TWG CLIX: Form your special exclusive groups now! - Game Thread

[ShadoWolfe]

So much Wine, so much bait, sooo much wiiiine iiin froont of meeee.

[Charu]

A tease, or a "fuck you"?

Vote now on your phones

[_Zenith_]

???????????????

[Charu]

What're you question-marking about?

[Hakulyte]

Things that have caught my attention last EoD;

Revisiting mellonxcollie:

Originally Posted by Gradiant

I also have not been liking how mellon's been posting, and the interactions between her and both shado and freezin have come across as awkward

Originally Posted by Precarious

Reread pt. 2

...

Mellon reappears. I find it hilarious that they argued for not needing to be taught mechanics when they clearly never read what I said to begin with. I'm not going to rehash that whole thing again, but #297 is a bad post. What's really troublesome though, is that mellon's whole demeanor changes later in the thread. I interpreted mellon, based on the early shit posts and this post, to be someone who was largely unfamiliar with mafia/TWG. The attack on me later was too self-assured tonally. I don't know what this inconsistency means, but I end up questioning the sincerity of 297 as a result.

I suggest rereading Page 15/16. I know I post dumb things from time to time, but is she on the same level as me for these things?

Originally Posted by DaBackpack

I'm not gonna be back in time

but I think juckteris a bad idea

Originally Posted by DaBackpack

I'm fully going to sheep charu here

Originally Posted by DaBackpack

shadow

It would be nice to know what you had in mind while all of this that happened.

[_Zenith_]

Originally Posted by Charu

What're you question-marking about?

Your post made the game stop so everyone is like, dumb?

Is that mean? You guys literally stopped posting as if this wasn't a game for a moment lmfao.

[Hakulyte]

Originally Posted by _Zenith_

Am I really invisible? I shouldn't be

Going to request a read list from you or even a couple of quotes with thoughts in general when you're done reading if you are not yet.

[Hakulyte]

Originally Posted by _Zenith_

Your post made the game stop so everyone is like, dumb?

Is that mean? You guys literally stopped posting as if this wasn't a game for a moment lmfao.

I think Shadow said he was about to go so, he probably left to work.
roundbox just left the thread.
I went back to rereading the thread like I mentioned yesterday.

[Hakulyte]

Zenith for President of White Noise.

[juckter1]

I'm back on a thing with an actual keyboard, I'll read some isolations in a bit, but before I do that

Precarious, could you please answer my question I asked a long time ago?

Originally Posted by juckter's question he asked a long time ago

yo dude, why did you unvote DBP when you were just pushing on him the day before?

You might think my question, my game, or even my entire existence as a human being is shit, but I still find that weird about your interaction with DBP, and I actually want to know the answer.

pls notice me Precarious-senpai

Originally Posted by ShadoWolfe

long-ass post about wolf Charu doing a gambit

While I think Charu doing that gambit is way more risky than you seem to think, that post was way funnier than it probably should have been, +1 for that mate

Okay, I'll read some stuff now, but I'll be around if you guys want to address something directly at me in the meantime

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

I think Shadow said he was about to go so, he probably left to work.
roundbox just left the thread.
I went back to rereading the thread like I mentioned yesterday.

No work today, just running a bunch of errands. I'll be back in a couple hours or sooner, then more shit to take care of, then back to TWG

[juckter1]

oh, the game's actually dead right now, I guess I'll just finish my ISOs in silence

[Hakulyte]

hi Juckter1, can you tell me why you missed EoD last night? (geez, I feel like a parrot.)

[juckter1]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

hi Juckter1, can you tell me why you missed EoD last night? (geez, I feel like a parrot.)

I mentioned it briefly on my first post today, I was feeling like crap the last couple of days, and on Saturday in particular I felt fucking terrible. I'm feeling alright now though.

[Hakulyte]

lmao, I somehow missed that page all along.

Didn't even see Zenith's read list as well.

[Hakulyte]

mfw DFR voted mellonxcollie and that I brought up the same thing later on without seeing him post about it.

[Hakulyte]

Originally Posted by _Zenith_

Okay I'm caught up.


1. Hakuright (Hakulyte) - Slight Wolf
2. SurelyWolfe (Shadowolfe) - Really sketched out
3. danceflashgun (danceflashrevo) - Haven't seen enough
4. Charuzard (Charu) - Pfft
5. DaKnapsack (DaBackpack) - Haven't seen as much as I'd thought rereading
6. PriCARius (Precarious) - Interesting, leaning town
7. boundrocks (roundbox) - Slight town
8. ho246 (botchi246) - Haven't seen enough
9. Sell?Nah (XelNya) - My radar tells Xel is rather interesting, pure null right now (needs isolation)
10. Lucker1 (Juckter1) - Haven't seen enough
11. melanxcholy (mellonxcollie) - Haven't seen enough

Oh okay, so, you're like a 2nd XelNya. Considering the activity/replacement card, you're down to Null to Wolf for me.

I may leave Shadow alone this phase, especially if he can prove his 1 shot-vigi and no one counterclaim.

