White Walls pt. 1 [79 or...]

[Xx{Midnight}xX]

Re: White Walls pt. 1 [79 or...]

Going with all that's been said here, and in comparison to files like PK, HA, and WEYX, I'm gonna say 82-83 would be best. Yes, a huge amount of the file is filler, but some of those sections are disgusting, enough to warrant the rank of Brutal, I'd say.

Why does it have to mentioned that there's filler? The filler isn't that much less difficult than the rest of it. There are still notes there, so you can still dump goods as easily at any point in the chart. The chart is all around brutal and only lets up at the end. There aren't any breaks. Chart's easily harder than WEYX in any regard. Take whatever WEYX is rated and add one or two.

Comparing this to CP is also rather stupid because that implies there's an unrealistic section in the chart (No one has yet to AAA CP without overlay or ds as far as I know.) Everything in white walls can be done without the use of a special setup. So again, this comparison is stupid as hell.

[xXOpkillerXx]

Re: White Walls pt. 1 [79 or...]

Bump, please move this file up to 82 at least.

[ssbmchamp]

Re: White Walls pt. 1 [79 or...]

Personally a song difficulty rating should be based on two things only:

1) Stamina
2) The hardest part in that song (a song is only as difficult as its most difficult part)

After all, these are the 2 main factors when trying to get a AAA on a song, so logically I
think you should rate the hardest part of this song (not parts) and then factor in a stamina rating to come up with a final difficulty rating.

[rushyrulz]

Re: White Walls pt. 1 [79 or...]

I vote 83 since there's awkward difficulty spikes + length

[TC_Halogen]

Re: White Walls pt. 1 [79 or...]

Personally a song difficulty rating should be based on two things only:

1) Stamina
2) The hardest part in that song (a song is only as difficult as its most difficult part)

After all, these are the 2 main factors when trying to get a AAA on a song, so logically I
think you should rate the hardest part of this song (not parts) and then factor in a stamina rating to come up with a final difficulty rating.

Stamina is an acceptable factor, but judging only by the hardest part is very bad, especially if the hardest part of a song is only slightly harder than the average difficulty of the file.

In any case, you should take multiple accounts of things, like stamina both on a physical and mental (length) level, physical pattern construction, extremes within particular patterns, frame placement (inconsistent frame placements at certain BPMs force you to be more accurate), difficulty of full comboing with respectable PA (or 0 boos), etc.

[ssbmchamp]

Re: White Walls pt. 1 [79 or...]

Stamina is an acceptable factor, but judging only by the hardest part is very bad, especially if the hardest part of a song is only slightly harder than the average difficulty of the file.

In any case, you should take multiple accounts of things, like stamina both on a physical and mental (length) level, physical pattern construction, extremes within particular patterns, frame placement (inconsistent frame placements at certain BPMs force you to be more accurate), difficulty of full comboing with respectable PA (or 0 boos), etc.

I 100% agree with what your saying, I guess I was just trying to take the shortcut and simplify it. I just looked at it as everything you just said into one more or less. Like I associate BPM with stamina and difficult patterns I associate with the the hardest part of the song. But in the end I'll leave it up to you guys because I am nowhere near the skill level of you or OWA, who can more accurately rate files. If stuff hard for me I just mash through it :p lol

[xXOpkillerXx]

Re: White Walls pt. 1 [79 or...]

Anything happening yet ?

[One Winged Angel]

Re: White Walls pt. 1 [79 or...]

Haven't been on much lately, but I'm pretty sure this is going to end up as either an 82 or 83 after reading what's been discussed in this thread. I think the general consensus is that this should sit higher than wherever WEYX lies, so 83 is probably the more appropriate difficulty. I'll lock this tomorrow and get this sucker bumped up soon unless this thread picks up again and starts discussing other potential difficulties. 83 seems to be the most agreeable location for this file though.

[xXOpkillerXx]

Re: White Walls pt. 1 [79 or...]

Haven't been on much lately, but I'm pretty sure this is going to end up as either an 82 or 83 after reading what's been discussed in this thread. I think the general consensus is that this should sit higher than wherever WEYX lies, so 83 is probably the more appropriate difficulty. I'll lock this tomorrow and get this sucker bumped up soon unless this thread picks up again and starts discussing other potential difficulties. 83 seems to be the most agreeable location for this file though.

Alright thank you Rob. Just wanted to make sure something happens with the rating ^^