Go Back   Flash Flash Revolution: Community Forums > General Discussion > Critical Thinking
Register FAQ Community Calendar Today's Posts Search

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 06-3-2007, 04:55 PM   #1
ledwix
Giant Pi Operator
FFR Simfile AuthorFFR Veteran
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: California
Age: 30
Posts: 2,878
Send a message via AIM to ledwix Send a message via Yahoo to ledwix
Default What's a soul?

I'm tired of seeing religious threads getting flamed for lack of evidence. I do agree that the recent thread topic was illogical through both religious and scientific reasoning. I do not, however, condone becoming judgemental about what every religion is. For reasons I may discuss later, I'd also like to address the following:

What is your view on what a soul is? Do you believe souls even exist? If so, what constitutes a soul? What animals, plants, fungi, etc. have souls? Where do you draw the line?

I'll provide my input in a bit.
ledwix is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 05:02 PM   #2
Kilroy_x
Little Chief Hare
FFR Veteran
 
Kilroy_x's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Colorado
Age: 32
Posts: 783
Send a message via AIM to Kilroy_x
Default Re: What's a soul?

A soul is a metanomic poetic construct, social device, and/or heuristic label for natural phenomenon outside the range of human perception.
Kilroy_x is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 05:02 PM   #3
Master_of_the_Faster
FFR Player
 
Master_of_the_Faster's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Storm Sanctuary!
Posts: 255
Default Re: What's a soul?

To me, a soul is a spirit in anything that can contribute to society and the environment (even if that means just existing) and can breathe. Because of my strict belief in logic or better yet "seeing is believing," I would say that souls either exist or don't, but I don't like to get involved in these situations unless there is evidence. How can a discussion on souls have more relevance in regards to religious and scientific reasoning compared to that of the last thread?
Master_of_the_Faster is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 05:05 PM   #4
Kilroy_x
Little Chief Hare
FFR Veteran
 
Kilroy_x's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Colorado
Age: 32
Posts: 783
Send a message via AIM to Kilroy_x
Default Re: What's a soul?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Master_of_the_Faster View Post
and can breathe.
Um. I'm not sure why I'm even bothering to ask, but how do you define "breathe"? Respiration occurs in a multitude of ways. If you define the process as broadly as possible, in terms of a process of combustion, then such things as rust and fire technically have souls.
Kilroy_x is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 05:12 PM   #5
Master_of_the_Faster
FFR Player
 
Master_of_the_Faster's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Storm Sanctuary!
Posts: 255
Default Re: What's a soul?

Well I meant a living being basically. I define breathing the way that you do so that statement was wrong and should be ignored.
Master_of_the_Faster is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 05:19 PM   #6
ledwix
Giant Pi Operator
FFR Simfile AuthorFFR Veteran
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: California
Age: 30
Posts: 2,878
Send a message via AIM to ledwix Send a message via Yahoo to ledwix
Default Re: What's a soul?

...so you define a soul as a living thing. Do your 100 trillion cells have individual souls? >___< That becomes problematic, as they are living things that don't perform any functions other than what they are programmed to do. I think a soul is something that contains not only an ability to willingly disturb its natural surroundings but desire to do so. Because of this, you could say that souls are entities that have the ability to think.

Last edited by ledwix; 06-3-2007 at 05:24 PM..
ledwix is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 05:28 PM   #7
Kilroy_x
Little Chief Hare
FFR Veteran
 
Kilroy_x's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Colorado
Age: 32
Posts: 783
Send a message via AIM to Kilroy_x
Default Re: What's a soul?

How do you prove that thinking isn't just reactionary though? A human being is reducible to their component processes, but somehow when you see all component processes together you manage to add them up to something greater than their simple combination.
Kilroy_x is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 05:32 PM   #8
Master_of_the_Faster
FFR Player
 
Master_of_the_Faster's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Storm Sanctuary!
Posts: 255
Default Re: What's a soul?

First off, this topic is just as seemingly unprovable as religion. Second of all, What if souls are exactly like people and that our cells are equivalent to a type of cell in each soul? Perhaps in my sense, these cells are a part of an entire soul (maybe souls of their own, but who knows?).

