Keyboard Collaboration III

[cuivien2]

sat down today and played the entire pack... Here's my thoughts:

Top score 10. Notes taken after first time playing the song and are based PURELY on my own
feelings, nothing fancy...

-be quiet: very fun and all that in the beginning, then got gay with all the jumps... 7 or 8
-beautiful synergi: kinda generic sharpnel file, but kinda fun as well because of some
unexpected patterns. a solid 8
-can't compete: as a indexer, I can't really judge this, but it seemed like the creator thought
"OMG let's make some retarded jumps***" and then acted upon it. 2
-code red: one word: boooooring. got a big fat b on first try, probably won't play again for a
looong time. 5 or something
-doll's wish: hmmm.. did I like it? not quite sure, but gonna play it some more. Addictive
streams
-don't say anything: not sure about the song, but LOVED the steps. blackflag on first try, but a
ton of perf. high 8, low 9, maybe the song will grow on me...
-eclipse: gah, seen it before.. different song, but same feeling to the stepchart, and I didn't
like it last time either.. 4 or 5
-empathy: my brain fell asleep during the freezes in the middle and I got owned by the massive
attack of boring jumps. 3
-ernst: oh wow, if and when I decide to swith to 4-finger setup I will whore this song. as it
is, it's kinda boring, but I imagine a good song for some skilltraining. 5
-exotic ethnic: beginning and end were made perfectly to go to the music. Congrats. However, the
middle is just gay. redo, and I will give it a 9, but now? 6
-extork: what happened with you during the song making? It started great, but went
downwards...the steps are decent, but I'm guessing 100 jumps could be removed and it would be a
better file. low 7
-final countdown: VERY fun steps, and even though it's eurobeat, I just have to give this a
shining 10
-fun fun pharaoh: now I feel akward for giving a 10 for the previous song. The minihammers
caught me offguard, but a great file! 10?
-gigadelic: well, the best version I've tried, but the ending jumps..? 6
-happy hardogs: not much to say. a solid 8
-happy rainbow: It's been done before.. 7 because I got 7 less :P
-hardware store: oh. what happened? oh well, the next time I'll play another version. Not very
indexfriendly. Loving the song, but.. 5
-identity: didn't finish the song, so I could be mistaken, but now that's a repeating file! 8ths
going stepstepstepstepjumpstepstepstepjumpjumpstepstep...zzz 4
-istanbul cafe: weird. The theme reminded me of Arrabiata, but the steps are very different and
kinda crazy. However, nicely done. 7 or 8, I'm not sure...
-japanese matafacka: japanese rave, what's there to say? steps follow the beat, but boring song
kinda destroys possibillities of good steps.. 6
-jurs op: Only one small problem with this, and that's the 16th jumps in the end of the midpart.
9
-last message: solid file. Fun as well, but not the "wow"-factor. High 8
-loaded futurefile: well, I failed utterly with a machinescore of 47xx. and the song was boring
as well. 2
-Love fighter: top 3 files so far hiiigh 9, maybe 10
-Love magic: generic, and weird small streams with jumps in the middle. low 7
-mad moon sonata: let those old composers die already! the steps are actually pretty ok, but I'm
sooo tired of playing yet another remix of a classical song.. 5 or 6
-moon child: good file. 8
-none would escape: I survived. However, this borders on crap IMO. jumpstreams like that is NOT
fun. 3
-Playing Inside: simple, yet great. 9
-policy in the sky!: wee, another sharpnel file.[/sarcasm] 7?
-red zone: say speedrave? :P cheesy, but I liked the song, Too bad that the steps were nothing
more than decent... 7
-socopogogo (+ some !'s): steps were crap, but went along nicely with the song. 4
-summer vacation: Liked the "original" from KBMP much better. 5
-The least 333 sec: hyped? I loved the song, and kept hoping for some index-areas which never
showed up. As a indexer, nothing more than 5
-tristram rock: I love it 10
-under control: I'm not a huge fan of metal, but found myself wanting to play this again. 8
-vijore: felt like I've played this before. 5
-vordhosbn: crap. 2
-we met dat night: wow! Different? Check. Fun? Check. Well synced? Check. 10
-what do you really want: actually a good file, but the jumps are overdone a few places. 7
-Why did you go away: Ageha + jumps... 5
-you are: less generic than above. actually it's pretty damn good. brb playing it again 9
-z: already have better version. nothin spectacular about this. 5
-zenius: sample sounded good, song was boring. steps jumpstepjumpstep = 3

