Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Oct 16]

Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #46
    Washed and Irrelevant D7
    PhantomPuppy
    • May 2012
    • 1955

    Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

    Originally posted by PrawnSkunk
    In addition to Halogen's response, since division boundaries are hard, you could be "demoted" if you are sitting at the bottom of a skill bracket and the boundaries are readjusted. It is also possible for your skill rating to be negatively affected if the ranking formula changes.
    hmmm im pretty borderline. looks like i gotta go get better scores to make sure that doesnt happen when the formula changes

    10th OT (D3): 13th
    11th OT (D6): 11th
    12th OT (D6): 6th
    13th OT (D7): 31st
    14th OT (D7): 25th
    15th OT (D7): LAST PLACE LOL
    16th OT (D7): LAST PLACE LOL


    Originally posted by Funnygurl555
    you know what they say

    under all the rust is really shiny...……… metal

    Comment

    • #47
      Rhythm game specialist.
      FFR Simfile Author
      FFR Music Producer
      TC_Halogen
      • Feb 2008
      • 19510

      Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

      so, another thing that I have thought of:

      This system needs another level of scaling for AAA equivalence -- particularly as the difficulty goes up. It goes without saying that a person getting mid-20s good count on something 95+ deserves more than a FEO/FMO equivalent. Devil's advocate because yes, they likely could AAA a song in that difficulty easily, but for the sake of balance...

      Comment

      • #48
        One-handed elite
        Guest15937
        • May 2008
        • 1523

        Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

        Originally posted by TC_Halogen
        so, another thing that I have thought of:

        This system needs another level of scaling for AAA equivalence -- particularly as the difficulty goes up. It goes without saying that a person getting mid-20s good count on something 95+ deserves more than a FEO/FMO equivalent. Devil's advocate because yes, they likely could AAA a song in that difficulty easily, but for the sake of balance...
        Yeah, I was about to bring this up...I don't really see how a 30g score is at the 0% mark when you need serious skill to get a 30g score on very difficult songs.
        The renegade has betrayed me.

        Comment

        • #49
          Administrator
          FFR Simfile Author
          FFR Administrator
          PrawnSkunk
          • Dec 2007
          • 3946

          Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

          Originally posted by Guest15937
          Yeah, I was about to bring this up...I don't really see how a 30g score is at the 0% mark when you need serious skill to get a 30g score on very difficult songs.
          This design choice was due to the lack of reliable data. The polynomial represented in the OP was carefully crafted using a wealth of community knowledge of how scores are relative to eachother linearly across all difficulties. That abundance of information becomes unpredictable when entering 30-40+ good-count territory (and is partially influence by educative mashing and pattern cheating). In order to modify the formula to adapt to this model, we would have to first collect data of impressive high good-count scores, and compare that data to the player's immediate actual skill. With the skill rating system, we will have the capacity to do something like this. With a concerted effort, we could foreseeable accurately weigh scores above 27g, but their impact would likely be negligible to the influence of SDG and teens scores.

          Simply ignoring all songs with a good count of 28 or greater is not a solution, and this is something I want to actively work towards solving.

          Comment

          • #50
            🥓<strong><span style="col
            justin_ator
            • Mar 2007
            • 7688

            Re: Skill Rating &amp; Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

            You all did some badass work on this, nice job.

            Comment

            • #51
              I like max
              25thhour
              • Feb 2007
              • 2940

              Re: Skill Rating &amp; Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

              Yay Max snap, come visit us from the dark alcoves of Langley Township. We miss you.

              but srsly wow, amazing job on this
              r bae adam bae max bae bridget bae claudia bae trevor bae adam2 bae mayo bae keith bae

              Comment

              • #52
                Stuck in the past
                FFR Simfile Author
                ItsOnlyDanO
                • Oct 2013
                • 1308

                Re: Skill Rating &amp; Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                I swear there are a bunch of people who are considered D7 who are now in D6 according to the update

                oh well
                Ghosts appear and fade away.......

                Comment

                • #53
                  Kawaii Desu Ne?
                  benguino
                  • Dec 2007
                  • 4233

                  Re: Skill Rating &amp; Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                  That polynomial approximation =3

                  Anyways, I just wanted to bring up one point made in the OP. It says that it's impossible to decrease your skill rating. However, isn't this still possible considering that scores are still being recorded using combo scoring and this measure of skill uses raw scoring? If someone "beats" their previous score with a better combo score but with worse PA, wouldn't their skill rating drop as a result?

                  Otherwise, I think this project is off to a great start and it appears to have relatively accurate results! Good job to all of those involved!
                  AMA: http://ask.fm/benguino


                  Originally posted by Spenner
                  (^)> peck peck says the heels
                  Originally posted by Xx{Midnight}xX
                  And god made ben, and realized he was doomed to miss. And said it was good.
                  Originally posted by Zakvvv666
                  awww :< crushing my dreams; was looking foward to you attempting to shoot yourself point blank and missing

                  Comment

                  • #54
                    🥓<strong><span style="col
                    justin_ator
                    • Mar 2007
                    • 7688

                    Re: Skill Rating &amp; Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                    I really think this should be coupled with a switch to Raw scoring on all stats....