Last edited by Master_of_the_Faster; 06-3-2007 at 05:34 PM..
Master_of_the_Faster is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 05:34 PM   #9
jamuko
FFR Player
 
jamuko's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: あsdf。
Age: 34
Posts: 1,087
Send a message via AIM to jamuko
Default Re: What's a soul?

This looks like it could get into the matter of free will. You say your cells "don't perform any functions other than what they are programmed to do"; I don't think anyone would argue with that. But then take it to the next level... earthworms? They are alive, they appear to move in a way that shows free will, but their processes are very simple. Some would say that they are too low a level of life to have a soul, and only act out of "what they are programmed to do".

Take it another step up... birds? Small mammals? They also appear to have free will, but only act out of simple biological processes as well.

You can keep taking steps up the ladder of animal intelligence until you reach human life. Where is the line drawn? Who are we to say that we, as complex as we are, do honestly have a free will that isn't simply acting out of our biological instincts?
__________________
♪~
Always Happy! Smile! Hello!
I like delicious things
I shoot eye beams at the things I hate and make them explode! (Yay!)
So Happy! Smile! Hello! It's a picnic every day
There's lots of happiness in my pocket
So let's play forever~
jamuko is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 05:39 PM   #10
Master_of_the_Faster
FFR Player
 
Master_of_the_Faster's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Storm Sanctuary!
Posts: 255
Default Re: What's a soul?

Wow, very good point. I would have to say that we don't know if we just act out of our biological instincts or if there is any line drawn. I guess this is why humans shouldn't necessarily claim that they are the superior race. I wonder what it would be like if these animals had the ability to talk and think for themselves... or if we could give animals such a power.
Master_of_the_Faster is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 05:47 PM   #11
ledwix
Giant Pi Operator
FFR Simfile AuthorFFR Veteran
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: California
Age: 30
Posts: 2,878
Send a message via AIM to ledwix Send a message via Yahoo to ledwix
Default Re: What's a soul?

That something greater (an overall function being performed by all cells as a whole, such as my typing on this comp right now) is a soul. What I am doing right now is reacting to a statement and replying to it, true. However, you cannot scientifically explain to me why I am reacting this way, nor predict exactly what I will type, nor explain the concept of individuality. (If you can, go for it) If there is a set of laws determining the exact reactionary actions of a person or group of beings, one could tell his future, the future of mankind, the universe, etc. in EXACT detail. If you were to launch a lifeform out of a cannon, that human being would decide how to react, whereas an inanimate object would have a definite fate according to physics. If you set an object next to a cliff, a rock, perhaps, it would never jump off the cliff, since it had no soul. A being with a soul can decide whether or not to jump off the cliff.

Now consider this. I read in The Elegant Universe that if one knew the exact location and velocity of every single particle in the universe, that one could also know the location of each and every particle in the universe at ANY point in time, from distant past to distant future. Let us assume that a race of beings harnesses enough energy to travel around to individual sectors of the universe and detonate massive bombs, disintegrating and destroying every physical body imaginable. This would disprove the above theory, because you cannot describe this event through reactionary processes alone. The above statement should apply, given that there is no such thing as life. There is, though, and life is a gift. If it is not, then what are you doing right now? Existing without a purpose? Without goals, things to strive for, everyday actions? (Sorry, that might not be relevant)

Last edited by ledwix; 06-3-2007 at 05:51 PM..
ledwix is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 05:58 PM   #12
jamuko
FFR Player
 
jamuko's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: あsdf。
Age: 34
Posts: 1,087
Send a message via AIM to jamuko
Default Re: What's a soul?

If that is your reasoning, then you must believe that anything that grows has a soul. Do you believe all animals, bugs, and other life forms with unpredictable patterns all have souls? If you set an earthworm on the ground, you can't predict exactly where it will go, or how it will wriggle. Even the growth of plants can't be exactly predicted. Do you believe plants have souls as well? What about mold?

