Twg XXIX Postgame Wolves Win

[talisman]

Re: Twg Xxix Postgame Wolves Win

that is the point, because that's why it should at least be asterisked, in my opinion. What you did had nothing to do with it, it was what mead didn't do that affected the game. The question was slightly ambiguous, and that ambiguity should have been addressed.

Note that if the ambiguity HAD been addressed before the question was asked/answered, afro could have just said "I don't know" and still been telling the truth, and then tps wouldn't have known that he was a wolf and that would have been the end of that, wolves still probably would have won.

If you do count it, you have to asterisk it.

edit: addressed at blah, when I hit submit it did nothing til just a few seconds ago.

[stretchypanda]

Re: Twg Xxix Postgame Wolves Win

I'm not saying it shouldn't be asterisked, or go down as a contested game. I'm saying it shouldn't go off the record.

And, really, Blah's plan had a profound effect on the outcome of the game. I'm not saying the wolves wouldn't have won without it, but it definitely helped.

I'm really sort of confused by your use of the word "broken" to describe the game. The game should be recorded, regardless of the outcome. Blah's right -- learn from it and make a new rule. Don't pretend it didn't happen.

[talisman]

Re: Twg Xxix Postgame Wolves Win

I would agree to that compromise, mainly because I really don't give a **** about the SPREADSHEET or anything like that.

[HansSky]

Re: Twg Xxix Postgame Wolves Win

Tass does.

[Afrobean]

Re: Twg Xxix Postgame Wolves Win

It's obvious that Tass simply doesn't want it on his record of being lynched as a human.

I have no problem at throwing an asterisk on it, but I don't want it thrown out simply because the records keeper was lynched. That's just plain stupid.

[Tps222]

Re: Twg Xxix Postgame Wolves Win

Why does it matter if games count? It's not like it erases the game from the public mind. Blah's plan will be remembered. Stats mean ****, there isn't a hall of fame or anything. The only one who keeps them is Tass. They are a nice addition, but does a game counting or not really make any difference?

[stretchypanda]

Re: Twg Xxix Postgame Wolves Win

The issue I'm taking is with repeating the 29th game, rather than moving on to 30. I also like the history thread. It's a good reference for the game.

[nforcer06164]

Re: Twg Xxix Postgame Wolves Win

The different between this and Tribal & TWG XXII is that those games were AGREED to be won by 1 specific team, and therefore went into the records as such. No "cheating" of any kind happened in those games and they were both ended early because of things the host did.

Uh, no, Tass, not everyone agreed. That was you being bullheaded and thinking you were right. Take offense to that comment if you want, but keep in mind you're doing the same thing here.

Personally, I don't care anymore. The game was handled incorrectly, and there was some misinformation. You know what the best thing to do is? Make a compromise to set things straight.

The game was mishandled. So the records won't be full. Keep it as TWG XXIX. Everybody that was lynched/wolfed before the Afrobean questioning incident has the information go on their records.

For example: I was lynched on Night 1, and that was not a consequence of blah's strategy. It WILL go on my record. Tass's lynching was a consequence of blah's strategy. It WILL NOT go on his record.

blah will get his win as a consolation for his well-played strategy that simply worked through mere result of circumstance.

The game will be asterisked with an explanation of what happened. That way, we can all stop bitching and move on. IT'S A GAME. Give it up, and let's get on with XXX. I don't want to see a three-month hiatus of TWG because we all couldn't agree on such a trivial issue yet again.

[Afrobean]

Re: Twg Xxix Postgame Wolves Win

The issue I'm taking is with repeating the 29th game, rather than moving on to 30. I also like the history thread. It's a good reference for the game.

Same here.

[JurseyRider734]

Re: Twg Xxix Postgame Wolves Win

IMO this was as much a real game as any other. If what happened to Tass happened to anyone else, it wouldn't even matter and no one would be arguing.


Just shut the hell up and get over it. Start a new game. Christ.

[Tasselfoot]

Re: Twg Xxix Postgame Wolves Win

*shrugs* whatever. The next game can be XXX.

I'll put the info from the game in the history thread and mark it down in the spreadsheet with a yellow background (just like the other 2 are marked). The only different is that the game won't be entered for statistical purposes while the other two yellow marked games currently do count.

The events of this game are completely different than any other that has occured... trying to compare it to a past game is the same as comparing apples to oranges.

And I'd like to think that people WOULD be this worked up over the game if it had happened to someone other than me. Just so happens that these situations ONLY happen to me.

If the wolves want to make things easy... just wolf me night 1.

PS - Yes, I will continue to claim that I have only been lynched once as a human. I liked the analogy to the incorrect seer results that someone mentioned.


EDIT - Since we have a bunch of people banned... I was waiting until the weekend to start the game. Lent ends Sunday, so that is when Chardish will be back. He wants to play. I'll start the host signup thread Thurs or Fri, and Player signups will be Sunday. That cool with everyone?

[blahblah18]

Re: Twg Xxix Postgame Wolves Win

mark it as a win asshole or don't mark the others, they're identical and you ****ing know it

[Tasselfoot]

Re: Twg Xxix Postgame Wolves Win

I've explained in detail why they are different. The rest of TWC has already agreed with me, so don't blame me solely.

[Afrobean]

Re: Twg Xxix Postgame Wolves Win

Tass, of course you realize that it's this type of behavior that makes us all want to kill you, right?

Just don't be a jackass and we won't all want to cut your face off.

[Kilgamayan]

Re: Twg Xxix Postgame Wolves Win

lmao

Boy am I glad I got the hell out of here when I did.

People need to get the hell over themselves. I didn't complain when I got lynched even though it was up there with Afro's and Tass' in terms of stupidity, nor did I complain (at least not without recanting it) when Hans did the same several games ago. Buck up, there's always next game.