I don't think any new evidence is going to come up:
Dooeyabillion (4:33:04 PM): so are you a wolf or not?
Halleys4th (3:33:42 PM): negative
Dooeyabillion (4:33:30 PM): ok, any proof?
Halleys4th (3:34:05 PM): can't prove a negative
Dooeyabillion (4:34:36 PM): ok, any reason to say you are ahuman that is abetter reason then pnts saying you are a wolf?
Halleys4th (3:35:28 PM): I was dicking around with pnt because we're buddies in rl
Halleys4th (3:35:39 PM): and he's trying to make it look like more than that
Halleys4th (3:35:48 PM): but there's not much else I can say
Halleys4th (3:35:55 PM): because that's all there was to it
Dooeyabillion (4:36:12 PM): coudnt you have figured out from jTWG [XXXVIII] that rl buddies means nothing? what with einherjar and that
Dooeyabillion (4:36:30 PM): otherwise, you were right about being screwed
Halleys4th (3:36:59 PM): you're annoying
Halleys4th (3:37:00 PM): go away
Dooeyabillion (4:36:44 PM): ok
Dooeyabillion (4:36:46 PM): bye
I was in a multiple-hour meeting today and suddenly I had a revelation! I wrote it down on a napkin so I wouldn't forget it, but it came out as a mangled, inky napkin. The inky blotches allowed me to remember, though!
I was somewhat suspicious of Pnt being a wolf before - I saw it as nearly certain that Halley was, but I was looking for some kind of plot for Pnt to gain our trust using Halley. A few of you probably remember me saying that maybe Pnt was the MW and was trying to be seered. If Pnt was a wolf, though, he wouldn't have given a wolf as a sacrifice because when a wolf is lynched, somebody gets a heart container, and if the wolf was insta'd, it would almost certainly be a human. Thus, while Pnt does seem like the type to try to use a sacrifice tactic, it wouldn't gain them enough. Think about it.
Wolf thief: Steals stuff. Very useful.
Two combining wolves: Only useful when together, thus sacrificing one wouldn't be worth it.
MW: Useful, as he seers green, gets extra rupees, AND doesn't take arrow damage.
I'm not saying that Pnt is 100% yes-he's-human, but I can't see any circumstance that would benefit the wolves from giving up another wolf. Unless I'm missing something?
Halley
Originally posted by MalReynolds
it just goes with what I said
what brought this country together?
desegregation
we need to segregate again so we can DEsegregate and everyone will feel good again
I'm thinking pnt isn't a wolf either, I had a convo with dooey about it earlier today. Pnt is mainly the only person I have been talking to, other than small convos with a few others. So I have had a lot of time to see if he slips up about anything. I am still suspicious of him, but only on a low level. I don't know who else to suspect other than halley right now, even though I am not thoroughly convinced of his wolfiness either.
That being said I am going to safety on dooey because I don't know what vote count we are at, and don't know if we want an insta or just a majority kill of halley. Someone let me know if an insta better benefits us, and then I will switch my vote.
Pro of an insta - a human could get the heart container
Con - a wolf could get the heart container
I say just let him go [he's at 5 votes and needs 8], and that way a human is most likely to get the heart, but a wolf doesn't have the chance to force insta and receive it.
Make sure you safety on somebody, though. No phantoms.
Originally posted by MalReynolds
it just goes with what I said
what brought this country together?
desegregation
we need to segregate again so we can DEsegregate and everyone will feel good again
Comment