TWG XIV Emergency Voting

[Tasselfoot]

RE: Re: RE: TWG XIV Emergency Voting

Chardish... I just want recognition for the work I put into winning this game for my team. Kilga and I spent a while discussing it last night, getting everything together, working it out... And, it just isn't fair of you to end the game because LD starts blabbing his mouth to you.

Alderoth won this game, and my whole TEAM deserves to be recognized for winning.

[lightdarkness]

RE: Re: RE: TWG XIV Emergency Voting

Ok

Alderoth won

Happy?

You still aren't getting pip's

[flypie743]

RE: Re: RE: TWG XIV Emergency Voting

forum drama++

Hey guys, you are all fighting over...

A PIP..way to be mature guys.



I think I'm glad I missed the sign ups for this one =/

[Tasselfoot]

RE: Re: RE: TWG XIV Emergency Voting

I'm fighting on principle. Why did Chardish end the game? There is no reason whatsoever he should have done that. The 9 of us worked on this, put time into it, and would like the recognition we earned for it. The game may have even been interesting had it gone on, with 3-4 people knowing all the wolves, plus knowing we're still going for tribal victory. We'll never know. Well... could have been interesting, but the outcome was fixed. I was enjoying talking to Hans/LD last night, giving them hope of human victory.

::sigh:: If nothing else, Chardish should never host a game again that is new.

[Kilgamayan]

Re: RE: Re: RE: TWG XIV Emergency Voting

You still aren't getting pip's

Disclaimer: I don't care one way or the other about getting a pip for this game. I'm competitive, yes, but not to that extent.

That being said, I hardly think you have a say in the matter considering we would be getting one if it wasn't for you. At the very least, mead and Tass deserve pips for the work they did.

[Demon_Of_The_Comet]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: TWG XIV Emergency Voting

Whoa, am i the only one who doesnt care about a pip?
I just play this cuz its fun, and somewhat competitively.


Im changing my vote to B
Tribal sounds good, but in action it just doesnt work out.
Also we should just give Tass a pip, he kinda did work at this.
Or if not we could just start over with original rules and stuff cuz Chardish isnt doing so hot with the tribal thing =/

[lightdarkness]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: TWG XIV Emergency Voting

Hans and I talked to spheriod for like 2-3 hours, and I believe hans got in trouble with his parents for staying on the computer too long.

It took a lot of effort for us to get that info out of him.

Honestly, when tass was gonna come out and say they were going tribal, we would've fought back. What do you think everyone would've gone for? A victory that took 6 or so days, or 4. More people would win if we just went for the wolves, Tass was just being an elitest, trying to keep victory in a tight group.

Regardless, I say TWG 14 is restarted, different host. (nudge, me, nudge)

[mead1]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: TWG XIV Emergency Voting

Ok, well this game has certainly had problems. From beginning to "end". But I side with Tass completely on the fact that the Alderoth team should get pips for this game. For almost the entirety of the time before Day 1, Alderoth members were hard at work poking and prodding to find the others (Though some did more than others). Had the game not ended, we were insured victory. Not because we did anything unfair, but because we played the game well. Since we won this game, fair and square, why should we be deprived of what comes of victory?

@Chard No one was expecting a tribal push because everyone in chat had made it look like their opinion was "screw tribal", and because a victory by racial only required 4 kills, not 9. You were so hot on the tribal idea in chat, and the Alderoth team did that. We played as effectively as it is possible to do so. You wanted tribal victory, you got it.

[Tasselfoot]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: TWG XIV Emergency Voting

LD... I come out on day 4 with NINE of us in a group, vs FOUR... and, in either case, it ends on day 5. Do your math buddy.

Also, I know you spent hours and hours interrogating Spheroid... I found that funny, knowing you were still losing regardless.

[lightdarkness]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: TWG XIV Emergency Voting

Chardish is gonna have the final say, I just think that this argument is Alderoth vs Sayban.

[Tasselfoot]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: TWG XIV Emergency Voting

Err.. day 3.

[lightdarkness]

Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: TWG XIV Emergency Voting

LD... I come out on day 4 with NINE of us in a group, vs FOUR... and, in either case, it ends on day 5. Do your math buddy.

Also, I know you spent hours and hours interrogating Spheroid... I found that funny, knowing you were still losing regardless.

Jay: day 4 1 is lynched
Jay: so 3 on night 5
Jay: one wolfed
Jay: 2 on day 5
Jay: one lynched
Jay: 1 on night 6
Jay: victory day 7
Jay: do YOUR math

PS: Glad you acknowladge I was working too.

[Kilgamayan]

Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: TWG XIV Emergency Voting

Ok, well this game has certainly had problems. From beginning to "end". But I side with Tass completely on the fact that the Alderoth team should get pips for this game. For almost the entirety of the time before Day 1, Alderoth members were hard at work poking and prodding to find the others (Though some did more than others). Had the game not ended, we were insured victory. Not because we did anything unfair, but because we played the game well. Since we won this game, fair and square, why should we be deprived of what comes of victory?

@Chard No one was expecting a tribal push because everyone in chat had made it look like their opinion was "screw tribal", and because a victory by racial only required 4 kills, not 9. You were so hot on the tribal idea in chat, and the Alderoth team did that. We played as effectively as it is possible to do so. You wanted tribal victory, you got it.

Hot damn, you rule.

I also found it pretty funny that in the end, chardish got his tribal victory.

Also, for math:

Night 1: Sayban 1 dies
Day 1: Spheroid (Sayban 2) dies
Night 2: No one dies (worst case)
Day 2: Jenova (Sayban 3) dies
Night 3: Sayban 4 dies (no Sayban wolves left)
Day 3: Sayban 5 dies
Night 4: Sayban 6 dies
Day 4: Sayban 7 dies
Night 5: Sayban 8 dies
Day 5: Sayban 9 dies, Alderoth wins

If I get Jenova to help me lynch a Sayban (Hans was the most likely choice even given the Sayban guardian) then it only takes until Night 5.

It ends on Interval 5 either way.

[lightdarkness]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: TWG XIV Emergency Voting

Happy now tass? *points to your sig*

[Kefit]

Some experiments don't work out.

This was one of them. The problem with tribal, as far as I see it, is that it is useless if you don't know the majority of tribal affiliations, and it gives victory to whichever tribe has more living players if one does have this information.

Anyway, I vote B. Chardish's experiment may have failed, but I see no reason not to let him host a game closer to the norm.