FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

[Glitz]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

I know Spin wasn't a good file, I just wanted to see what the judges would say (seemed like a good song, but in retrospect I never should have stepped it lol).

thanks for not wasting anyone's time

you'd think people would stop giving feedback to cut down on this but I guess not

[kommisar[os]]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

u gonna submit zelder?

[gnr61]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

hes butthurt still about his nominal misrepresentation
also what jimerax said is completely correct and is also why i stopped posting judgements publicly during the last pack. it's not our job to help you make a better file, its our job to say "this is good and this isn't." if case is such that a file has the potential to be improved upon and accepted into the pack we will give more detailed criticism as to what specifically can be fixed. otherwise we say what's wrong with it and leave it at that.

and i'll toy with ur mosaic file kommi lol, i'll just add another chart with the tweaks and run it by you when its done.

[kommisar[os]]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

sure thing. i'd put mines in if i wanted to but would probably turn out harder than your files ;_;

[N.T.M.]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

I haven't been active recently because my step dad is a drunken ****** and bought beer instead of paying the internet bill.

Is this why you're always such a nice guy?

[operationstrawbarry]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

Leave drama out of this. One thing I learned about my experience in sending to FFRCP1 is that complaining about ur file wont get anywhere. Ur file is either accepted or not. Fix it or dont. No one cares otherwise.

Leave torrent stuff to PMs. Though I can vouch for torrent being on Basic Training. He told be over PMs when we were trying to figure out what to do with Hell Hath No Fury. I can't vouch for anything else though.

Hope you got my Creepout file again.

[omgitznpv]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

i already went over fixes with puppet for futsuu. not fixing it anymore. mini freezes are justified and patterns are fine just get better at da game

yo

the file isn't hard and by patterns i mean it could be more fun.......kinda....

Sorry, I thought you only judged one chart when playing, not all of them.

Also, judging by the reviews you gave the only reason it got such a dismal rating was due to the song choice...seemed pretty catchy and a good song choice. Call me weird, but having song that's (somewhat) educational and decent stepping material is something that is a unique and rare thing to find.

"educational" is completely irrelevant to song choice and judgment overall

by song choice i'm questioning how it would be a decent song to step. sorry, but family guy music is generally something to stray away from if you wish to make a quality simfile. the songs first off, simply don't make interesting files. second, they lack much "informational content" in terms of theory. going with song choice, i also take into factor would people actually like the song (not many people will play a file for a terrible song); i judge it from the view of the majority of people. would people like this song?

P.S I don't understand how the the patterns/freeze usage is bad - just saying it doesn't help at all. I placed freezes in areas that should contain them, so I'm not sure what to fix. I'll probably send out my file to somebody else for testing first, such as Patashu

as already said, we're not really here to tell you exactly what to fix. we tell you why your file is accepted/rejected, which is clearly stated in the post. we don't tell you what exactly do with it. we simply do not have the time; it'd take forever to judge otherwise and we have lives anyways. if you need to know precisely what to fix, get somebody to personally test it for you. doing that takes about 20-30 minutes per file for me, on average, and doing that for every file is death.

on a side note, don't take this as if i'm attacking you or something. i know i probably sound that way, but i don't mean it; just take it as constructive criticism. i'm just trying to get points across.

Leave drama out of this. One thing I learned about my experience in sending to FFRCP1 is that complaining about ur file wont get anywhere. Ur file is either accepted or not. Fix it or dont. No one cares otherwise.

words of wisdom

[gnr61]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

last time i told bynary fission to acquire some file testers if he wanted hyperspecific feedback he thought i was insulting him -.-
but really theres nothing better you can do if you're looking to improve your files, having pack judges try them is not the most productive route lol

[omgitznpv]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

for myself, the only way i improved my files was by stepping more and more and more...jx judged my first files and he knows how bad they were if he does remember.... ~___~ i kinda just looked at what i did wrong and acknowledged it but i didn't really do much with it

[who_cares973]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

i dont bother having people test my files i just send them

[xferrarix]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

i dont bother having people test my files i just send them

^^

also i re-sent 3y3s and other file. i made 2 diffs on the other file; delete the other one, its jus a dummy chart for the main (standard). kthx

[Choofers]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

Might send something :]

[operationstrawbarry]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

Reads fifth post.

Hmmm Im running out of computers and now my laptop is doing this bull **** on me.

Ive already restepped the damn thing... Im running out of ideas.

NPV... mind if I try via MSN with you or AIM? Its starting to seem that zipping the file is causing this problem because for some reason, Im not having the problemns when I transfer the file via computers through USB.

[xferrarix]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

ooo alright yeah send me back the first one and i'll try to or something

[kommisar[os]]

Re: FFR Community Pack III (Submissions Open)

i realized i'm yet to make a file that npv likes