Most Overated and Underated Games

[BlazeDrag414]

What do you think is the most overrated game and the most underrated game?

I think the most overrated game is Halo and the most underrated game is Suikoden.

[ShAiOnEi]

Overrated:Guitar Hero/rock band
Underrated:Foosball

[MystictheHedgehog]

Don't make multiple threads just because someone doesn't post in one immediately. Give it time.

Overrated- Halo 2 and 3.
Underrated- FF:Crystal Chronicles.

[DarkbearX]

By 'games' I'm pretty sure you mean video games.

If so... overrated: Final Fantasy VII. Underrated: Chrono Cross.

Suikoden's pretty underrated too I guess. Same with Wild ARMs.

[BlazeDrag414]

Oh sorry the other thread was an accident because I refreshed when I made the thread and it resent it or something.

[-Yukari-]

Holy ****, where have you been all my life? I looked at the title of this thread and voted Halo for overrated before it even loaded, and Suikoden is a great answer for underrated (although not my answer). Personally, I think Ephemeral Fantasia is ridiculously underrated.

[infinity.]

overrated: All the Metal Gear Solid / Call of Duty series
underrated: Katamari Damacy

[-Fallen-]

Overrated: StarCraft, WOW, Halo
Underrated: Can't really think of none, too many mixed emotions..

[fido123]

Halo I would say is the most overrated game
Most underrated game...The Orange Box for the general public. The people who have played it love it but most people don't even give it a chance.

[xplayfan]

Overrated: Gears of War, Halo series, Call of Duty series, Assassin's Creed
Underrated: Katamari Damacy, Zack and Wiki, Tales series

[meno_rocks123]

overrated: halo
underrated: startropics

[Relambrien]

Originally Posted by -Fallen-

Overrated: StarCraft

I have to disagree about Starcraft. Most people today don't even know what it is, much less have any respect for it, having come out in 1998 and all. Perhaps among its community it is somewhat overrated, but when there's a thriving professional Starcraft scene where thousands of people come to see the finals of tournaments played live, with thousands of others watching at home on TV, you kind of wonder if a game like that -can- be overrated.

Anyway, overrated games: Halo for sure, FFVII too. It was certainly a revolutionary game, but by today's standards, wouldn't be considered all that awesome. Good, but not awesome. People love it so much because of how great it -was-.

As for underrated games, definitely God Hand. It got somewhat-mixed reviews, but is by far the most hilarious game on the PS2 and an absolute blast to play. It might not have the best controls in the world, but they're not difficult to get used to. An amazing game that didn't get the recognition it should have.

Also, Sonic Adventure 1 and 2, at least among Sonic fans. Most fans tout these as the beginning of Sonic's decline, but I disagree. SA2 is the most fun I've had in a Sonic game, beating Sonic 3 & Knuckles by a long shot. I will admit though, after SA2, the series got really crap, really fast. Heroes, Shadow, and Sonic 2006 to name a few recent iterations of Sonic that sucked.

As for the most unrecognized game (awesome game that just didn't get attention, as opposed to being underrated), Skies of Arcadia for sure. My favorite game for a long time, but yet not many had heard about it. I only learned about it from a Dreamcast demo disc, actually. The combat system was very innovative for a turn-based RPG, the setting and story, while traditional JRPG fare, had its own special flair and style, with some added twists, to really allow you to enjoy it. It's a shame more people didn't know about it.

[lumphoboextreme]

halo is somewhat overrated but still a good game.

most overrated game probably call of duty 3.

most underrated game space giraffe

[Gibson63]

The most Over Rated Game is Stepmania
The Most Underrated Game Is FFR

[infinity.]

Originally Posted by Gibson63

The most Over Rated Game is Stepmania
The Most Underrated Game Is FFR

kill yourself

[MystictheHedgehog]

I definitely agree with Sonic adventure 2 being an underrated game. I love that one to death.

Here is another underrated one for you, Metal Arms:Glitch in the System. Yeah, it was a little glitchy, but for any of those that every played it, that game was pretty awesome, clever, funny, and actually fun. Seemed a bit like Ratchet and Clank yeah, but fun none the less.

Also Banjo-Kazooie and Tooie. Banjo-Tooie is in my top 5 of favorite games ever.

[psychopete]

Originally Posted by DarkbearX

overrated: Final Fantasy VII. Underrated: Chrono Cross.

Suikoden's pretty underrated too I guess. Same with Wild ARMs.

Effin' agreed about FFVII. Overrated, overrated, overrated.

Wild ARMs is underrated, but then again, 4 sucked so much that I refused to play 5.

Ontamarama is a pretty underrated DS rhythm game. I also find Final Fantasy Tactics Advance/A2 to both be underappreciated.

[infinity.]

Originally Posted by MystictheHedgehog

I definitely agree with Sonic adventure 2 being an underrated game. I love that one to death.

Here is another underrated one for you, Metal Arms:Glitch in the System. Yeah, it was a little glitchy, but for any of those that every played it, that game was pretty awesome, clever, funny, and actually fun. Seemed a bit like Ratchet and Clank yeah, but fun none the less.

Also Banjo-Kazooie and Tooie. Banjo-Tooie is in my top 5 of favorite games ever.

Banjo-Kazooie was rad man,
i used to love it, but some of the darker parts + creepy music scared me horribly when i was younger
ahaha

[Redorigami]

FFVII is WAY overrated.
Same with GH and Halo

Also, how did I have a feeling DbX was gonna beat me to the Wild ARMs? (omg my avi lol ya dumb ****s that have no clue what it is.) And pete, 5 is somewhat better than 4, not near as horrible. although it sucks in comparison to all the previous

[-Yukari-]

I was going to post FF7, but I felt Halo was MORE overrated because it isn't even very fun. Granted, FF7 isn't as good as people crack it up to be, it was still a really good game.

Chrono Trigger? You serious? lol. Chrono Trigger was humongously popular and even re-released on the Playstation. It is HAILED by SNES and Squaresoft fans alike.