TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

[inDheart]

Re: TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

shado writing that post earlier is making me think about why roundbox wouldn't be roleblocked. mrr

we didn't talk peeks too much ahead of time though mml asked about coordinating something (which could be a leading question to see whether they would need to block haku)

i think they would not block roundbox just because the fake cop can carry kp and roundbox is probably not blocking between the cops to let them resolve

as for peeks mml is required to at least name someone today, because he can't be wolfblocked again and no one would believe him peeking roundbox lmao

blocking haku also makes it look like he's the one slowing things down now

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

Gotta solve things in order.

MML

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

My bad, I wrote my post assuming you already read that post.

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

I asked you what you would do if you were Haku here because I don't see how I could have given you information without people figuring out I'm real.

If I were Haku, I wouldn't have said "Honestly, I wonder if we have enough info from night actions to win by PoE already." unless I was planning on claiming, because I would've expected to have been asked to share what my winning PoE deductions were.

but the fact is, the timeline was:

Haku: "Honestly, I wonder if we have enough info from night actions to win by PoE already."

Haku: "ps: I have a green check on raeko this phase. Previous phase was Daikyi."

THEN me asking "Can you walk me through what info you got from the night actions? Without revealing your own role, if you are one." in response to the first post.


So if I were townHaku and I were asked by Shado "Can you walk me through what info you got from the night actions?" after I'd already shared my checks, I'd just quote my own "ps I have a green check" post right back at him with the finger pointing up emoji

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

I think I know which cop is lying, but wanna wait til claims come out bear with me

Thought this is what shado was going for with the waiting for checks but I guess not

Nah, what I had been thinking over the nightphase was how the wolves are playing a strategy seemingly consistent with the right mechanical moves, meaning they'd need one player on their team that's able to analyze setup and lead with a mechanical strategy to how they're gonna play and which roles to claim.

Outside the cop claims, I was trying to find the likeliest partner. That led me to thinking Raeko is almost always a wolf here. Even Roundbox had said he was changing his mind before he died. I had showed him how she was wolfy by his own criteria earlier on, but the factor that was missing was the "opportunistic timing of posts" and the fact that she wasn't dead last in postcount. Now, her posting is opportunistically UTR and near-nonexistent because mechanical lynches mean she's not in danger for at least this phase, AND she's dead last in postcount.

Problem is, I believe Raeko when she said she couldn't figure out setup or analyze game mechanically and had to rely on what other ppl told her.

Antori didn't seem hopelessly lost or anything, but also didn't seem like he had taken initiative, analyzed setup, and coached the scumteam on who should claim what and why.

which led me to the cop claims.

Haku had said last phase he was having a hard time with analyzing setup. It took an explanation from Daikyi to get him to clear it up well enough to vote Antori. I didn't see him being the scum playmaker either.

MML, on the other hand, seemed to have a good enough grasp of mechanics to be able to do exactly that. He was cognizant enough to soft in D0, so if that was fake then I def see him having the foresight to make those plays.


Basically, at the start of today, game summed up to "MML + Raeko!Godfather" likeliest but if MML flips town then I have a hard time seeing the "Antori/Haku/Raeko" team being able to figure out mechanics as well as they have

Wanted to see flips first so I wouldn't give anyone ideas

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

which struck me as odd given the night actions (deaths + MMLs checks) didn't come close to solving game in my eyes, so I wanted you to elaborate on how we could win by PoE.

Also, you claimed before I wrote that, so how am I forcing you to claim after the fact?

I asked you what you would do if you were Haku here because I don't see how I could have given you information without people figuring out I'm real.

[Gradiant]

Re: TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

Oh god I wish I could delete my own post. I realized too late it could inspire a whole ton of fake paranoia if he's wolfing

Nah, with how hakus been posting I don't see it. The check on mml is also something I could see coming from him. And I think a wolf haiku would have input from his team on a check that would look better than the other 'cop' that others would assume to be fake

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

Oh god I wish I could delete my own post. I realized too late it could inspire a whole ton of fake paranoia if he's wolfing

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

This paranoia actually feels towny coming from Haku. He's just directing it at the wrong person rn.

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

How would you answer that yourself ?

I wrote that before seeing your green checks. You can read my following post and see very obviously the difference in reaction once I actually saw your claim.

It was in response to this post:

Honestly, I wonder if we have enough info from night actions to win by PoE already.

which struck me as odd given the night actions (deaths + MMLs checks) didn't come close to solving game in my eyes, so I wanted you to elaborate on how we could win by PoE.

Also, you claimed before I wrote that, so how am I forcing you to claim after the fact?

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

because we have 7 players alive, even if we lynch the wrong cop first, we will get down to final 3.

Believe haku over mml, wolf roleblock would roleblock one of the cop claims there.