Everything that is alive on this earth is unpredictable to some degree. The world is not a simple computer; there are many variables that go into how a being moves and lives, and the more complex the being gets, the more difficult it is for our minds to get a grasp on, which is when the concept of "soul" seems to come into play.

Unless you believe that all living things have souls, you will need a better argument for what constitutes one.


Edit: Regarding your cliff scenario... if we're going to compare living things to inanimate objects, then what about artificial intelligence? It is conceivable that a robot or similarly programmed "inanimate object" could also make a decision of sorts to make the jump.
__________________
♪~
Always Happy! Smile! Hello!
I like delicious things
I shoot eye beams at the things I hate and make them explode! (Yay!)
So Happy! Smile! Hello! It's a picnic every day
There's lots of happiness in my pocket
So let's play forever~

Last edited by jamuko; 06-3-2007 at 06:02 PM..
jamuko is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 05:59 PM   #13
Master_of_the_Faster
FFR Player
 
Master_of_the_Faster's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Storm Sanctuary!
Posts: 255
Default Re: What's a soul?

Perhaps, most humans have the same repetative goals unless something outlined from some god. I mean we have jobs (some), eat, sleep, have certain hobbies, but what else is there? Probably nothing (which I would hate because humans are so impatient for a god to exist because we have so much fear about our population just dying). Sure humans have goals set by themselves to satisfy themselves, but do they serve any purpose if we all die out? For the most part, I don't think so.
Master_of_the_Faster is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 06:08 PM   #14
Kilroy_x
Little Chief Hare
FFR Veteran
 
Kilroy_x's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Colorado
Age: 32
Posts: 783
Send a message via AIM to Kilroy_x
Default Re: What's a soul?

Quote:
Originally Posted by ledwix View Post
That something greater (an overall function being performed by all cells as a whole, such as my typing on this comp right now) is a soul.
Any attempt to define which functions demonstrate a level of functionality equivalent to a soul is guaranteed to be arbitrary, or at least dangerously subjective.

Quote:
What I am doing right now is reacting to a statement and replying to it, true. However, you cannot scientifically explain to me why I am reacting this way, nor predict exactly what I will type, nor explain the concept of individuality.
So what? What I can't do today I can do tomorrow, so it goes in history. The label "soul" will exist for precisely as long as people can't give or understand the answers to that list you just gave me. That doesn't mean you as an individual, as the collection of your thoughts and answers, don't consist entirely of quantifiable phenomenon.

Quote:
If there is a set of laws determining the exact reactionary actions of a person or group of beings, one could tell his future, the future of mankind, the universe, etc. in EXACT detail.
The amount of calculations involved in determining such things precisely would be far beyond examination of just people, would also likely be far beyond even physical possibility.

Quote:
If you were to launch a lifeform out of a cannon, that human being would decide how to react, whereas an inanimate object would have a definite fate according to physics.
Lifeforms are reducible to physics. Organic chemistry is still chemistry.

Quote:
If you set an object next to a cliff, a rock, perhaps, it would never jump off the cliff, since it had no soul. A being with a soul can decide whether or not to jump off the cliff.
You seem to be equating complexity with a soul. This retains the problem, at what level of complexity does something have a soul?

Quote:
Now consider this. I read in The Elegant Universe that if one knew the exact location and velocity of every single particle in the universe, that one could also know the location of each and every particle in the universe at ANY point in time, from distant past to distant future. Let us assume that a race of beings harnesses enough energy to travel around to individual sectors of the universe and detonate massive bombs, disintegrating and destroying every physical body imaginable. This would disprove the above theory, because you cannot describe this event through reactionary processes alone.
... yes you can. What the hell do you think this race of beings are composed of, pure "soul"? No, they're composed of particles as well.

Quote:
There is, though, and life is a gift.
Cute.

Quote:
If it is not, then what are you doing right now?
Following mechanical laws outside of my range of awareness.

Quote:
Existing without a purpose?
I can give myself a purpose, I don't need to pretend there are purposes external to me.

