TWG V Postgame Analysis

[alainbryden]

Is there any other way of life?

use protection kids

[evilbutterfly]

Besides all that--I think the wolves played this one really well until Alain screwed up with the fake seer bit.

The big screw up was in admitting to the fake seer bit.

[sleeplessdragn]

yea, honestly i really felt like the dead wolves basically gave up after they were killed. i think i would have lost this game with more satisfaction if not for that.

[stretchypanda]

K, so somewhere back a few pages, it was mentioned that Chardish went through asking if people were or were not wolves, with the intention of telling Tassel. Please tell me, Tass, that you don't think this is okay, since you wouldn't tell me, after I'd died, if you were a wolf. I understand the suspicion that, had I known, I would have run to my boyfriend to rat you out, but I'm only slightly insulted by this, since I know Guido is a big boy and can play a forum game on his own.

And on that, everyone has already said that this is just a forum game, and not worth cheating on, but you did it anyway. I would have expected you and Chardish to take the most fun in the CRITICAL THINKING part of the game and try to actually figure out who is and isn't a wolf. I think that's where the respect bit comes into play. Come on, guys, you're older than over half the forum, and you're mods, and these people look up to you. Even during a silly forum game. It's not any fun if the people playing are too busy wondering who's cheating (just to get a stupid pip on a stupid signature banner) to play the game.

Have fun on game 6 -- hope it's more interesting.

[Tasselfoot]

i don't control chardish, but i wouldn't have declined any information that he could have told me. in the end, he told me nothing. the rules are that the dead can say nothing... no where does it say the living have to decline offers of the dead.

plus, its each individuals decision on whether or not to reveal their role to the dead. i told Guido everything before twg4 was over.

y'know, so fine... this game had alot of flaws to it. the only important part of any of it is that alain getting nabbed as the fake seer was the sole catalyst of the humans winning. we most likely lose if not for that.

and, i would appreciate it if y'all are going to criticize my morals, to keep it at the things i did do... and to also criticize the others who either participated in similar actions, or more obvious ones. i seem to be the one being singled out.

[Kilgamayan]

You're probably being singled out because you tried to justify your actions where Eee Bee and Afrobean apologized.

If chardish were around and acting the same way I'd have no different of an attitude toward him.

[evilbutterfly]

Hey, I admitted my mistakes, and I think that everybody (especially you, since you're like, a role model for us young'ns) should do the same and promise to never cheat again.

[roopert]

Arrrrg, well I missed the signups for this game since I was still at school (seriously, is it too much to ask for the signup thread not to be unlocked until everyone has a fair shot at it? No i'm not talking about peoples' personal schedules, just TIMEZONES at the very least). good luck everyone. hopefully there won't be any cheaters.

[lightdarkness]

Arrrrg, well I missed the signups for this game since I was still at school (seriously, is it too much to ask for the signup thread not to be unlocked until everyone has a fair shot at it? No i'm not talking about peoples' personal schedules, just TIMEZONES at the very least). good luck everyone. hopefully there won't be any cheaters.

Sorry :-\ I guess I didn't really think of west coast :'(

[roopert]

I don't mind sitting out one game and letting others have a shot, I just want it to change in the future so I can have an equal shot at it.

[Tasselfoot]

EB... thought i had made my feelings clear. alot of you have issues with some of the things that have been done in the game. you won't have another issue from me.

[roopert]

So, did this game not count in terms of banners or have they just not been updated yet?

[lightdarkness]

So, did this game not count in terms of banners or have they just not been updated yet?

Chardish will do them when he is done with exams.

[alainbryden]

NEIGH006: I think I would have done legendarily well if I hadn't been so unlucky
evilbutterfly87: yeah
evilbutterfly87: and if you hadnt admitted
evilbutterfly87: and if your fellow wolves hadnt gone for tass
NEIGH006: and I only admitted to falure because I honestly thought the evidence was overwhelming
evilbutterfly87: no spoken evidence is overwhleming unless from the convicted
NEIGH006: true enough
evilbutterfly87: i seriously doubted them until you spoke up
evilbutterfly87: Afrobean still doubted them after that
NEIGH006: I just didn't to head maths right. It took 2 people put together to claim that I was a wolf, LD and Tass working together, but all I saw was that exactly what I feared would happen, happened, so I gave up.
NEIGH006: it's sad though, because first I put up this huge post countering it and everything, then posted it and saw that tass had supported LD's claims, and then gave up and edited.
NEIGH006: I didn't really think it through
NEIGH006: so you're right
evilbutterfly87: always deny
evilbutterfly87: ALWAYS
evilbutterfly87: as you're being dragged away to be shot, keep denying
NEIGH006: hehe

[User6773]

What I apologize for: Attempting to gather information from the dead and relay it to Tass. The dead are supposed to stay out of the game, and I did not. I accept as punishment being banned from TWG VI. :P

What I somewhat apologize for: Discussion of last letters in PMs. Yeah, I know this is low. Yeah, I know it's against the spirit of the game. Yeah, I knew it would only work once. But it's legal, and even though it's wrong, it plain and simple wasn't cheating. The (old) rules say you don't share your PMs with others. We didn't share PMs - we asked each other questions about them. And though it is low and crummy and unfair, I pride myself that I had the idea. I promise never to do it again.

I've got a neat new idea for TWG VII. I'm keeping my lips shut about it, but needless to say it will add a whole new layer of intrigue to the game.

Right. Back to being invisible again....