Re: TWG CXXXVII - Crisis in Kitchen Stadium! Bobby Flay's Revenge - GAME THREAD
Updated Reads list. Likely will end up voting one of the top 3. Almost certainly will be voting one of the top 4/5. Right now I'm voting Sunfan because of all the players I put in my list he's the one I think that has the least pointing to him being human.
TheSunFan: This post and this post seem town to me. The rest of his game seems wolfy to me. He has a lot of posts, but who does he suspect? Roundbox I guess, but his vote's been pretty static so far.
Vendetta/Kawamii: Is hard to get a handle on. I have one game of human meta on her on a different site with different rules and whatever J-Rodd says about her wolf game. And depending on how I interpret that one game I have, it points in different directions. On one hand, she used the same intuition-based scumhunting technique she did last game, which is why I initially thought she was town. On the other, she was way less assertive. Last game she was telling people they were garbage TWG players or obvious scum because they didn't agree with her. She never got to that stage today. But it just doesn't make sense to me. She's been keeping up with the thread. If your only goal is to stay alive, why not post some reads when people ask you to? It didn't seem like the reaction she had was warranted even if she is a wolf. At the moment I've been thinking that maybe we should leave her alive to at least get Vendetta's thoughts if the slot's human.
J-Rodd: I've already been over this, but I really got a bad feeling about his Kawamii vote. I was fine with it as a reaction test, but I really didn't like the "Oh well I guess we're going to have to lynch Kawamii" vibe I got from this post. Other than that though, I've felt J-Rodd's play has been for the most part town. I really like the fact that he's operating by a POE system. It's pretty awkward as a wolf to use because it means you've got to defend all the people who are getting lynched who aren't your top suspects. I also think this post is on point. He's a really tough slot for me because he's probably the person with which I've mindmelded the most with the exception of a few posts about Kawamii/Vendetta that gave me a stronger initial bad gut feeling about him than I've had for any other player.
Roundbox: Nothing he's done is all that suspicious by itself, it's just that all the player slots he's gone after are ones I think or know are human.
Benguin: I know it's hard on the host but Benguin should probably be replaced following this phase.
Mashi: This is entirely a feeling thing. Mashi felt human to me when we were talking about C&R.
C&R: I think he's human. I feel like he tunnels a lot as town, and he gets lynched a lot for being both contrarian and not active enough to properly defend his contrarian-ness. He's being really contrarian this game.
choof/Zenith: I read choof/Zenith town early and I'm not deviating from that now. Out of the question today.
Updated Reads list. Likely will end up voting one of the top 3. Almost certainly will be voting one of the top 4/5. Right now I'm voting Sunfan because of all the players I put in my list he's the one I think that has the least pointing to him being human.
TheSunFan: This post and this post seem town to me. The rest of his game seems wolfy to me. He has a lot of posts, but who does he suspect? Roundbox I guess, but his vote's been pretty static so far.
Vendetta/Kawamii: Is hard to get a handle on. I have one game of human meta on her on a different site with different rules and whatever J-Rodd says about her wolf game. And depending on how I interpret that one game I have, it points in different directions. On one hand, she used the same intuition-based scumhunting technique she did last game, which is why I initially thought she was town. On the other, she was way less assertive. Last game she was telling people they were garbage TWG players or obvious scum because they didn't agree with her. She never got to that stage today. But it just doesn't make sense to me. She's been keeping up with the thread. If your only goal is to stay alive, why not post some reads when people ask you to? It didn't seem like the reaction she had was warranted even if she is a wolf. At the moment I've been thinking that maybe we should leave her alive to at least get Vendetta's thoughts if the slot's human.
J-Rodd: I've already been over this, but I really got a bad feeling about his Kawamii vote. I was fine with it as a reaction test, but I really didn't like the "Oh well I guess we're going to have to lynch Kawamii" vibe I got from this post. Other than that though, I've felt J-Rodd's play has been for the most part town. I really like the fact that he's operating by a POE system. It's pretty awkward as a wolf to use because it means you've got to defend all the people who are getting lynched who aren't your top suspects. I also think this post is on point. He's a really tough slot for me because he's probably the person with which I've mindmelded the most with the exception of a few posts about Kawamii/Vendetta that gave me a stronger initial bad gut feeling about him than I've had for any other player.
Roundbox: Nothing he's done is all that suspicious by itself, it's just that all the player slots he's gone after are ones I think or know are human.
Benguin: I know it's hard on the host but Benguin should probably be replaced following this phase.
Mashi: This is entirely a feeling thing. Mashi felt human to me when we were talking about C&R.
C&R: I think he's human. I feel like he tunnels a lot as town, and he gets lynched a lot for being both contrarian and not active enough to properly defend his contrarian-ness. He's being really contrarian this game.
choof/Zenith: I read choof/Zenith town early and I'm not deviating from that now. Out of the question today.
Comment