Re: TWG CLVI: The Grand TWGabout - GAME THREAD
I guess I'll go over xelnya, I think it's mostly going to be looking at his big post
I said earlier this reminds me of the boats game where he said a similar soft defense of me and was a wolf. but sunfan also pointed out that xelnya didn't know his partners that game, so it's not a good comparison. That said, somehow it still makes me feel uneasy, except for the fact that he talked at length about it in his big post which makes me think it's less likely to be an easy pocket attempt
side note: I like this post because I agree that at this point there was a lot to go through and xel saying that shows that he's trying to keep track of what's happening this game
The first thing to note here is that xel noticed the same thing that charu did, which I think is good because he's trying to figure out reasoning behind people's votes. I think wolf xel would be more likely to make a shitpost about jake's early vote on me and leave it alone instead of hunting for the reason behind it. admittedly the series of posts looks like a blatant contradiction but hopefully it makes more sense after you realize that I was thinking of the boats game where xiz was both wolf and hit xel early on (as another wolf)
his response to charu saying he had an 800 word essay about how dumb my post was is also good because again, xel doesn't seem to be taking the easy way out
the next part with really big words I actually disagree with somewhat. I agree that it's odd that xiz didn't push indheart more for seemingly sheeping his vote, but I disagree that indheart can't think my play is weird because it's his first game with me. That being said, these two posts sum up what I thought about indheart's justification for voting me
ok it's not actually that obvious but I didn't buy it and I still don't, his vote isn't on me atm though
this post that xel pointed out actually makes me think of two things
1. he's basically saying "until I see a towntell I'm going to keep you open as an option"
or much worse,
2. "if you don't do xyz I'll lynch you"
it seems more like 1 but the potential for 2 is there, which is pretty much what xiz did as a wolf in the turbo game. I think it's not pressing right now though and that it can be left for later. also the fact that I think xiz is town makes it even less worrisome
the part where xel says in response to gradiant that my posts are pretty standard: I'm pretty sure gradiant just doesn't like how I post, because as I said pretty much every game we've played together he's disliked how I word posts/my interpretations, so I don't think it's that noteworthy
he ends with a vote on xiz which makes sense given how his post went, so I'm ok with that
I like this post because as yoshl pointed out, MML basically takes away none of the main points that xel talked about and instead hones in on the small yoshl part. xel rightfully calls him out on it, seems like a town wanting to make sure that people don't misconstrue his post or cherry pick out what they want from it
oh shit actually completely missed xel's big spoilered post
, which in the interest of readability I'm linking
I like how he revises his read of xiz a little bit after reading xiz's large post. It seems like an easy takeaway given that most people seem to have liked that post, but I think from where xel was at with xiz it would have been plausible for him to dismiss it and stick with his strong scumread on xiz. he also actually gives examples of what he likes which is a +
ok, the point where xel points out MML's post where he says he's voting on DBP and blatantly said he's piggybacking is good because MML's vote there is disgusting
don't have much to say about the rest of his post but it's fine
and finally, I thought his defense against zenith's read on him was good enough, especially since I disagree with the zenith meta-read. I think xel shitposting less is actually more towny because that usually means he's putting in work, and he also points out how zenith's read is purely meta when at this point in time there were xel's two big posts to look at as a starting point
conclusion: xel pretty solidly town
I guess I'll go over xelnya, I think it's mostly going to be looking at his big post
First off: Other shit:
Cute post. For a shit post this doesn't smell like shit.
Eh?
wth the fuck
I wanna speculate this post was serious for a moment, but what is kinda wrong with this?
Wait are you referencing this:
Because if so, this post is so dumb wtfh?
Ok, but like rly? This is a hella stretch? The fuck ARE these posts?
No, leave them in the dark obv. And yes, packback enters a game and usually doesn't post in a foreign language and with fucking images, and make a joke at the host.
Now the AA thing
this is really dumb like
This is funny as a shit post I guess.
Eh? Is this because of:
alright nice vibes here fam.
Nice vibes.
Alright.
Wait what?
I actually don't agree with this pov at all. The question's answer can be inferred yes, but what's wrong with getting a player to state it? On top of that it could lead into an actual explanation of the process and point of view? Like, really, the hell is this?
But no really, the hell is xiz this game?
FOR WHAT FUCKING REASON?!
What. The. Actual. Fuck. Is you letting him off with this shit?
Like I feel I get what you're going for a decent amount of the time with your witholding of information and seeminly random questioning and such, but what precisely is the reason you don't hound him for blatantly piggybacking a vote?
On top of THAT InDheart has literally no actual reason to vote AA because you can't say his play is weird, then immediatly retract the statement with " it's my first game here and i'm not familiar with his play style yet."
Like what the actual fuck mate.
Like fuck let's look at some fucking good aa posts
Like, how is anyone fucking not unvoting him here. He's fucking murdering you guys, espeically when you're letting InDheart fucking walk away with some of the most shite logic.
After the posts I've just reread, I genuinely sit here debating if you've magically fallen face first into the ground really goddamned hard.
