Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Oct 16]

Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #31
    aka Haku
    Hakulyte
    • Jul 2005
    • 4750

    Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

    Someone knows who's Halilintar and Animal. ?

    Comment

    • #32
      sausage
      FFR Simfile Author
      Xayphon
      • Nov 2008
      • 1632

      Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

      Originally posted by PrawnSkunk
      Hmm, separate "active" and "all-time" leaderboards was a controversial idea I had thrown out, however I am definitely open to investigate this in greater detail if it's something people would like to see.
      I'm absolutely not saying that there should be seperated leaderboards, I'd be against that even. A little text saying "inactive" or a little icon which symbolizes "inactivity" etc. would be enough. I thought that it might be interesting to see who hasn't played in a while - not just for veterans, but also for new players who have never seen any of the names suddenly popping up on the list and are too lazy to click themselves through every profile to check whether these people haven't played in a while or not (especially those having a higher rank than said user). It'd also prevent new players from getting a false picture of the website where everybody who is on the leaderboard automatically still plays the game or something...

      On the other hand it's controversial, I agree with that. It's not really needed in a list representing the skill of players, no matter when they played and if they still play.

      It was a thought I had which I wouldn't mind seeing on the leaderboards personally, but of course it's up to the others and the devs
      Last edited by Xayphon; 02-16-2015, 10:27 PM.

      Comment

      • #33
        has nice tits
        XCV
        • Nov 2008
        • 744

        Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

        Originally posted by Xayphon
        I'm absolutely not saying that there should be seperated leaderboards, I'd be against that even. A little text saying "inactive" or a little icon which symbolizes "inactivity" etc. would be enough. I thought that it might be interesting to see who hasn't played in a while - not just for veterans, but also for new players who have never seen any of the names suddenly popping up on the list and are too lazy to click themselves through every profile to check whether these people haven't played in a while or not (especially those having a higher rank than said user). It'd also prevent new players from getting a false picture of the website where everybody who is on the leaderboard automatically still plays the game or something...

        On the other hand it's controversial, I agree with that. It's not really needed in a list representing the skill of players, no matter when they played and if they still play.

        It was a thought I had which I wouldn't mind seeing on the leaderboards personally, but of course it's up to the others and the devs
        Two separate boards is probs not a good idea, but it'd be nice to be able to hide inactive accounts with a checkbox, or show active players' rank on mouseover, or something like that

        Comment

        • #34
          [Kaho]
          FFR Simfile Author
          XelNya
          • Sep 2012
          • 3372

          Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

          Originally posted by PrawnSkunk
          You cannot report yourself, but if you search for "KungFuHustle" on your main account, you will be given the option to report the alternate account. Thanks for helping keep the leaderboards clean!
          Probably could clarify it a bit better like:

          "If you want to report your own alternate accounts, you can do so by searching them in the leaderboards and then clicking the exclamation point next to their name after you search them. Note that if the account doesn't qualify for being ranked in this system, you cannot report it."

          Or picture based example:



          Because the description on the front page can lead you to think it's this one:



          Which is the user control panel, which is what I thought of.

          tldr: The FPP could use a little extra clarification just in case. I'm kinda dumb so I was pretty confused where to go myself. Dunno why I assumed it was on profile / in the control panel, but it'll help from other people like myself from getting confused.
          Last edited by XelNya; 02-16-2015, 10:38 PM.

          Comment

          • #35
            FFR Player
            KungFuHustle
            • Dec 2008
            • 34

            Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

            Originally posted by XelNya
            I'm kinda dumb so I was pretty confused where to go myself.
            hey

            Edit: Oh, super super minor thing, but the flag for Taiwan is wrong. The Taiwan flag looks like this:
            Last edited by KungFuHustle; 02-16-2015, 11:05 PM.
            hi i'm mikeshinoda12345

            Comment

            • #36
              Administrator
              FFR Simfile Author
              FFR Administrator
              PrawnSkunk
              • Dec 2007
              • 3946

              Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

              Thanks, Xayphon and XCV! A checkbox sounds like a great compromise. I'll bring this up with the other devs tonight.

