Re: jTWG XLVI: Chicago
All right. Here's what I think of sc: In the last night phase xplay came to me and said that he got a psychic counterclaim. One of them was sc. A detail he mentioned to me was that sc had said dorama came back as "not red". Now, I've talked to dooey about how this is handled, and he had said the psychic gets his reports by color. I've also talked to the other psychic, and s/he sounds like the real deal, after a lengthy discussion.
Here's my convo with xplayfan:
Another important detail is that sc chose not to come out to xplayfan after he got his "report" on trav, which was quite strange. It seems to me that the blues would want to ally and work together to win the game. Now, here's my convo with sc just now:
The important things to note here is that sc was incorrect on how the psychic gets his reports (by color instead of red/not red), and that the psychic also gets reports on the nightly kills as well. As such, I think that sc is a wolf.
All right. Here's what I think of sc: In the last night phase xplay came to me and said that he got a psychic counterclaim. One of them was sc. A detail he mentioned to me was that sc had said dorama came back as "not red". Now, I've talked to dooey about how this is handled, and he had said the psychic gets his reports by color. I've also talked to the other psychic, and s/he sounds like the real deal, after a lengthy discussion.
Here's my convo with xplayfan:
Code:
JONALEON1 (2:30:41 PM): hey DrKirth (2:32:24 PM): heya JONALEON1 (2:32:34 PM): i got a counterclaim for psychic -_- DrKirth (2:32:40 PM): eh what? JONALEON1 (2:33:54 PM): Both *edited* and sc said to me that they were psychic. DrKirth (2:34:16 PM): hmmmm DrKirth (2:34:26 PM): lemme check my logs with sc DrKirth (2:34:29 PM): something was fishy there DrKirth (2:34:41 PM): he slipped, and i found out he was blue, but maybe he was red instead [B]JONALEON1 (2:34:58 PM): *edited* came out to me first. after day 2. sc came out to me after day 3. DrKirth (2:35:48 PM): *edited* would make sense since he'd get trav's autopsy report[/B] JONALEON1 (2:36:55 PM): yeah, when sc told me he was psychic. he just said that dorama was not red. *edited* on the other hand told me that he was green. DrKirth (2:36:56 PM): yeah sc is blue or red, but that doesnt help much in this situation JONALEON1 (2:39:37 PM): i should ask dooey on how the psychic gets his results DrKirth (2:40:24 PM): hmm i don't know if that'd help much.. *edited* might have said green just because it wasn't red DrKirth (2:41:47 PM): i dont get why sc would wait to ally for another whole day JONALEON1 (2:42:19 PM): yeah that confuses me. he should've told me after day 2. DrKirth (2:42:59 PM): so both said dorama was human? JONALEON1 (2:43:04 PM): yup DrKirth (2:43:08 PM): bleh DrKirth (2:44:22 PM): well i gotta get to class DrKirth (2:44:29 PM): so be back sometime tonight JONALEON1 (2:44:34 PM): ok
Code:
Sam97379 (2:00:50 PM): hey DrKirth (2:00:56 PM): yo Sam97379 (2:01:03 PM): is there a reason you're voting for me DrKirth (2:01:10 PM): yeah DrKirth (2:01:33 PM): apparently you came out to xplay as the psychic, and in reality xplay already had a psychic come out before Sam97379 (2:01:42 PM): ?? DrKirth (2:01:50 PM): two psychics came out to xplay DrKirth (2:02:26 PM): at the moment, the other psychic claimer is more believable Sam97379 (2:02:34 PM): why DrKirth (2:02:57 PM): well, if you're the psychic, then what reports did you get on the other people, aside from dorama? Sam97379 (2:03:17 PM): trav was red Sam97379 (2:03:20 PM): dorama was not red [B]DrKirth (2:03:38 PM): how about lito, shadow, and xception Sam97379 (2:03:48 PM): i don't get those Sam97379 (2:04:05 PM): only from the lynchings DrKirth (2:04:36 PM): failure. the psychic gets reports from every death[/B] Sam97379 (2:04:43 PM): err Sam97379 (2:04:44 PM): I didn't Sam97379 (2:05:03 PM): and wtf [B]Sam97379 (2:05:10 PM): it's not like a wolf will wolf one of their own DrKirth (2:05:33 PM): so? maybe the psychic wants to know if the seer or guardian died Sam97379 (2:05:38 PM): ? Sam97379 (2:05:44 PM): I only get red/not red DrKirth (2:05:55 PM): failure. psychic gets reports by color, not red/not red[/B] Sam97379 (2:06:03 PM): no DrKirth (2:06:25 PM): don't bother talking out of this one. i confirmed this fact with dooey Sam97379 (2:06:43 PM): wtf DrKirth (2:07:17 PM): if you're going to fake a role, you might want to get your facts straight beforehand Sam97379 (2:07:25 PM): i'm not faking a role DrKirth (2:07:55 PM): mhmm Sam97379 (2:08:03 PM): ... DrKirth (2:08:33 PM): putting all that aside, why did you come out to xplay once you got dorama's report? Sam97379 (2:08:42 PM): because he came back not red Sam97379 (2:08:46 PM): that's important, isn't it? Sam97379 (2:08:55 PM): i would've kept my role to myself if he came back red DrKirth (2:08:56 PM): what about trav's report? Sam97379 (2:09:01 PM): he was red Sam97379 (2:09:10 PM): everyone knew already, so it didn't matter DrKirth (2:09:20 PM): so, it's not important to establish an alliance with the seer? Sam97379 (2:09:39 PM): not necessarily Sam97379 (2:10:05 PM): my role already leaked out to at least 2 people DrKirth (2:10:10 PM): i think anyone who played the game would do so DrKirth (2:10:43 PM): yeah, your role got leaked because of two psychic claims Sam97379 (2:11:21 PM): so I basically got screwed for waiting until after dorama's report to tell him? DrKirth (2:11:47 PM): that, and the fact you were incorrect about two aspects of the psychic role Sam97379 (2:12:01 PM): uhh Sam97379 (2:12:11 PM): i would know if i was wrong about that or not DrKirth (2:12:48 PM): *ahem* [URL="http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/vbz/showpost.php?p=2130961&postcount=36"]http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/vbz/showpost.php?p=2130961&postcount=36[/URL] Sam97379 (2:13:18 PM): ... Sam97379 (2:13:20 PM): i didn't Sam97379 (2:13:33 PM): and it doesn't make sense anyway DrKirth (2:13:53 PM): sure it does, because the psychic gets results by color, another detail you've overlooked Sam97379 (2:14:02 PM): no Sam97379 (2:14:07 PM): i've already said what i get DrKirth (2:14:35 PM): i forwarded to you on the forums the pm i sent to dooey and his response Sam97379 (2:15:11 PM): hmm Sam97379 (2:15:55 PM): i probably should talk to dooey about that
Comment