I think keeping these two lines of reasoning in mind leads to:

>Because fakeclaiming cop will get lynched guaranteed either this phase or next, wolves are required to block the real cop or reveal too much info to recover from
>If they knew this, though, then it wouldn't make sense for wolves to come out with a claimed check. They would claim No result and end up at a thunderdome with no additional mechanical info.
>Wolves would not care to block the real cop if the godfather is not the fakeclaiming cop. Either godfather has already been checked or godfather is in the unchecked (includes those checked by the fakecop) VTs.
>Wolves claiming to be blocked while letting the real cop out his check is then possible, as is claiming a check while blocking the real cop. This is pretty much WIFOM and reading too much into goes nowhere.


I think I have a better shot solving Haku than MML so that's where I'ma focus my reading. If anyone else thinks they have a good handle on either player, now's the time to ISO them and come to a conclusion. Despite the fakecop getting lynched either way, it'd help town's odds immensely if we do get it right the first time. I don't think we're ever lucky enough to have the fakeclaiming cop be the godfather given the claimed checks, unfortunately.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

Can you walk me through what info you got from the night actions? Without revealing your own role, if you are one.

How would you answer that yourself ?

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

Shado keep doing that thing where he answers for others when he should be sitting back and waiting for said person to answer.

Also didn't like how he kind of indirectly pushed me to claim.

It's like trying to control events to unfold a certain way when there's no reason to evaluate said event until it happens.

Ideally, I should have claimed one phase later.

Something's fishy here imo.

Excuse me?

Shado keep doing that thing where he answers for others when he should be sitting back and waiting for said person to answer.

Where do I do this? You literally asked me, "Why would I not check MML after Antori flip wolf ?"

I don't "answer questions for others". Period. I haven't done it once this game (including the comment on Gradiant's post early on). I'd love for you to quote me directly answering a question addressed to anyone other than myself. It doesn't happen.

I'll share my thoughts on stuff that I think is relevant, even if its an ongoing conversation, but it's a plain lie and misrepresentation of my play to say I answer questions for others. If you end up being town we can talk more about why weighing in on everything, even ongoing conversations, is a *GOOD* thing later on

Also didn't like how he kind of indirectly pushed me to claim.

It's like trying to control events to unfold a certain way when there's no reason to evaluate said event until it happens.

Ideally, I should have claimed one phase later.

MY MAN, YOU DID THAT ALL ON YOUR OWN.

You claimed two green checks right off the bat at a point when everyone had already broken cover in our reactions to MML's claim. My reaction was like "damn, forreal?" or something along those lines.

You saying "hypocop" at that point does NOT magically restore cover to you. If you felt you should've claimed one day later then you absolutely should've. But you can't have it both ways. So instead, I made the best of the situation where we had TWO outed cops and started a massclaim hoping that mechanics would lead to a wolf.

and GUESS WHAT? THEY DID. That is NOT "Shado indirectly pushed me to claim". It's more like "I claimed and then waffled with an impossible hypocop so Shado held me accountable by telling me to either confirm or retract and now I'm upset because I realized I should've claimed one day later".

[inDheart]

Re: TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

that also means antori literally asked me what i thought about the big post from the guy they might have thought was the cop to see if i was down with lynching him

yeah i like where this is going now

[inDheart]

Re: TWG CLXXXV: C9+++++++++ Game Thread

cf.

Booooo

Hey roundbox

let me ask you something

would you be down to lynch lar today

btw Antori this is how you wall post :]

1) Daikyi

Solid postu.

2) roundbox

I'm getting flashbacks on d1.

4) MixMasterLar

I like this post... about as much as I like waking up at 230 in the morning... But I can see how town lar would post this

but it really feels like you're seeing an oppertunity to suck up and taking it. BUT IN CONTEXT TO THE REST OF YOUR GAME It leaves me a tad torn on which interpretation appeals to me more



Hindsight here: I think star was having the same vibes I'm having on this reread. And I'm gonna sheep it a bit, that in context with the above quoted post, you are looking less townie to me right now, especially with her flip.





I smell the oppertunity from here and greatly wish I had addressed this on d0.



I feel like what happened was is that you either: A: Went along with your d0 lynchanomics of lynching a low post count. Or B: Used your lynchanomics to purpose two easy lynches that are easily awful because OH NO THEY NOT POSTING THEY NOT MEETING MY STANDARDS but it's typical d0 lar and it's really ytou trying to score an easy mislynch for wolfteam.

And I don't think I've read a game where this is the impression your lynchanomics has given me.

Now I really wanna take a moment to touch on something super important. In any other game, when you call someone out, and they outright defy you, you never let them slide. And other than a half assed "hey guys xel's a choice as well" you didn't even TOUCH me for outright shitting on you.

These posts:

Are disgustingly antagonistic. I'm literally laughing in your face, and you fucking hate that. Remember the part of this section where I mentioned a post that reads one of two ways? This section is why I lean to the second one. You *might* have gotten intimidated that I'd actually pick myself up to fight you and that'd throw off what you're doing openly.

There's no reason for you to have not dunked on me for these posts.

Especially when this post is in the game:



Where I actually spell it out so rudely, I'd even argue this post is fucking toxic, and I don't give two fucks about how rude you are in a game of twg. I only tame my shit because I genuinely can't be bothered for the aftermath of not doing so.



