FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

[gnr61]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

huh, night and day didn't mess up for me/ferrari at all and neither did girls/boys/toys o___0
what freezes did you think were extraneous
since theres very little actual layering in the file what parts do you think could be represented better

[moches]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

60. Vanity - moches

1/5 *REJECTED*

for the most part- what the heck is this

huh

[xferrarix]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

i <3 npv reviews

ps i'm startin to judge nxt batch now~

[operationstrawbarry]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

@gnr's review: You are going to have to be a little more specific. If you referring to the jacks in the slow section, thats intentional. That part I would of thought was the obvious section to step. Other than that, Im not sure what other way to step it than the way it is now. Is there a problem with the way its stepped. I know you said that you aren't here to improve others stepfiles or their abilities, but here to tell people why their files are accepted and rejected and I respect that. But Im not sure where to even start with the revisions with such a vague review. No offense man. If possible, send me a PM wioth possible fixes, but thats at ur own discretion, but would help. Im trying to diciper ur review right now.

Edit: Im happy you didn't reject it for song choice though. LOL.

Like I said before, Im down to go all the way with the file. Just need more information in order to fix the file. Awaiting NPV's and Ferrari's notes. Maybe I will get a clue on what I should fix.

[Cherubi]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

the mines in hyperdrive are to make an elevator effect with the sound effect thats going on. if you played it on xmod you would see why. i put in the bubble noises because without them it was really boring

[Patashu]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

what is 'an elevator effect' that holds no meaning for me

edit: wait I think I get you from the context but the phrase you used is still pretty meaningless lol

oh and btw don't feel disillusioned if you don't get any files in the pack. it's harsh as ****

[moches]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

oh and btw don't feel disillusioned if you don't get any files in the pack. it's harsh as ****

I sort of agree with this

Like, I get that you guys want really really good files in here but it's not like we step so bad that every file that gets submitted gets a 1...

[Cherubi]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

patashu i can send you my file so you can see what i mean by elevator haha

[Patashu]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

I figured out what you meant from da :context: so that's okay

[gnr61]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

8th notes create jacks too you know. i suppose i can pm you with specific examples of what i mentioned but it's pretty straightforward. also for a song to be rejected for song choice alone it has to be genuinely so awful that i couldn't see how anyone could stand it. i have no problem accepting files for songs i don't like (which i have now several times), i'm just harder on the charts.

also even fewer people on this site play x-mod than index, i'm afraid. the mines will remain meaningless since no one will want to play x-mod just to see what you were trying to do in the beginning. also, if you find that your file would be exceedingly boring without stepping some incredibly subtle sound at 16th streams, you may need to find a new song.

and i realize this was a particularly rough batch of files; and you're right, they're not all 0s and 1s. the ratings (particularly npv's rageratings) are more or less immaterial so don't get too discouraged at those.

[Patashu]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

you can sort of play implied xmod by watching how the lifebar changes you know

[gnr61]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

and the mines will continue to rise in a uniform column nowhere near the desired effect 0.0

[moches]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

7. (npv) Dajoolggeh

Oh **** this is a Korean song

I love you npv

[operationstrawbarry]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

8th notes create jacks too you know. i suppose i can pm you with specific examples of what i mentioned but it's pretty straightforward. also for a song to be rejected for song choice alone it has to be genuinely so awful that i couldn't see how anyone could stand it. i have no problem accepting files for songs i don't like (which i have now several times), i'm just harder on the charts.

This was direted at me right? Im sure it is, but just wanted to know for sure. Going to respond to it like it is even though Im sure it was. I dont think Paranoia Revenge is a bad song choice. Hell, im actually stepping Paranoia Rebirth right now and its turning decent.

Like I said, Im willing to go all the way on this becaus as a Paranoia Fan, there hasn't been anything decent out there for the song series. But generally, anything I send to this pack or any pack, Ill go all the way with it. That will be the last time I mention this.

I seriously have nothing against ur review on my file. I was expecting things like this after the FFCP1, but I can only guess where you have a problem and I really dont want to send it a million times because I keep guessing wrong. If you can find time to send me specific examples, that would be great. I will work on those sections.

In regards to being harsher on the judgeing aspect, I kinda expected that. That doesn't bother me one bit. I just hate guessing. Example: Drop V9 or more to FFR.

[Glitz]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

paranoia rofl