TWG XXXVII

[Afrobean]

Re: TWG XXXVII

rofl

I would say it's best for no one to be resurrected unless it's obvious that they were human before.

This includes Talisman last night. Don't ressurect him, because if he was a wolf, that would be exactly what I'd expect him to do. Yeah, I know, it'd have happened the same way if he was human too, but who cares.

Honestly, I'd say guard powers are better used protecting an alliance head than bringing back random people.

EDIT: by "alliance head" I mean that I want to see a seer come out. Unless it gets to be end of day, then any seer coming out is probably wolf faking it.

[sertman]

Re: TWG XXXVII

However, we don't know if theres a guardian or not...

[Afrobean]

Re: TWG XXXVII

There's definitely a guardian.

[sertman]

Re: TWG XXXVII

How would you know this?

[Kilgamayan]

Re: TWG XXXVII

Because he's the goddamn Batman.

[Afrobean]

Re: TWG XXXVII

Based on things I've asked Stoic, I'd say it would be near impossible for there to not be a time travel guardian (also consider that ressurrection of dead players is a corner stone of the game).

[Wilkin]

Re: TWG XXXVII

Lezzgo:

1) Talisman. A standard Night 1 kill in my opinion, due to his experience and reputation. It'd be quite a gamble as a self-wolfing, since the only real way to resurrect them is for a time-travel guardian to act (I'll elaborate in a bit on this). Though anything is possible this game, I wouldn't worry too much about Talisman's alignment if he does come back.

2) Time travel. Stoic said that there would be at least one time travel wolf in this game. If Talisman and any others get a backdated guard, the wolves finding the guardian (which we can pretty much all agree exists by this point) could time travel back and kill him Night 1 and undo everything he's done the entire game. Of course, this all depends on the wolves finding the guardian, the guardian actually having time travel powers (as opposed to a blue completely devoted to time travel), etc. This completely complicated scenario leads into my next subject:

3) Time travel wtf. No time travel in this game is safe. Any wolf who goes back and does an alternate kill could risk getting killed themselves, just like a guardian saving someone, and getting subsequently lynched due to mulitple votes sent in. Thus said, I think we should all come to an agreement about posting all of our numbered votes, or PMing the second and third to Stoic.

I'm interested in everyone else's views on these subjects, as well.

[sertman]

Re: TWG XXXVII

I was thinking about this too. It's to our advantage that the wolves don't know ALL of our votes, but in order to prevent the wolves from bandwagoning easily by just PMing the votes, your idea is what we should do.

[iggymatrixcounter]

Re: TWG XXXVII

Well if you do send votes to stoic, send them to me too if you trust me. That way I can better plan where things go and happen.

[Afrobean]

Re: TWG XXXVII

ugh you ****ing people

Wilkin says we should give INSANELY VALUABLE INFO to the wolves.

IT DOESN'T AID THE HUMANS AT ALL TO KNOW WHO WOULD BE LYNCHED IN PLACE IF A LYNCH IS CHANGED. IT ONLY ALLOWS THE WOLVES TO PLAN THEIR TIME TRAVELINGS SO THAT CERTAIN PEOPLE GET LYNCHED.

Although, I suppose, even with us all posting our choices, the wolves still wouldn't have the whole picture. There are the votes of dead players to account for. YOUR PLAN IS USELESS, WILKIN.

[sertman]

Re: TWG XXXVII

uh where in his plan does it say that the wolves get any type of valuable info

[Afrobean]

Re: TWG XXXVII

It let's them know who the second choice for lynch is. That is massive.

[sertman]

Re: TWG XXXVII

Oh wow I completely misread his post... i read it as "...only posting our first numbered vote, and then pming the second and third to stoic"

Yeah that's bad wilkin

[Wilkin]

Re: TWG XXXVII

I was just saying that since Stoic said we could do either in the original thread, we should agree on which method to take (or mix them for strategic purposes). I wasn't condoning either method specifically.

[Afrobean]

Re: TWG XXXVII

Well you shouldn't have even mentioned posting them openly. That's such a blatently stupid idea, there shouldn't even be discussion to it.