TWG CXLIII: SK Loses Again Game Thread

[_Zenith_]

Originally Posted by roundbox

Tinfoil implies that his wolf deductions are on highly townread players (to the point of sounding like a conspiracy, hence the name) after a long amount of time of them being townread. None of these players have been universally townread, and I'm not sure what you mean by "if you really read ymia's wolf reads list". Is there some other magical way I'm supposed to read this?



My post was partially examining ymia's reasoning in addition to factoring in your analysis of his reads. I would argue that the OMGUS part here is solely for the fact that ymia mentions that he was scumread (I think it was scum lean?) by AA in this post and mentions nothing of his read from you as well as YoshL.



I do think the breadcrumbing here is a good point, but ymia is concerned about lynch candidates here (both personal and thread-based). If he went straight on defensive, he would be chastised. Just take a look at what you said after rzr made his big post recently. You solidified your scumread of him since his post was, in your words, defensive. I need to take a look at it myself to see if I arrive to the same conclusion, but my point still stands. ymia was just looking into lynch candidates, three of which are who he believes to be wolf. He put the section on DaBackpack there to convince people to ignore him and focus on the three wolf reads he posted, since he sees DaBackpack as a wasted lynch.



What bad early post are you referring to? Haven't you and plop really been the only ones to say something about "this one post now being judged by multiple people"? Has someone else scrutinized my post about you and ymia?

*Insert YoshL fixing my terminology mistake* because I misused the word Tinfoil there. I should've used the vague word, shaky, to describe it because imo the thought process doesn't hold. Also, you're right about the last of the first section because of different perceptions of how we read posts, so I was basically trying to say "hopefully you can see the post a different way".

My response was also incorporating my own read on AA there, but I would counter-argue that ymia and I are against each other dominantly but with reason, as well as AA which you stated and I'm not sure if I reapplied the word omgus towards YoshL.

It seems extremely awkward though the inclusion of DBP here (you stated his name is frequently tossed around by multiple players). I know that is 10/10 breadcrumbing material that I strongly feel he'll use if he lives, but there is no need to state DBP there. You, Round, mentioned that he thinks DBP is a waste of a lynch; then why include him in a list of his suspicions?.

I'm referring to your setup post in which you mentioned "any post after this..." which imo gave off a weird vibe and it slapped you on some radars.