Quote:
Without goals, things to strive for, everyday actions? (Sorry, that might not be relevant)
It's relevant, it just isn't a good argument.
Kilroy_x is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 06:11 PM   #15
Kilroy_x
Little Chief Hare
FFR Veteran
 
Kilroy_x's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Colorado
Age: 32
Posts: 783
Send a message via AIM to Kilroy_x
Default Re: What's a soul?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Master_of_the_Faster View Post
Sure humans have goals set by themselves to satisfy themselves, but do they serve any purpose if we all die out? For the most part, I don't think so.
Sure they have a purpose. They have the purpose of immediate satisfaction. And if human beings existence is finite, why must their goals be infinite? Why search for the meaning of human life outside of human nature?
Kilroy_x is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 06:17 PM   #16
GuidoHunter
is against custom titles
FFR Veteran
 
GuidoHunter's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Texas
Age: 36
Posts: 7,379
Send a message via AIM to GuidoHunter Send a message via Skype™ to GuidoHunter
Default Re: What's a soul?

Why can't they be infinite? I think the meaning/purpose of human life lies in nature (of which humans are a subset, of course), and is thus as infinite as the universe may be.

--Guido

http://andy.mikee385.com
__________________

Quote:
Originally Posted by Grandiagod View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by Grandiagod View Post
She has an asshole, in other pics you can see a diaper taped to her dead twin's back.
Sentences I thought I never would have to type.
GuidoHunter is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 06:19 PM   #17
Master_of_the_Faster
FFR Player
 
Master_of_the_Faster's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Storm Sanctuary!
Posts: 255
Default Re: What's a soul?

I personally believe that human beings can live for ever. I don't like people who use religion and oppression to enforce views on other because it delays this dream of mine. I don't believe that the definition of a soul or religion would be any relevance unless we find any type of proof of existance in either (in which it might still not help us at all). Imagine if you were a god who could live for ever in some heaven like place. Would you honestly still be debating souls or religion (in which case no one would be harmed by your inaction or helped by your action)?
Master_of_the_Faster is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 06:32 PM   #18
Kilroy_x
Little Chief Hare
FFR Veteran
 
Kilroy_x's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Colorado
Age: 32
Posts: 783
Send a message via AIM to Kilroy_x
Default Re: What's a soul?

Quote:
Originally Posted by GuidoHunter View Post
Why can't they be infinite? I think the meaning/purpose of human life lies in nature (of which humans are a subset, of course), and is thus as infinite as the universe may be.
The universe most likely isn't infinite, and even if it was life would always be able to expand only in some proportion which, relatively speaking, is finite compared to the universe.
Kilroy_x is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 06:34 PM   #19
Master_of_the_Faster
FFR Player
 
Master_of_the_Faster's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Storm Sanctuary!
Posts: 255
Default Re: What's a soul?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kilroy_x View Post
The universe most likely isn't infinite
Why do you say such a thing? Even if it's true, why is it most likely (in regards to the fact that there is no shown evidence in the thread)?
Master_of_the_Faster is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-3-2007, 06:36 PM   #20
Kilroy_x
Little Chief Hare
FFR Veteran
 
Kilroy_x's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Colorado
Age: 32
Posts: 783
Send a message via AIM to Kilroy_x
Default Re: What's a soul?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Master_of_the_Faster View Post
I personally believe that human beings can live for ever. I don't like people who use religion and oppression to enforce views on other because it delays this dream of mine.
What dream is this?

Quote:
I don't believe that the definition of a soul or religion would be any relevance unless we find any type of proof of existance in either (in which it might still not help us at all). Imagine if you were a god who could live for ever in some heaven like place. Would you honestly still be debating souls or religion (in which case no one would be harmed by your inaction or helped by your action)?
You're arguing that advancement of human progress will ultimately lead to our ability to create an artificial paradise, rendering concerns about the human soul irrelevant? Well maybe, but that still doesn't mean there might not be truth or falsity about any given claim made about the soul. It just means the demand for such finding out through such deliberation has been supplanted by an alternate demand which is preferred because it is attainable.
Kilroy_x is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:40 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright FlashFlashRevolution