              Originally posted by XelNya
              Probably could clarify it a bit better like:

              "If you want to report your own alternate accounts, you can do so by searching them in the leaderboards and then clicking the exclamation point next to their name after you search them. Note that if the account doesn't qualify for being ranked in this system, you cannot report it."
              Good call. After working on a project for so long, I seem to lose the ability to explain basic things in normal english. Thank you -- I've used your suggestion to clarify this in the front page post.

              Comment

              • #37
                For a New Beginning
                FFR Simfile Author
                Deidara837
                • Jun 2008
                • 1930

                Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                Yeah I agree, viewing top 4 scores would be wonderful

                Wait does this mean my Einstein-Rosen Bridge score is actually recognized, even with the miss? (5-0-1-6) Because currently my levelranks show 9-0-1-3

                _9th OT: D2 - 13th Place
                10th OT: D5 - 45th Place
                11th OT: D6 - 12th Place

                EMG Rivalry | EMG Spreadsheet

                Comment

                • #38
                  [Kaho]
                  FFR Simfile Author
                  XelNya
                  • Sep 2012
                  • 3372

                  Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                  Originally posted by PrawnSkunk
                  Good call. After working on a project for so long, I seem to lose the ability to explain basic things in normal english. Thank you -- I've used your suggestion to clarify this in the front page post.
                  ^_^

                  English is hard anyways. Even my explanation was very wordy compared to yours rofl.

                  Comment

                  • #39
                    Rhythm game specialist.
                    FFR Simfile Author
                    FFR Music Producer
                    TC_Halogen
                    • Feb 2008
                    • 19510

                    Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                    Originally posted by Xayphon
                    I'm absolutely not saying that there should be seperated leaderboards, I'd be against that even. A little text saying "inactive" or a little icon which symbolizes "inactivity" etc. would be enough. I thought that it might be interesting to see who hasn't played in a while - not just for veterans, but also for new players who have never seen any of the names suddenly popping up on the list and are too lazy to click themselves through every profile to check whether these people haven't played in a while or not (especially those having a higher rank than said user). It'd also prevent new players from getting a false picture of the website where everybody who is on the leaderboard automatically still plays the game or something...

                    On the other hand it's controversial, I agree with that. It's not really needed in a list representing the skill of players, no matter when they played and if they still play.

                    It was a thought I had which I wouldn't mind seeing on the leaderboards personally, but of course it's up to the others and the devs
                    I think this is a very reasonable request.

                    As I expected after only a few minutes of comprehending how the system worked, a number of users took an absolutely massive hit in their ranks. Yes, this system does assess skill by taking the best score that users have, but there are an absurd number of users that have fallen inactive that pass a good number of these users whose ranks would be terrible because they haven't played anything new.

                    I don't feel like the leaderboard should represent players that haven't played after a certain period, which is why I think it's necessary to a.) expand the scoring beyond four scores and b.) come up with an effective calculation that still adds some minor weight to playing through the game. Yes, this is not a full skill-based assessment, but I hardly feel like a four song list is going to do the job either -- those involved with the development of this already realize that given the indication of wanting to expand past four songs.

                    Another interesting way to alleviate this situation is to apply some retroactivity to the minimum games (or some higher totals) played by omitting players who do not have the gameplays/songs over some sort of arbitrary time. This would cause players who do not play the game to fall off of the skill rating leaderboard, giving those who do play a bit more activity. The time would have to be somewhat reasonable, as higher level players that require less plays to get desired scores on lower level songs should not be falling off as a result of simply being capable of doing what they can.

