TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

[mellon_collie]

Originally Posted by Shadow_God_10

I think you fail to realize how many anime girls I've seen with black hair,

I also have not seen Madoka Magica in nearly half a decade lmao.

You don't recognize waifus by hair, you recognize them by school uniform!!!! wtf

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by mellon_collie

It's definitely not an informed vote and don't think he is serious about keeping it on Wolfe forever, but idk. I guess the fact that he used actual reasoning instead of the standard meme vote where you just throw out a name. Those type of meme votes are pretty meaningless, but if he puts reasoning he can point back to it later in the game.

Idk I'm not putting much stake into this opinion but yeah

I don't have any sort of meta knowledge on WV but I took his vote on me as 10% serious, 90% meme if he's town. Meaning i sort of expected some comments on my "buddy buddiness" considering I had literally half the total player posts at the time I went to bed last night, and I saw his comment as meeting a good line between a bit of natural suspicion and plain memeing. So I took it more as an acknowledgement of my (potentially excessive) friendliness and a possible baseline for future thought, but not a serious vote as such

[Shadow_God_10]

Originally Posted by mellon_collie

You don't recognize waifus by hair, you recognize them by school uniform!!!! wtf

You can also recognize them by hair!

Take Rias Gremory for example, her hair is so recognizable you'd know it was her in a few seconds of looking!

[ShadoWolfe]

Him making his whole post a joke was pretty indicative of his seriousness in the vote itself I feel

[mellon_collie]

Originally Posted by Shadow_God_10

You can also recognize them by hair!

Take Rias Gremory for example, her hair is so recognizable you'd know it was her in a few seconds of looking!

And how well did that work out for you this time?? Not all waifus will have such distinctive hair! Especially dark haired hime cut, there is pretty much one in every anime. If you look at the uniform you know the anime right away. THEN look at hair for character specification

[flashflash account]

I'm town reading star tentatively
the idea that star is nagging haku just to pocket me is super paranoid so
just town read it and be wrong later

[Shadow_God_10]

Originally Posted by mellon_collie

And how well did that work out for you this time?? Not all waifus will have such distinctive hair! Especially dark haired hime cut, there is pretty much one in every anime. If you look at the uniform you know the anime right away. THEN look at hair for character specification

Why do I feel like I'm being lectured on how to recognize an anime girl....

[Shadow_God_10]

I'll be back in a bit... Gonna finish some anime and read the thread. Things got off to a quick start though, so I'll have to eat my words and say star-crossed was right in saying this game will have its own vibe to it.

[Shadow_God_10]

read the thread later**

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by Shadow_God_10

Why do I feel like I'm being lectured on how to recognize an anime girl....

With added disappointment and disdain that weren't able to recognize this specific one. It's a trip watching this even from the outside man

[flashflash account]

dbp

someone has to die and this would be funny

my logic is infallible

[mellon_collie]

Originally Posted by ShadoWolfe

With added disappointment and disdain that weren't able to recognize this specific one.

I gotta stick up for Homura <3 and as a man with 20+ waifus, I expected more from Lewdy himself!

Originally Posted by flashflash account

dbp

someone has to die and this would be funny

my logic is infallible

I don't hate this vote. I would like to hear more from dbp

[bugkid666]

Originally Posted by Wayward Vagabond

shadowolfe is way to excited kind of like a Labrador that is meeting people for the first time. Dogs are to close to wolves for my liking and right now I don't like him

Haku is soft town. Just his vibe and thread presence is really good. I like how his post about not losing his job really resonates with his town vibe. Just super sid

Bug kid is kinda sus. I don't like how they think having a life outside of twg is a big deal. Also she mentions school and backpack which is pretty Dora the explorer and I don't like it. Dora helps swiper become a better fox and foxes are practically wolves so bugkid is helping wolves and that's just not very town. Probably my second strongest wolf read other than Wolfe (who btw if you haven't noticed has wolf in his fucking name like Jesus Christ could you be more on the nose)

