killed because he suspected inactives, honestly that doesn't sound like a good motive to me because being inactive draws suspicion in every game, that ideology isn't specific to YoshL. Before he was killed he was more suspicious of you than inactive players, anyways. But that's not a topic of discussion because lol case closed guys YoshL was clearly killed because he solved the ancient riddle of inactive players being suspicious players.

Also, in a recent post you say that telling the enforcer/inspector not to seer you was just a joke. It's post 565 if anyone wants to see if they get the humor, but here is the specific line: "A final reminder; PLEASE DON'T SEER ME, ITS A WASTE OF A SEER..."

Maybe I just don't get it.

[Charu]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

Hmm... someone soft defending Riot but this time going after sunfan who also soft defended Riot.

sunfan wanted to be casted suspicious for some reason. Or stated as such after someone casted a vote on him.

...Da fuck?

[mellonxcollie]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

but how do we do that, do you propose?

The way I see it, we have three options:
pressuring them with votes
seers coming out with results (this is risky tho)
just asking questions to specific people to prompt them to answer?

Is out of thread talking allowed to remind people to post?

[Charu]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

No, out of thread talking isn't allowed in this game.

[mellonxcollie]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

Also still working on my big post. I was planning on reading the whole thread and giving thoughts on everything but I think it's too difficult. Gonna work on simplifying my big post down a bit and making a suspicion list.

Now for my third suggestion, I guess I will start things off. I have explained myself and my play style several times now so now it's time for you guys to do the same so we can get a better read on you!

JWCGATOR: where are you? why have you been flying under the radar for basically this entire game? Do you feel that the rest of the players know enough about you this game to make a judgement on you? What are some reads that you have as basically an outsider?

TOKZIC: why have you been making so little posts? and why are the posts you do make so aggressive in tone? What are your read this game?

RSD: where have you been, and why are you hesitant to say anything substantial? You seem to show up and then quickly leave without saying much, do you have any reads you'd like to share?

KRAUT: how come after being relatively inactive, as soon as you show up you start targeting RP? Do you have any other suspicions/thoughts about other players too, or RP's possible teammates if you truly believe he is a wolf?

Now that I've addressed some people individually I hope that will prompt them to post more. POST MORE GUYS!!!

[mellonxcollie]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

No, out of thread talking isn't allowed in this game.

Right... we're not allowed to talk about the game. I don't think a "play twg!" facebook message constitutes talking about the game. I guess it's up to Silvuh to decide!

[mellonxcollie]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

What's up with this RiotPolice thing? A brand new player makes bad posts and uses logic that makes no sense, how is that role specific? If this was day 1 and the only thing we had to go on was how people word their posts and their shitty/not so shitty plans, I'd probably be down for a RiotPolice lynch. But this is Day 2 and we have behaviors and reactions to specific situations to make our judgements on.

I feel like I need to state this again. Different people have different play styles. Just because something would be suspicious for one player does not mean that it is suspicious for all players, because we need to take their individuality into account. Given that RP has never played TWG before, I do not see his posts as being as suspicious as I would if they had been posted by a different player, because I am taking his specific circumstance into account. RP is a new player. Of course he is going to mess up a few times and say weird things.

Do I agree that he is suspicious? Yes. Do I think that his posts are suspicious enough to warrant a bandwagon vote on him? No.

I do not see a problem with putting a bit of pressure on him right now though so that he can further explain what he is talking about, so I do understand the votes.

[Silvuh]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

5-7 Vote Requirement
Riotpolice (4) - Xiz, BDN, Tokzic, Krauthammer
BDN (2) - thesunfan, T-Force
thesunfan (1) - pntballa18
pntballa18 (1) - Cedolad
mellonxcollie (0) - Xiz, thesunfan
Krauthammer (0) - Xiz
T-Force (0) - thesunfan
jwcgator (0) - Tokzic

Yet to Vote
runescapedude1126, jwcgator, Charu, mellonxcollie, Riotpolice

Xiz >> mellonxcollie
thesunfan >> mellonxcollie
Xiz >> Krauthammer
Xiz >> Riotpolice
thesunfan >> T-Force
pntballa18 >> thesunfan
BDN >> Riotpolice
thesunfan >> BDN
Tokzic >> jwcgator
cedolad >> pntballa18
Tokzic >> Riotpolice
T-Force >> BDN
Krauthammer >> Riotpolice

Activity Messages
Because you're not discussing the content of the game, just telling someone to post more should be okay, so I will allow it. For total neutrality, I should be the one to message people about posting more, but I don't want to bother people when they know what they're doing. If anyone else wants to bother people, go ahead.

[Xiz]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

Rakeo, I'm glad you have been suddenly making a lot of posts and you are now putting a lot of thought into your posts.

......bbuuutttt

After a few of us started calling her out, don't you think she might be trying a bit too hard to look green? She has made quite the sudden change in her posts after being called out....

[Charu]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

That's a fair point, but I think with how she's playing, this doesn't look too suspicious... yet. She could be doing this because of knowing there needs to be some incentive and so is trying to have us move forward.

...I'm instantly reminded of Svaz's game again, dohoho. She was, if not exactly, very similar to her posting style.

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

Xiz, I swear if you weren't older then me and ugly as shit I would say we're identical twins.
mellon

[mellonxcollie]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

So not posting is suspicious, and posting is suspicious... right. I think you guys have major tunnel-vision this game. I'd still encourage you all to judge people based on the content of their posts, not their posting habits.

I was being criticized for not voicing my opinions enough and trying to blend into the background. I'm trying to make an effort, I'm not sure what you want from me?

[Charu]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

...Interesting...

Are you voting like this on purpose or something? You seem hellbent on making yourself suspicious suddenly. Why place a vote when all she was doing was giving incentive input?

Why do you want this suspicion? I don't understand the reasoning.

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CIII: New Players Welcome

I am judging you from the content of your posts, Martin Luther King, not the quantity of posts you make. You look like you're trying awkwardly to appear green to both Xiz (at least apparently) and myself. This fast reaction kind of assures me otherwise, though. But keep the info going.