Re: TWGXLIII: Finish the Fight
So apparently I'm playing this game, so here goes.
I think stoic was wolf based solely on his posts. Several made him just jump out as wolf especially his posts regarding talisman. Lynching stoic seems like it was a good idea even if it was accomplished with KitB.
Stella! seemed quite human to me and when I read that she was vigi'd I was surprised. pntballa seems legit but quite a bit misguided. Killing stella! was a mistake considering that better choices that could have been made. I agree here with Tps, that the vigi really shouldn't live up to their name in that rather than being a vigilante in their choice, they should seek consensus, especially among the more experienced players.
As I read through the thread mead stood out as quite wolfy before pntballa posted his seering. At the start of his posts he was already trying to excuse himself from acts he had not committed yet. He acted as the game were overwhelming him and the only way to get a vote in was to go for a safety. Again he made excuses for himself that were unnecessary. His vote justification was weak. I saw more than that, but that's enough for me to put my vote on him. Oh yeah, he was seered red.
Because I believe mead is a wolf, I likewise believe that pntballa is legitimate (at least not a wolf).
In a similar manner to mead, Fojar stood out a little with some wolfish behavior. Nothing to lynch him over, but worth noting.
Fish seems very wolfish. His supposed panic over our need to find wolves and his emphasis on lynching mead immediately play right into what I know to be his wolf style. He does a good job as a wolf, but I think his giveaway is that he jumps on things that support the human cause if they seem to be headed that way anyway. Not to mention his overblown reaction to stella. Since mead was seered red and it seems most people trust pntballa, you can't go wrong supporting mead's lynching. However it struck me as odd that despite the push on the vote, fish did not actually bold mead's name.
As far as Chromer is concerned, I don't know yet. I'm looking into it but my initial feeling was that he was a wolf however there's a lot to piece together and I haven't taken the time to think it through.
Going forward, I do think it is important to make the right lynches because wolf numbers started at 5. Hopefully at this point, we've gotten at least one (stoic?).
Theories aplenty, correct me if I’m wrong. I've got notions on other people, but I need time to develop them. I don’t intend on getting another phantom, and if you want to talk to me on AIM I’ll be around.
So apparently I'm playing this game, so here goes.
I think stoic was wolf based solely on his posts. Several made him just jump out as wolf especially his posts regarding talisman. Lynching stoic seems like it was a good idea even if it was accomplished with KitB.
Stella! seemed quite human to me and when I read that she was vigi'd I was surprised. pntballa seems legit but quite a bit misguided. Killing stella! was a mistake considering that better choices that could have been made. I agree here with Tps, that the vigi really shouldn't live up to their name in that rather than being a vigilante in their choice, they should seek consensus, especially among the more experienced players.
As I read through the thread mead stood out as quite wolfy before pntballa posted his seering. At the start of his posts he was already trying to excuse himself from acts he had not committed yet. He acted as the game were overwhelming him and the only way to get a vote in was to go for a safety. Again he made excuses for himself that were unnecessary. His vote justification was weak. I saw more than that, but that's enough for me to put my vote on him. Oh yeah, he was seered red.
Because I believe mead is a wolf, I likewise believe that pntballa is legitimate (at least not a wolf).
In a similar manner to mead, Fojar stood out a little with some wolfish behavior. Nothing to lynch him over, but worth noting.
Fish seems very wolfish. His supposed panic over our need to find wolves and his emphasis on lynching mead immediately play right into what I know to be his wolf style. He does a good job as a wolf, but I think his giveaway is that he jumps on things that support the human cause if they seem to be headed that way anyway. Not to mention his overblown reaction to stella. Since mead was seered red and it seems most people trust pntballa, you can't go wrong supporting mead's lynching. However it struck me as odd that despite the push on the vote, fish did not actually bold mead's name.
As far as Chromer is concerned, I don't know yet. I'm looking into it but my initial feeling was that he was a wolf however there's a lot to piece together and I haven't taken the time to think it through.
Going forward, I do think it is important to make the right lynches because wolf numbers started at 5. Hopefully at this point, we've gotten at least one (stoic?).
Theories aplenty, correct me if I’m wrong. I've got notions on other people, but I need time to develop them. I don’t intend on getting another phantom, and if you want to talk to me on AIM I’ll be around.
Comment