That's everyone who's posted so far. I haven't seen any other interactions between anyone else that I haven't posted a read on so either I'm early or everyone else is just waiting for me to post so they can contribute

going to hop on the "this has to be a meme post otherwise i'm losing brain cells" train

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by flashflash account

I'm town reading star tentatively
the idea that star is nagging haku just to pocket me is super paranoid so
just town read it and be wrong later

I agree with the town lean but I disagree with your logic behind it.
Namely I think that even if you're right, you're too locked onto the idea that Haku is necessarily wolf and shouldn't be extrapolating reads on others based on Haku = wolf 100%. IF haku is town, where does that put your read of star?

[flashflash account]

Originally Posted by ShadoWolfe

I agree with the town lean but I disagree with your logic behind it.
Namely I think that even if you're right, you're too locked onto the idea that Haku is necessarily wolf and shouldn't be extrapolating reads on others based on Haku = wolf 100%. IF haku is town, where does that put your read of star?

like most always it's not about the read, it's about the why
I'm town and see an off thing or two about haku

star calls the off thing or two out after I say "haku=wolf" which could be a joke from another's perspective
if I was wolf star I would try to pocket me by doing this, but I don't think wolf star does the same thing

[bugkid666]

Originally Posted by ShadoWolfe

Ew it's putting capital letters in my twg posts...
twg is the one place where I can write totally fucked up sentences with no syntax grammar or punctuation to speak of and chalk it up to being a dumbass and no one will care
fucking hell I have to manually undo its capitalization every line

/rant

my only semi read is that this feels very much like "don't call me sus because i'm suddenly capitalizing letters please" which is instinctively a bit wolfy. this is a reach tho

[star-crossed]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

#1 is mostly activity + how I vote. I'm not really organized in my intentions D0 so, I try to read and take everything for granted by default. I try to not do any level 2 thinking. I just react to everything I see surface level.
Just pretend I have autism and that my ability to read between the lines has been stripped from me for 1 phase.

#2 is mostly based on meta/how I view the game. Just because I think someone is town doesn't mean that they are, but people need to see how others view others to compare their own views or question further why I have these views. Solving town is meaningful because it narrows the possibilities for where to vote. If 4-5 people agrees that one player is town, there's a pretty good likelihood that they are. This is a lot easier to do early game than magically finding wolf team unless there's an obvious blunder.

gtg work

You still did not answer why you thought I was correct. And I get you are busy, but almost your entire post seems to be talking about things that are adjacent to what I am not liking with you, but not directly what I meant.

From a theory perspective, I agree with some of what you are saying about #2. However, even if I take your bugkid and Shadowgod leans to mean just that they are basically behaving how you expected them to, I still do not like it in context. With Shadow, you even found something that seemed odd on the surface, but softened the impact by saying you do not want to hang him overall.

[star-crossed]

Originally Posted by mellon_collie

It's definitely not an informed vote and don't think he is serious about keeping it on Wolfe forever, but idk. I guess the fact that he used actual reasoning instead of the standard meme vote where you just throw out a name. Those type of meme votes are pretty meaningless, but if he puts reasoning he can point back to it later in the game.

Idk I'm not putting much stake into this opinion but yeah

Sorry if this is pedantic of me, but what's not informed about his vote?

Originally Posted by flashflash account

I'm town reading star tentatively
the idea that star is nagging haku just to pocket me is super paranoid so
just town read it and be wrong later

This seems like such a self-centered take hahah.

[Shadow_God_10]

Originally Posted by mellon_collie

I gotta stick up for Homura <3 and as a man with 20+ waifus, I expected more from Lewdy himself!



I don't hate this vote. I would like to hear more from dbp

I second this notion, tbh.

Also all of us have forgotten that Zenith in this game and hasn't said a word yet.

I'd like to hear from him as well

[Shadow_God_10]

Also to make things easier for all of us, since we have Shado, and Shadow. Y'all can just call me Lewdy instead to keep things simple for everyone.