If I'm slightly wolf for you, you should build me a case.

I'm not talking about the rest of your read list because it sounds like copy/pasta.

[mellonxcollie]

Just got caught up to the thread. That was quite a bit to catch up on. but I'll comment on this for now.

Originally Posted by danceflashrevo

Quick response, to not wanting to talk about it ("but that's kind of a dumb thing to be concerned about if you ask me") then to shit post ("we should play a game where we all pretend to be afrobean"). Then when gradiant pressures further into it, she basically responds with "i misread it" again. A lot of her interaction just seems weird but that could be due to sick meds which is understandable

I really did misread it. Don't know what else I can say about that one. it was stupid. I thought the best course of action after messing up like that would be just to be honest.

Originally Posted by danceflashrevo

Says that the day 0 interactions seemed pointless, gets traction from charu, then she switches to "nonono misread lolol" and says something that doesn't follow her logic imo. She seems to want to dismiss them but then says that she's not. Her phrasing was off and that leads to a lot of awkwardness (as to what's pointless, what she actually thinks about the interactions).

That was poor wording on my part. I never meant to imply that I thought the interactions themselves were pointless.

When I made that statement I was basically trying to say that I found the interactions hard to follow. because of their content and the circular nature of many of the arguments. I didn't switch my position or try to say that I misread anything. However I definitely could have phrased that post in a better way because in hindsight I see how it can be interpreted that way.

I never wanted to dismiss those interactions. I was trying to make connections within those interactions and that is what was giving me a hard time to begin with.

Then she has an argument with precarious over theory stuff (gut reads and whether they're good or not). But I feel as though she's happy to start conflict in this way because it looks like she's being assertive when really she's not being attacked in any way. She doesn't have to mask her role, just has to talk about what she believes is the best way to play the game. (This interaction can be seen pages 31 and 33).

I understand your point against me here. Precarious's posts bugged me and that is why I responded in that way, lol. That's pretty much all there was to it.

Turns out he is just using a different definition of "confirmed" than I do. Really, we agree with each other.

I wasn't here for EOD because it was Saturday night and I was out with my friends. We were supposed to go to Round One, a super cool arcade with a lot of rhythm games. We didn't know we needed ID to get in so even though we are all above 21, and not even planning to drink, we didn't all have our ID so we didn't get to go (protip for anyone who tries to go to Round One after 10 pm). We did still end up partying though when we just came back home.

It's pretty clear about how I feel about phases ending on Friday and Saturday nights, especially Saturdays. but oh well what can ya do

Lots of other interesting stuff has happened. gotta take some time to process and get some wine

[Hakulyte]

Originally Posted by roundbox

Haku I think you're giving too much positivity to the metric of activity for towniness. Most of your reads are strictly attached to this metric. You might want to reconsider

Okay, DFR is back to Null to Town because I don't believe he's suicidal enough to fake wolf.

I just wonder if he has patterns with faking threats in general.

Stuff like:

Originally Posted by danceflashrevo

if you think this is my wolf game you're in for a fuckin treat when i actually roll wolf holy shit

This is very wifom-ish to me and I can't tell if it's a slip or if it's him being like "are you serious?"

[Precarious]

Going back through earlier today. Updated reads soon.

Originally Posted by Charu

So out of all the people that voted shadow, do you think any of them had wolf-y intentions?

This partially depends on whether Shado is town or wolf, and given the vig claim (unless something has happened that I haven't read to yet), it's not a good idea to lynch him today anyway.

The biggest issue regarding Shado votes would basically be opportunism. It's not clear how much that played in, given that everything happened basically instantaneously, but a ton of people were reading Shado to various degrees of wolf, so it was a superficially safe place to park a vote--at least, no one would really question the decision, given all the suspicion.

It's hard to believe that the wolves would thrown Shado under the bus at that point; there were enough opportunities to lynch a non-wolf without issue that I don't think they'd have arrived at that point (particularly given no communication + the ultra last minute nature of the votes). If there were any votes on a Shado that's a wolf, they were probably of the "look I voted Shado who turned out to be a wolf, it's not my fault no one else did" variety.

If Shado's town, then the general safeness still applies (people wouldn't pick up too much heat for the mislynch). Again, it comes down to a safe place to park a vote, and if Freezin was more likely to be lynched (which certainly seemed to be the case until last minute insanity), then there was even less reason to call out the vote.

Of the three Shado voters, Freezin is dead and cleared by flip. Backpack voted Shado without warning (reversing from a Freezin vote and changing the calculation by two). Botchi voted Shado after a brief post.

Although I voted Botchi, I find DBP's vote more suspicious, given that it fundamentally changed the situation, and was done without warning or explanation, from a player who had been largely absent. However, DBP did note that he was debating between Freezin and Shado earlier in the thread.

I still have some misgivings about both, but neither vote is inherently terrible on its face (that's one of the problems with the last minute thing, though--it prevents any reaction to those votes, which might have revealed more). I wouldn't be surprised if there's a wolf between the two of them, but not because of the votes.