TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

[Turboyoshi]

Re: TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

no, that's not what i'm saying. all i'm saying is that just because freaky claims he's the wolfsbane is no reason to immediately assume that he's a wolf. I'm saying we shouldn't jump to conclusions to quickly, because if we do lynch him, and he actually is the wolfsbane, we just lost a valuable member of the team

[rzr]

Re: TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

That's what I'm thinking. But, if FoJar wants the wolfsbane lynched... Hmmm?

[Litodude]

Re: TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

Nice move freaky....let me think this through...

k, i'll be pretty much repeating what turbo said but read anyway.

Freaky's claim for wolfsbane is a very good move. Justification for my reasoning is as follows:

If he's a wolf pretending to be a wolfsbane, then he's taking a serious risk as it's not confirmed that there isn't a seer playing. And even if there is a seer, that person would have to come out and tell us that freaky is a wolf Day 2(assuming the seer seered freaky N2). Then it would all be up to chance to see if we have a guardian or a real wolfsbane. In this scenario, guardian doesn't come out to anyone, or wolfsbane comes out to seer.

Now if freaky is really a wolfsbane then this game is pretty much in the bag if we have a seer as the second random blue. Although, this is the risky part where he must determine whether or not to trust freaky's claim. I know freaky was contacting a bunch of people over AIM, as he sent me a message as well early into the night (I'm sure you felt confident to talk to people as you're safe from killings, right?) which made him a prime wolf target, thus resulting in the "no one was killed" update we got.

Going back to sleep - still sick. Leave me an offline message on AIM if anything (if you're blocked send me a PM lol). Also I have rzr ignored for the entirety of this game so far and my play is not affected any differently

[FoJaR]

Re: TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

if freaky really is a wolfsbane, why come out so soon? why not slow play his hand a little bit?

[Litodude]

Re: TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

Why should he?

I lied I'm not asleep \o/

[Ruritsu]

Re: TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

Who cares, treat him as though he was, if things go sour, we can lynch him later.

Lynching him now would sorta be jumping the gun me thinks >_>

[freakysnots]

Re: TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

Session Start (freakysnots:thisisfojar): Fri Jan 23 01:05:47 2009
[01:05] freakysnots: you is fojar
[01:06] freakysnots: why am i noob/wolf
[01:06] freakysnots: im wolfsbane
[01:07] freakysnots: well get back to me
[01:07] freakysnots: but the only reason you want me lynched is because you are a wolf
[01:07] freakysnots: you can't wolf me so the only way you can kill me is to get me lynched
[01:07] freakysnots: but i'd like to see your reason too
Session Close (thisisfojar): Fri Jan 23 01:12:54 2009

I'll probably go vote him if anything else doesn't come up. I just don't see why wolfsbane should not come out and why you wanted me lynched.

Get on aim before i lose my motivation for twg.

Blues, come to me.
- Seer, seer me and then come to me if you feel like it.
- Physic, I believe phychics are useless, but what ever, come to me.
- Guard, message bdn and see if you can guard yourself. That way we get 2 people who cannot be wolfed. If not, guard random people.

Also, I think they tried to wolf me night 1 but failed although I don't understand why it doesn't say it.

[freakysnots]

Re: TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

oh sup

I got a blue claim. [No, this isn't one of those blue claims that are bs to get the blues to come out. I really did get someone claiming blue]

Not telling you what role they are because that will help the wolves fake a counterclaim easier.

[Ruritsu]

Re: TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

Freaky, telling the blue role doesn't make it any easier for wolves to counter claim 'cause the roles are random. They could very easily just claim to be another role, so telling the thread would be nice >_>

[freakysnots]

Re: TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

mmorpging so ill make this quick

if i say what role he is, then if the wolves want to counterclaim a blue, they know what not to claim they are

now that i think about it, i should have said something fake to see if i can catch any wolves.

oh well

[rzr]

Re: TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

Digging for info, Mr. Ruritsu?

[Litodude]

Re: TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

chill.

[Ruritsu]

Re: TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

mmorpging so ill make this quick

if i say what role he is, then if the wolves want to counterclaim a blue, they know what not to claim they are

now that i think about it, i should have said something fake to see if i can catch any wolves.

oh well

They could still claim anything except for wolvesbane. I.E. You say your blue claim was psychic let's say, wolf responds "BS, I'm psychic!", but guard and seer will work equally well, considering that there can't be 3 blues. Unless you mean that if they claimed to be something and then whoever they claim to runs over to you and asks if the blues match ect ect.

An explanation as to why telling the blue role would help the wolves would be nice is all I'm saying...

@Rzr: Cute, but I just don't see the reason is all...

[rzr]

Re: TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

The reason for what?

[Ruritsu]

Re: TWG LXXIV: Luck of the Draw

For concealing the blue role, which I asked right above it. I know he said that it would help a counter claim, but being more specific would be nice is all...

But meh, he'll either explain and I'll be informed or he won't and I'll just be SOL, whatever...