                    Comment

                    • #40
                      Administrator
                      FFR Simfile Author
                      FFR Administrator
                      PrawnSkunk
                      • Dec 2007
                      • 3946

                      Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                      Originally posted by KungFuHustle
                      hey

                      Edit: Oh, super super minor thing, but the flag for Taiwan is wrong. The Taiwan flag looks like this:
                      http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi..._China.svg.png
                      Oops! Thanks KungFuHustle for catching that. There was an indexing error because there was no flag for Tahiti.

                      For some reason FFR feels the need to have separate countries for French Polynesia and Tahiti.

                      ... and for Great Britain and the United Kingdom.

                      ... and for American Samoa and Samoa American.

                      Actually, there are so many hilariously arbitrary islands on the FFR country list. I think we found the next FFR prodigy:

                      Comment

                      • #41
                        Washed and Irrelevant D7
                        PhantomPuppy
                        • May 2012
                        • 1955

                        Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                        might be a stupid question, but is it possible for a person to get demoted? like, if u fall below the rest in ur division, and ppl in the division below u get ahead of u? course im not planning on letting that happen lol, but just curious.

                        10th OT (D3): 13th
                        11th OT (D6): 11th
                        12th OT (D6): 6th
                        13th OT (D7): 31st
                        14th OT (D7): 25th
                        15th OT (D7): LAST PLACE LOL
                        16th OT (D7): LAST PLACE LOL


                        Originally posted by Funnygurl555
                        you know what they say

                        under all the rust is really shiny...……… metal

                        Comment

                        • #42
                          Rhythm game specialist.
                          FFR Simfile Author
                          FFR Music Producer
                          TC_Halogen
                          • Feb 2008
                          • 19510

                          Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                          Originally posted by PhantomPuppy
                          might be a stupid question, but is it possible for a person to get demoted? like, if u fall below the rest in ur division, and ppl in the division below u get ahead of u? course im not planning on letting that happen lol, but just curious.
                          There are hard skill ranking cutoffs to get into a division.

                          The only reason you would get demoted is one of two possible reasons, in my mind:

                          a.) a song that was one of your top four scores gets removed from the game, or

                          b.) a score on one of those four songs gets forcibly removed

                          Comment

                          • #43
                            For a New Beginning
                            FFR Simfile Author
                            Deidara837
                            • Jun 2008
                            • 1930

                            Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                            As it stands the division cutoffs are flat score based, and there's no way to decrease your score, so the answer as of right now would be no

                            If the cutoffs changed then there'd be potential for division dropping but that's probably not going to be considered for a while

                            Edit: I take too long to type but what I said is slightly different so I'm leaving it up asdf
                            Last edited by Deidara837; 02-16-2015, 11:29 PM.

                            _9th OT: D2 - 13th Place
                            10th OT: D5 - 45th Place
                            11th OT: D6 - 12th Place

                            EMG Rivalry | EMG Spreadsheet

                            Comment

                            • #44
                              Washed and Irrelevant D7
                              PhantomPuppy
                              • May 2012
                              • 1955

                              Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                              ah ok, thanks you two for clearin that up.

                              10th OT (D3): 13th
                              11th OT (D6): 11th
                              12th OT (D6): 6th
                              13th OT (D7): 31st
                              14th OT (D7): 25th
                              15th OT (D7): LAST PLACE LOL
                              16th OT (D7): LAST PLACE LOL


                              Originally posted by Funnygurl555
                              you know what they say

                              under all the rust is really shiny...……… metal

                              Comment

                              • #45
                                Administrator
                                FFR Simfile Author
                                FFR Administrator
                                PrawnSkunk
                                • Dec 2007
                                • 3946

                                Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                                Originally posted by PhantomPuppy
                                might be a stupid question, but is it possible for a person to get demoted? like, if u fall below the rest in ur division, and ppl in the division below u get ahead of u? course im not planning on letting that happen lol, but just curious.
                                In addition to Halogen's response, since division boundaries are hard, you could be "demoted" if you are sitting at the bottom of a skill bracket and the boundaries are readjusted. It is also possible for your skill rating to be negatively affected if the ranking formula changes.

                                Comment

                                Working...