Stepping Stones of Stepmania (Submissions Open!)

[ilikexd]

starting university so no time for sm, and lots of stress

it would be funner if my wrists didn't feel like Twenty Knives were penetrating them

[mi40]

just remember

u are not a lemon

and that is what matters

[XelNya]

Originally Posted by mi40

opening (xelnya) - rejected
66 seconds of pretty much.. nothing.. i expected some kinda epic orchestra to come in but it never came, chart is fine but song choice is def. not what we're looking for here, sorry

Well it's nice to know the chart is fine at least. Thanks

[rCaliberGX]

Sent Kirlian Voyager v2. Tweaked the layering in the ending and changed the trill. I removed the jump, but made it 13131313 instead of 24242424 so that the minihold going to the piano is still pitch relevant. Also included the cdtitle.

[rCaliberGX]

Are files with xmod gimmicks ok? Making a file atm, and the area I want to have gimmicks is only in 1 portion of the song which is like 15 seconds.

[mi40]

xmod gimmicks are fine

[rCaliberGX]

gr9 now i have to find someone willing to xmod my file when i finish it since i can't do it all all

[Fission]

review my file juicy ji

[mi40]

daybreak (fission) - accept w/ minor fix
- missed sound at 38s i think
- check rhythms @ 88s ish <<< look @ this pls, do like 0.7 rate or something
- pretty nice and mellow, reminds me of shortcuts a lot
- you left out song author in the sm
- i havent checked all the pr cause i suck at pr but you should look over pr carefully cause it's a piano file after all

kirlian voyager v2 (rcalibergx) - still need a few fixes before fully accept
- things i didnt notice before!
- ghost note @ 59.541s/63.454/64,578/67.367s/83.019s..... i think this repeats in a lot of other places
i know what you're doing with these but they are barely audible even on 0.5

-check patterns @ places like 91.7s, the 4[34][124] is kind of hard to hit for some people, if you're gonna layer those 3 sounds in the rising fashion just do 4[34][134] so that the hand is easier to hit without much thought... same thing happens @ 92.965s, the 4[34][123] is really tricky to hit, just change it to something like 3[23][123]
^ this occurs in a lot of places as well

[Fission]

Originally Posted by mi40

daybreak (fission) - accept w/ minor fix

coolio

Originally Posted by mi40

- missed sound at 38s i think

i'll check when i get home. this might have been a conscious decision.

Originally Posted by mi40

- check rhythms @ 88s ish <<< look @ this pls, do like 0.7 rate or something

i'll also check this. if it's that weird 4 color note thing, i can understand thinking that.

Originally Posted by mi40

- pretty nice and mellow, reminds me of shortcuts a lot

thanks

Originally Posted by mi40

- you left out song author in the sm

d'oh. silly me, will fix this right away.

Originally Posted by mi40

- i havent checked all the pr cause i suck at pr but you should look over pr carefully cause it's a piano file after all

i redid some sections multiple times, so i think i got the PR as good as i could get it.

the layering was unorthodox but you didn't comment on it, so i'm guessing you understood what i was trying to do.

[rCaliberGX]

Originally Posted by mi40

kirlian voyager v2 (rcalibergx) - still need a few fixes before fully accept
- things i didnt notice before!
- ghost note @ 59.541s/63.454/64,578/67.367s/83.019s..... i think this repeats in a lot of other places
i know what you're doing with these but they are barely audible even on 0.5

Half expecting this. I put the ghost notes there to differentiate/break the monotony of the drums. Some of the 16ths after the snare hands are going to the background piano, though.

-check patterns @ places like 91.7s, the 4[34][124] is kind of hard to hit for some people, if you're gonna layer those 3 sounds in the rising fashion just do 4[34][134] so that the hand is easier to hit without much thought... same thing happens @ 92.965s, the 4[34][123] is really tricky to hit, just change it to something like 3[23][123]
^ this occurs in a lot of places as well

Agreed. the jump before the hand is a side effect of layering the piano on top of the drums, but I can change the patterns also.

I'll send v3 after I finish fixing up some other files in other packs.

[mi40]

yea send those fixes in and we're good to go
the ghost notes in kirlian voyager gotta be fixed 100%

[rCaliberGX]

Sent v3 w/ fixes.

[Kraezymann]

Soooo, just wondering what the gfx situation for this is like? I can help, if you want

[mi40]

i'll link you to a link with all the current files we have
you and necros can pump out gfx sets

[rCaliberGX]

Also make new sets for Mirror Mirror. The current ones are placeholder.

[Fission]

i sent a revision for daybreak, review pls

[mi40]

ok

[rCaliberGX]

Sent another file.

[mi40]

k i finish reviews tonight after league