[DiGiTaLSeraph]

ROFL how did you give beautiful synergie an 8? I stopped even bothering to read your review after that.

[Suzuru]

So you rate file low because it's not index friendly?　Lol

[T0rajir0u]

Rating a file low because it's hard is retarded. Noobs would rate Biaxident low.

[-Izzy-]

Because its fun. I agree with him on the most part for everything. We met dat night is definatly the best file in the pack. by a long shot. i hated just about everything else. Jurs op was fun to.

[Kil-]

i just jacked off

out came a simfile

[xMordecaix]

Originally Posted by Kil-

i took a ****** ****

out came luxemburg

8)

[xExigex]

Originally Posted by cuivien2

sat down today and played the entire pack... Here's my thoughts:

Top score 10. Notes taken after first time playing the song and are based PURELY on my own
feelings, nothing fancy...

-be quiet: very fun and all that in the beginning, then got gay with all the jumps... 7 or 8
-beautiful synergi: kinda generic sharpnel file, but kinda fun as well because of some
unexpected patterns. a solid 8
-can't compete: as a indexer, I can't really judge this, but it seemed like the creator thought
"OMG let's make some retarded jumps***" and then acted upon it. 2
-code red: one word: boooooring. got a big fat b on first try, probably won't play again for a
looong time. 5 or something
-doll's wish: hmmm.. did I like it? not quite sure, but gonna play it some more. Addictive
streams
-don't say anything: not sure about the song, but LOVED the steps. blackflag on first try, but a
ton of perf. high 8, low 9, maybe the song will grow on me...
-eclipse: gah, seen it before.. different song, but same feeling to the stepchart, and I didn't
like it last time either.. 4 or 5
-empathy: my brain fell asleep during the freezes in the middle and I got owned by the massive
attack of boring jumps. 3
-ernst: oh wow, if and when I decide to swith to 4-finger setup I will whore this song. as it
is, it's kinda boring, but I imagine a good song for some skilltraining. 5
-exotic ethnic: beginning and end were made perfectly to go to the music. Congrats. However, the
middle is just gay. redo, and I will give it a 9, but now? 6
-extork: what happened with you during the song making? It started great, but went
downwards...the steps are decent, but I'm guessing 100 jumps could be removed and it would be a
better file. low 7
-final countdown: VERY fun steps, and even though it's eurobeat, I just have to give this a
shining 10
-fun fun pharaoh: now I feel akward for giving a 10 for the previous song. The minihammers
caught me offguard, but a great file! 10?
-gigadelic: well, the best version I've tried, but the ending jumps..? 6
-happy hardogs: not much to say. a solid 8
-happy rainbow: It's been done before.. 7 because I got 7 less :P
-hardware store: oh. what happened? oh well, the next time I'll play another version. Not very
indexfriendly. Loving the song, but.. 5
-identity: didn't finish the song, so I could be mistaken, but now that's a repeating file! 8ths
going stepstepstepstepjumpstepstepstepjumpjumpstepstep...zzz 4
-istanbul cafe: weird. The theme reminded me of Arrabiata, but the steps are very different and
kinda crazy. However, nicely done. 7 or 8, I'm not sure...
-japanese matafacka: japanese rave, what's there to say? steps follow the beat, but boring song
kinda destroys possibillities of good steps.. 6
-jurs op: Only one small problem with this, and that's the 16th jumps in the end of the midpart.
9
-last message: solid file. Fun as well, but not the "wow"-factor. High 8
-loaded futurefile: well, I failed utterly with a machinescore of 47xx. and the song was boring
as well. 2
-Love fighter: top 3 files so far hiiigh 9, maybe 10
-Love magic: generic, and weird small streams with jumps in the middle. low 7
-mad moon sonata: let those old composers die already! the steps are actually pretty ok, but I'm
sooo tired of playing yet another remix of a classical song.. 5 or 6
-moon child: good file. 8
-none would escape: I survived. However, this borders on crap IMO. jumpstreams like that is NOT
fun. 3
-Playing Inside: simple, yet great. 9
-policy in the sky!: wee, another sharpnel file.[/sarcasm] 7?
-red zone: say speedrave? :P cheesy, but I liked the song, Too bad that the steps were nothing
more than decent... 7
-socopogogo (+ some !'s): steps were crap, but went along nicely with the song. 4
-summer vacation: Liked the "original" from KBMP much better. 5
-The least 333 sec: hyped? I loved the song, and kept hoping for some index-areas which never
showed up. As a indexer, nothing more than 5
-tristram rock: I love it 10
-under control: I'm not a huge fan of metal, but found myself wanting to play this again. 8
-vijore: felt like I've played this before. 5
-vordhosbn: crap. 2
-we met dat night: wow! Different? Check. Fun? Check. Well synced? Check. 10
-what do you really want: actually a good file, but the jumps are overdone a few places. 7
-Why did you go away: Ageha + jumps... 5
-you are: less generic than above. actually it's pretty damn good. brb playing it again 9
-z: already have better version. nothin spectacular about this. 5
-zenius: sample sounded good, song was boring. steps jumpstepjumpstep = 3