I disagree, you should be on the goddamned table, are you fucking kidding me.
Those posts are rly standard aa tho? Like especially recently?
-- end of aa thing --
It's NOT a real catch though
just feels like an error filled shite post.
Most scummy aa post all game guys
Eh?
Eh?
Anyways
Xiz
I don't have a fucking clue why your play reads like shite to me this game. You're clearly doing something, but I don't get it, and I don't understand anything you're trying other than a badly executed reaction grab.
Would also be worth looking you know, maybe into inDheart as well because even with my lack of anything there's less of it than there is there.
Cute post. For a shit post this doesn't smell like shit.
Eh?
wth the fuck
I wanna speculate this post was serious for a moment, but what is kinda wrong with this?
Wait are you referencing this:
Because if so, this post is so dumb wtfh?
Ok, but like rly? This is a hella stretch? The fuck ARE these posts?
No, leave them in the dark obv. And yes, packback enters a game and usually doesn't post in a foreign language and with fucking images, and make a joke at the host.
Now the AA thing
this is really dumb like
This is funny as a shit post I guess.
Eh? Is this because of:
alright nice vibes here fam.
Nice vibes.
Alright.
Wait what?
I actually don't agree with this pov at all. The question's answer can be inferred yes, but what's wrong with getting a player to state it? On top of that it could lead into an actual explanation of the process and point of view? Like, really, the hell is this?
But no really, the hell is xiz this game?
FOR WHAT FUCKING REASON?!
What. The. Actual. Fuck. Is you letting him off with this shit?
Like I feel I get what you're going for a decent amount of the time with your witholding of information and seeminly random questioning and such, but what precisely is the reason you don't hound him for blatantly piggybacking a vote?
On top of THAT InDheart has literally no actual reason to vote AA because you can't say his play is weird, then immediatly retract the statement with " it's my first game here and i'm not familiar with his play style yet."
Like what the actual fuck mate.
Like fuck let's look at some fucking good aa posts
Like, how is anyone fucking not unvoting him here. He's fucking murdering you guys, espeically when you're letting InDheart fucking walk away with some of the most shite logic.
After the posts I've just reread, I genuinely sit here debating if you've magically fallen face first into the ground really goddamned hard.
I disagree, you should be on the goddamned table, are you fucking kidding me.
Those posts are rly standard aa tho? Like especially recently?
-- end of aa thing --
It's NOT a real catch though
just feels like an error filled shite post.
Most scummy aa post all game guys
Eh?
Eh?
Anyways
Xiz
I don't have a fucking clue why your play reads like shite to me this game. You're clearly doing something, but I don't get it, and I don't understand anything you're trying other than a badly executed reaction grab.
Would also be worth looking you know, maybe into inDheart as well because even with my lack of anything there's less of it than there is there.
his response to charu saying he had an 800 word essay about how dumb my post was is also good because again, xel doesn't seem to be taking the easy way out
the next part with really big words I actually disagree with somewhat. I agree that it's odd that xiz didn't push indheart more for seemingly sheeping his vote, but I disagree that indheart can't think my play is weird because it's his first game with me. That being said, these two posts sum up what I thought about indheart's justification for voting me
1. he's basically saying "until I see a towntell I'm going to keep you open as an option"
or much worse,
2. "if you don't do xyz I'll lynch you"
it seems more like 1 but the potential for 2 is there, which is pretty much what xiz did as a wolf in the turbo game. I think it's not pressing right now though and that it can be left for later. also the fact that I think xiz is town makes it even less worrisome
the part where xel says in response to gradiant that my posts are pretty standard: I'm pretty sure gradiant just doesn't like how I post, because as I said pretty much every game we've played together he's disliked how I word posts/my interpretations, so I don't think it's that noteworthy
he ends with a vote on xiz which makes sense given how his post went, so I'm ok with that
I like this post because as yoshl pointed out, MML basically takes away none of the main points that xel talked about and instead hones in on the small yoshl part. xel rightfully calls him out on it, seems like a town wanting to make sure that people don't misconstrue his post or cherry pick out what they want from it
oh shit actually completely missed xel's big spoilered post
, which in the interest of readability I'm linking
I like how he revises his read of xiz a little bit after reading xiz's large post. It seems like an easy takeaway given that most people seem to have liked that post, but I think from where xel was at with xiz it would have been plausible for him to dismiss it and stick with his strong scumread on xiz. he also actually gives examples of what he likes which is a +
ok, the point where xel points out MML's post where he says he's voting on DBP and blatantly said he's piggybacking is good because MML's vote there is disgusting
don't have much to say about the rest of his post but it's fine
You're certainly over meta-reading me because while you talk about how much I've posted in terms of overall, shit, and contentful posting, you based your read purely on a perceived meta. Not based on anything I've said.
Which is why I outright disagree with your read on me.
I'm not gonna answer if I've changed style because coming from me, that's super subjective.
Which is why I outright disagree with your read on me.
I'm not gonna answer if I've changed style because coming from me, that's super subjective.
conclusion: xel pretty solidly town
Comment