03-9-2015, 05:47 PM | #11 | |
The Doctor
Join Date: Apr 2006
Age: 35
Posts: 6,145
|
Re: Skill Rating & Leaderboards Discussion [Updated Feb 17]
Quote:
A) Why have it decrease all the way to 0? Why not cut it off at 75% at the 28g mark? Someone could get 28g on RATO and it be beaten out by a Free Space AAA. Then again, someone could get 20g on RATO and have it beaten out by an 80 AAA B) The curve simply drops off too steeply, adding 1 point of difficulty adds more than 1g to your score. This will underrate players who don't whore for AAA's and overrate players than do. Ex. 16-18g on an 80 is about equal with a 64 AAA - just no way in hell those are in the same ballpark. For instance in my own, I would consider the more difficult song here the better score - #7 63 None Would Escape 6,243 1372 0 0 0 2 59 #8 67 Oops 6,237 1394 5 0 0 4 13 Adding 4 points of diffuculty should theoretically add more than 5-0-0-2 to your score on any given song. C) This system overrates a player's strengths and completely neglects weaknesses. Then again, everyone has strengths and weaknesses. However this system really shows how good someone is at their strengths, and not a measure of all around skill. For example, my jumpstreaming ability is just plain bad compared to my scores on non-JS charts in the FMO range. D) Suggestions - Fix the difficulties on many errant charts, especially in the lower range. The D2-D3 range is very off because of just a few charts (please fix party4u now that you can record a score without a background). Also because of this new skill system, I think there should be a mixed consideration for difficulty to AAA and Difficulty to SDG. I know OWA currently has spoken against this, but if our skill ratings are going to show this balance, why wouldn't the song difficulties to some extent? ABCDeath is a perfect example, and if it's showing up on many, multiple players top 4 songs, it's clearly overrated. I like the system, but it can certainly use some tweaking. It doesn't need a major slope change as the difficulty/PA drops, but it needs to be propped up some at least. |
|
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
|
|