n00b.

If you thought Vordhosbn was crap, you're a n00b.

Yes, Code Red sucked, but Snapps wouldn't get off my balls about how I NEEDED to make a sim for it.

I think I was high when I submitted Can't Compete, and lolicy in the sky too.

Obviously you're not going to like it if you suck at SM and are a ******y indexer.

[DiGiTaLSeraph]

Holy crap, after reading Exige's post I just read... Lol. too good.

He said zenius was a boring song. XD STOP QUOTING him!

[Snapps]

ya fagit and im still on ur ass

[xExigex]

His avatar is ******y too.

[aperson]

Originally Posted by xExigex

His avatar is ******y too.

oh.

[xExigex]

Originally Posted by aperson

oh.

yeah.

[Snapps]

Originally Posted by xExigex

yeah.

yeah.

[dballin4]

Originally Posted by T0rajir0u

Rating a file low because it's hard is retarded. Noobs would rate Biaxident low.

Biaxident is a fun hard. NVLM **** is just hard. It also sucks the cock. The only questionable pass for me in this whole pack is Can't Compete and Zanthro's file with all the hands.

I said it before. Stepmania is a game. If you don't have fun why should he rate the file high? Passage D is the best simfile in existance by the way. It's accurate therefore it's gr8.

oh wait. =/

[cuivien2]

As I said before the review, I rated on how I felt playing it for the first time. If it's retardedly hard, but I still enjoy the way it's been made, I grade accordingly, but if it's hard PLUS boring, then I couldn't care less and thus grade low... A technical masterpiece that is boring to play is ultimatly a boring file IMHO

Oh, and I don't think I've played Biaxident, so can't say much about it

edit: @xExigex - Yup, I'm a "******y indexer", but I'm not going to change that unless I feel like it, and I don't feel much like it atm

[Bursurk_Lurk]

brb ignoring reviews by pure indexers

[DukAmok]

brb sweden

[dballin4]

Originally Posted by Bursurk_Lurk

brb ignoring reviews by pure indexers

k ;*

[Zanthro]

Why hasnt this been stickied yet? F5 was and this is better than F5.