TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

[DaBackpack]

Re: TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

bonehican was not a bad lynch, it was just the wrong one

[Lightknight924]

Re: TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

[DaBackpack]

Re: TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

Nakah, he has to actually play the game

he would have been replaced for not meeting the post requirement anyway

fuck off

[DaBackpack]

Re: TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

OK technically he met the post requirement. He still did jack shit and literally watched himself die.

Not my problem

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

it's not much but it's better than last game

I'll concede that it is better then the laid back conversations of the last game.

I am not compelled to say that was serious enough to actually clear someone even if all we have to do is clear them enough to not be policy'd.

Now picking Boney over here for that reason is more then legit enough but I get the sense you're defending her way more then just that and I don't really understand it.


I also think picking Boney over her because of him being invisible is pretty bad and should have never happened, but I'll let others chime in on that before I try to decide just how bad it is.

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

I'm so pissed I missed the end of day phase last night, because I would have been talking you all out of killing bonhican....Seriously, why would you guys kill off the new member on the forum that I brought on as a friend? What kind of community are you trying to facilitate? A community of the same old members over and over again? Do you not see how ugly this reflects on all of you that voted him out?

I hope he doesn't feel like he was voted because he isn't welcomed here on FFR, and I hope he checks out the rest of the site and chooses to stick around. I would love to play with him again.

As for you specifically, new people can role wolf just as easily as anyone can. I rolled wolf my first game and got way further then I had any right doing because I kept having people say that I was too new to lynch (took me mechanically being caught by the seer). Not lynching someone on those grounds is simply not playing the game, and I didn't sign up and deal with this 15 year old forum interface to not play the fucking game.

Also this post is damn near too extensive to really be considered a death post IMHO but if SunFan's cool with it I have no complaints

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

But back to the task at hand

I don't think Boney should have been considered on grounds of being invisible over the other inactives

I guess that's my piece on the matter.

[the sun fan]

Re: TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

that death post is probably too game relevant
I won't be deleting it, but lets save our strong feelings about the events of the game for the postgame, ok?

[DaBackpack]

Re: TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

But back to the task at hand

I don't think Boney should have been considered on grounds of being invisible over the other inactives

I guess that's my piece on the matter.

Okay even if you think the "invisible thing" didn't matter read the EOD again and remember that he admitted that he was present in thread while he was getting voted by other people and did nothing about it

you're hung up on this one thing when his behavior end of phase was actually just really bad

[Svaz]

Re: TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

Oh hey, a screenshot from HxH, I hope that means you're finally getting into it, it's a pretty good series and it surprised me a lot, my suspicions were "ahh, shonenshit, here comes some fighting" but I liked it a lot outside of that (and some of the fighting scenes are rly cool tbh).



Also regarding Bonehican's lynch, I think you're at least half right, a lot of people have been playing with each other for a long time and are more certain about how to read the players they know, and a new variable can read as wolfy (it's not impossible to roll wolf on one's first game after all) just by merit of not being well versed in the meta (sunfan even used that as a means to guess my wolfteam through me not knowing the vote tags existed last game). Also, I guess it's worth saying: I wouldn't recommend TWG as an initiation accommodating community necessarily, it's just... not really how the game works. It brings out some pretty rough parts of personalities by merit of being a game based on suspicion.

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

Okay even if you think the "invisible thing" didn't matter read the EOD again and remember that he admitted that he was present in thread while he was getting voted by other people and did nothing about it

you're hung up on this one thing when his behavior end of phase was actually just really bad

He did admit that after the push so it doesn't excuse you making the push.
You can say it justifies your push, but that's honestly debatable because lets face it he was new and probably was just trying to sit back and soak it in.
You made the call way too early for me to excuse on his last post that was made right at 9.

[DaBackpack]

Re: TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

He did admit that after the push so it doesn't excuse you making the push.
You can say it justifies your push, but that's honestly debatable because lets face it he was new and probably was just trying to sit back and soak it in.
You made the call way too early for me to excuse on his last post that was made right at 9.

He plays on another website

even so I'm having a hard time believing you're actually arguing this in good faith

I don't regret the lynch

period

[the sun fan]

Re: TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

Upon consideration, the deathpost will stay. The wolf has been slightly compensated for Nakah's deathpost. The compensation does NOT take the form of additional wolf KP, or alter the setup itself in any way by giving the wolf any additional role actions. Please refrain from making game-relevant deathposts.

[DaBackpack]

Re: TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

Nakah, go fuck yourself

goodbye

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG CLXXXIII: star-crossed Can't Roll Wolf Because... Game Thread

He plays on another website

even so I'm having a hard time believing you're actually arguing this in good faith

I don't regret the lynch

period

I have no idea how extensive he's played before and I probably should have thought to ask him. I can't comment on that.

I was letting the issue rest so if you're upset that we're still at you should look at your bad habit of having to always get the last word and decide when conversations end. But you're probably not saying the "good faith" thing because of that because it reads as this sly threat that you'll vote me for pushing you

Which actually does push my buttons so yeah sure whatever vote stands come vote me for the push let's goddamn thunderdome this shit your vote was shit your reasoning was shit you didn't even want to play the fucking game until Yosh whined and whined that you where not and then these where the results and someone calls you out on them and it's all Naw man shit happens just deal with and stop talking I posted about it so there can't be anymore to say about right just like, period dude like alright buddy ol' pal tell you what man you can have tonight free go ahead and make another post and handwave it all away and I can promise I won't respond because I'm logging off this motherfucker and I'll see you at EoD