I was being so goddamned toxic there's NO EXCUSE to have not made mince meat of me, the hell you doing this game man, the narrative isn't that important!

ps as d1 starts you again don't even touch this shit.



YOU DON'T EVEN TOUCH IT.

NOT EVENNNNNNNN

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH



Hey FFA: ThISSss iS ThE NARaTivE at play he established.

NICE.

5) Gradiant

You make a good call out I mention later in the post, noting here as a positive for you.



I do like this because it's not "how much he cares" it's an actual trait we can talk about

how much I care or not is completely imparative to what I'd tell you, the only person who can fight that point is me, and that's just self-meta.

7) inDheart

I leik dis p0st

Also there's a back and forth between star and InD on page 5 I really like more on a reread with Star's flip.



oh, stop mindmelding with my actual read

jerk



Yikes.



See like

at least unlike a certain someone, you did you, boo.



Yesssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss

8) XelNya - AH

Ass hole.

9) flashflash account

this post sucks dicks



At the point of the game this post is located, it's gross. Even with your general d0 shitposting tone it's bad.



WHY THOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO



Rude. I disagree on Lar tho~ his tone is completely out there and if you say he's being nonsensical I'd argue that should be a red flag for lar.

10) Antori

I don't like this post.



Noting this spicy point out here and not in the gradiant pile



There is a way better point for you to be at in this point of the game. THIS feels like a pad vote.

Admittedly your posting in d1 has been better especially on page 32.

11) Hakulyte

Usually I skip Haku's posts because they're really wordy and he ends up getting lynched for something else.

I commented on day 1 with InD how I thought Haku was not playing a "I don't know how to wolf here" game and was playing a "I missed my chance to enter in my usual fassion" kind of game. This post is part of the why, and it's not so much because Haku said this I leaned that way, but it's how his play reflects this post that convinced me.



Unique Haku post here folks.

Also on Page 5 Haku has a bunch of shit posts that feel outta Haku place for me. Is that even a term?



This is probably your least likable post I've seen you make.

12) mellonxcollie

The cluster of posts at this point of this game are.. Not great.

Especially when later roundbox posts as shado put it a "rubric" of how she plays and if part of that is she's posting more frequently, it falls moot when there's posts like this at the juncture of the game it's at. (Earlier in the game would have been totally fine though. It's about the placement not the content here.)

Her posts do get kinda better as the day's going on, they're just not worth quoting.



This feels like a good post, but the second part of the post is... Questionable is the word I'd use. It tone wise leaves a bad mention in the back of the brain. But that's not indicitive.

13) ShadoWolfe

to be honest, I leik dis post because it was a mindmeld



on a reread I should like roundbox significantly less than I said I did. Roundboxes posts to me read better on d0 than they do d1. And Yoshl is that despite the curbing of toxicity he's posting in a way that takes him off the table but doesn't confirm to the town pile.

This got misplaced: Wolf and yoshl back and forth is pretty clean

Random thoughts at the end I wanna throw out there

1. It's very different to see roundbox play a passive role in a game. It'd look horrible if he was trying to assert something similar to yoshl / gradiant in trying to change something about their play.
2. I think this is the first game I have outright wanted to see lar get shot by a vigi, like right now.
3. I think Raeko should be on the table tomorrow, but there's CERTAINLY better choices for today.
4. Nightkilling Star was such a great kill. Her game was so on point and leaving her alone would have caused wolf team problems, but none of her reads really point me to one person I'd wanna see go for it.
5. Let's go on the votecount exploration.



I wanna theoryshit my thoughts on this:

1 Wolf is on WV
1 Wolf is on FFA
The last wolf is either on FFA or in the solo vote department

why? It feels from a wolf perspective this is the way the votes ought to be placed. Wolves have day chat..

I guess a where I be list.

1) Daikyi
2) roundbox
4) MixMasterLar
5) Gradiant
7) inDheart
9) flashflash account
10) Antori
11) Hakulyte
12) mellonxcollie
13) ShadoWolfe

Out of the greys I'd say mellon but I don't think she's posted enough to day to land in either pile, and the discussion is still going pretty good on it. I really like InD based on posts, and even with the progression but I'd want to see a hard push to sell myself.

Lar is a wolf in my eyes because his play doesn't feel authentic, it feels like it plays to a narrative, and he's dodged things and provocations in a way I don't think he usually does, especially when someone outright says come at me and he doesn't, particularly because of the context of where it happens in the game.

At the very least for now I am not entertaining a shado lynch.

Spoilering this because it ruins the rest of the post if it's in the open

lar

my head hurts

reminds me

lar

and yes I had to redo this

hey fuck face

their entire metaread of me is based on how interested I come off to be in the game

As in my entire read is based on if I appear to have "checked out"

swapping me for you would not be anywhere equivocal

As in lar literally was trying to peg me this game for it

Lar is a better lynch

Lynch lar with me

Thats what i need from you

Lar is a wolf

Twg whatevernumberthisgameisfuckinghellusenumbersalready

peep that colorized reads list