TWG XXIV Postgame

[talisman]

what the fuck would I have lynched blah day one for? If he was human that would have been A) flat out retarded B) revealed at least two members of the alliance to the wolves and C) gotten rid of a valuable player. Seering him was clearly the correct choice.

Hell, I suspected qreepy before anyone, but my suspicion on him waxed and waned. If you recall, he was who I initially suggested we might seer night two, until the blah prospect came up.

[Afrobean]

what the $*%# would I have lynched blah day one for?

Because I said so haha.

PS blah is not as valuable a player as people give him credit for.

PPS it would not give away anything at all. I had said NOTHING of wanting to lynch blah so I was clearly disconnected from it, and I do not believe tps or eb mentioned blah either. You're forgetting that you could IM any one in the game and say "ok we're vote switching to blah at the last second. If you don't help me with this, you'll be lynched tommorow."

PPPS I don't recall about Qreepy, but I wouldn't be surprised. I just remember going "Qreepy is the last wolf because blah named him as one of the three" I can't think of if you said anything before this or not.

PPPPS it really is because of Tps we won though. Talisman, your position was circumstantial. Anyone in that position would have been able to lead a win (some others would have been able to pull a more efficent win ), but Tps's saving was truly brilliant and it was that save that gave us this win.

[evilbutterfly]

eb said he seer'd me because he thought I was a wolf based on my behavior pregame. Haha.

Who said that? I thought I seered you because well, I hoped you'd be on my side. Chris+Noah = teh win. :O. I can't remember, though. XD

[dAnceguy117]

After thinking on it some, I've decided to sit out 1-2 more games. Right now, it's finally back to the point where I could be active and play decently again. However, I don't miss the game. I want to make sure I really want to play this game when I start playing again.

[Tps222]

I was glad Afro was saved because I talk to him a lot.

I appreciate the props on the save, but it was fairly obvious.

Talisman came up with some good plans, especially the Jipkin account one. He lead well.

I enjoyed getting the power I wanted every night I needed it, especially the seer with Blah and Guard with Talisman.

[talisman]

Afro, I stand by seering. I don't play by my gut like that. And blah IS a good player, despite what you think. He's very perceptive and can lie on a dime.

you have to admit though, the jipkin account was brilliant... what's twc policy going to be on that one, btw?

[QreepyBORIS]

Having a spare account to do all your work on and having it guaranteed to be blue just makes it a damn lot harder for the wolves. It's not quite fair in my opinion. In TWG, there should be no guarantees (unless you count seering and the psychic; I do not).

[Afrobean]

I was glad Afro was saved because I talk to him a lot.

I appreciate the props on the save, but it was fairly obvious.

Talisman came up with some good plans, especially the Jipkin account one. He lead well.

I enjoyed getting the power I wanted every night I needed it, especially the seer with Blah and Guard with Talisman.

I was never saved.

Also, I'll give Talis that the jipkin idea was clever (even if I think it should be outlawed). It's pretty much a moot point though since Talis lived til the end.

PS Blah is a valuable player but no where near valuable enough for you to say "no afro, I'm ignoring your awesome intuition and instead helping to lynch nforcer, even though nforcer is helpful when he tries too." It's silly to automatically make people immune to lynching day 1. This is why we don't lynch wolves on day 1 folks.

EDIT: if we were lynching people based on who was most helpful on day 1, we should have gone after nick, matt, etc. Also, did LD even post at all? I can't think of a single thing he'd said. He would have been a better lynch day 1 if he's not going to post at all.

[mattc16]

Wow. GG humans. Sorry i couldn't be more active, my friend's death has really screwed with my mind over the last two weeks, and I wasn't really as helpful as I hope to be in the next TWG I play. Well played afro and talis especially.

[talisman]

uh posting alot isn't what makes a person valuable/helpful... blah is smart as fuck, and that's a fact. He can read people and figure shit about better than most. Like me though he tends not to act on it until too late (evidenced in this game by knowing who the blues were but not being able to do anything about it).

I only voted for nforcer because I thought jurs was more human than he was, and putting out a lame vote at that point would have been dumb... I didn't want to see a KiB (and I didn't know rai would switch!).

[Afrobean]

Well played afro and talis especially.

I repeat: we won because of Tps. Anyone could lead an alliance (especially when they're saved from being wolfed and they have no choice but to be an alliance leader), and my excellent wolf calls were basically dismissed at first.

However, it takes a great player to correctly save someone, especially night 1.

[Kilgamayan]

If the humans won because of Tps, then why should you get the MVP? >_>

[DarkManticoreX2]

Re: TWG XXIV Postgame

Archived 5-21-2014 11:27 AM EST