                    Comment

                    • #55
                      FFR Veteran
                      dabomb2223
                      • Oct 2006
                      • 113

                      Re: Skill Rating &amp; Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                      Yo just wanted to pop in and say how sweet this is. I've been off and on this site for like 8 years now(?) and stuff like this definitely makes me want to keep coming back. It's sweet to see FFR improving and while I haven't taken part of any tournaments or anything, I now have Tier Points (what, I'm not good?) and I'm considered Division 2 (again with the bad thing.) So I think all in all this is a dang sweet update.

                      Comment

                      • #56
                        FFR Player
                        MinaciousGrace
                        • Dec 2007
                        • 4317

                        Re: Skill Rating &amp; Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                        hello if i may sugest something i would like the coloring of the me and my clan to be changed aweay from snail entrail green to something else

                        Comment

                        • #57
                          Don't forget me
                          kmay
                          • Jan 2007
                          • 6636

                          Re: Skill Rating &amp; Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                          so to move up the rankings you actually have to beat your top 4 scores.


                          now would 2 goods on a 74 be better than say 12 goods on a 78? i'm not about to do all this math lol



                          or is there a way to see your 4 best scores?
                          Last edited by kmay; 02-17-2015, 06:09 AM.

                          Comment

                          • #58
                            FFR Player
                            DDRNGGin
                            • Jun 2014
                            • 494

                            Re: Skill Rating &amp; Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                            This new leaderboard system is well-developed; although, the FFR rank on profiles are not being reflected by the recent system update.
                            Example: My current FFR rank is 1,586; however, my profile says the FFR rank is 5,274.
                            If someone can look into the matter, I would greatly appreciate it.
                            Last edited by DDRNGGin; 02-17-2015, 06:46 AM.
                            DDRNGGin's New Stats Information

                            Playstyle: Index

                            Current Level / Division: Level 73 (Division 5)

                            Highest AAA/PFC: Flight of the Bumblebee (Difficulty 80)

                            Highest Blackflag: AIM Anthem (Difficulty 76)

                            Highest SDG: Choprite [3-0-0-1] (Difficulty 70)

                            Highest FC (Non-mashed): BB Revenge [14-1-0-3] (Difficulty 80)

                            Comment

                            • #59
                              FFR Player
                              Zapmeister
                              • Sep 2012
                              • 483

                              Re: Skill Rating &amp; Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                              ok this seems like a brilliant idea but can someone explain heuristically why a score of 20 goods is supposedly that much better than a score of 28 goods or even 24 goods, and also why four scores are supposedly sufficient to determine a player's skill level when they could all be weighted towards the same set of patterns (like aim anthem, club, largiloqu-ican'tspellthisthing are all jack-heavy songs)

                              also your system assumes that the difficulty scale is multiplicative. i mean like if you have 2 people and one of them can comfortably aaa 30's and the other one can aaa 60's and you get the first person to play a 40 and the second person to play an 80 then they'll get roughly the same score. i'm not 100% convinced on this bit but that's just my impression so feel free to convince me otherwise.

                              sorry if i come across as overly critical, i really like the idea of sorting out ffr division placements once and for all, i'd just like more...... transparency

                              Originally posted by TC_Halogen
                              There are hard skill ranking cutoffs to get into a division.

                              The only reason you would get demoted is one of two possible reasons, in my mind:

                              a.) a song that was one of your top four scores gets removed from the game, or

                              b.) a score on one of those four songs gets forcibly removed
                              you forgot when someone lowers the difficulty rating of one of those four songs (as well as reuben_tate's raw scoring point, but that's probably a marginal case)

                              Theorem: If you have a large enough number of monkeys, and a large enough number of computer keyboards, one of them will sight-read AAA death piano on stealth. And the ffr community will forever worship it. Proof Example

                              ask me anything here

                              mashed FCs: 329

                              r1: 5
                              r2: 4
                              r3: 6
                              r4: 8
                              r5: 3
                              r6: 5
                              r7: 15
                              final position: 4th

                              Comment

                              • #60
                                For a New Beginning
                                FFR Simfile Author
                                Deidara837
                                • Jun 2008
                                • 1930

                                Re: Skill Rating &amp; Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 16]

                                Originally posted by Deidara837
                                Wait does this mean my Einstein-Rosen Bridge score is actually recognized, even with the miss? (5-0-1-6) Because currently my levelranks show 9-0-1-3
                                So I guess that's a no

                                _9th OT: D2 - 13th Place
                                10th OT: D5 - 45th Place
                                11th OT: D6 - 12th Place

                                EMG Rivalry | EMG Spreadsheet

                                Comment

                                Working...