TWG CLXXIX: The Third FE Mystery Game Game Thread

[MixMasterLar]

Originally Posted by Xelicopter

he's arguably not wrong though

Originally Posted by Xelicopter

did not say it was a good idea

I feel like this is inconsistant

Please explain

[Xelicopter]

Originally Posted by FreezinIce

This is the truth. You have a way to confirm someone is not lying about their role and confirm them, and they tell you a lie. Are you supposed to swallow it and say "well OK you lied about your role, let's put a pin in this."

Or do you take the law into your hands and kill the snake.

Afro approved of our actions wherever he is. This is a case study of why Lynch all liars is not good meta, but at the time my thoughts were he was being evasive about his role so I iced him. Come at me

in a non mystery game it works rly well

in a mystery game it's lol

especially when the op says there's checks to punish you for being completely honest

[Xiz]

Hi

[_Zenith_]

Originally Posted by FreezinIce

This is the truth. You have a way to confirm someone is not lying about their role and confirm them, and they tell you a lie. Are you supposed to swallow it and say "well OK you lied about your role, let's put a pin in this."

Or do you take the law into your hands and kill the snake.

Afro approved of our actions wherever he is. This is a case study of why Lynch all liars is not good meta, but at the time my thoughts were he was being evasive about his role so I iced him. Come at me

DBP explicitly stated to not shoot Haku.

Charu backed this up saying to honor the man's wishes.

It was not honored.

It was a justified shot with very poor taste, but we didn't listen to DBP at all, we shot ourselves in our own fucking leg.

[Charu]

Originally Posted by Xelicopter

in a non mystery game it works rly well

in a mystery game it's lol

especially when the op says there's checks to punish you for being completely honest

Of course, which I said many posts ago Haku's actions were understandable. I think he went about it the wrong way though when he had a gun pointed at him.

If only he chose a white lie instead of a huge lie...

[FreezinIce]

Originally Posted by _Zenith_

DBP explicitly stated to not shoot Haku.

Charu backed this up saying to honor the man's wishes.

It was not honored.

It was a justified shot with very poor taste, but we didn't listen to DBP at all, we shot ourselves in our own fucking leg.

Stop being a weiner

[FreezinIce]

3 vests.

I rest my case. You guys have some serious hindsight bias

[Xelicopter]

Originally Posted by MixMasterLar

I feel like this is inconsistant

Please explain

you know what the fuck i'm going on about

vigi shot is double edged sword, sure it's a town role, but you miss more than like once and all of a sudden you may as well have been an extra wolf

[Xelicopter]

Originally Posted by _Zenith_

DBP explicitly stated to not shoot Haku.

Charu backed this up saying to honor the man's wishes.

It was not honored.

It was a justified shot with very poor taste, but we didn't listen to DBP at all, we shot ourselves in our own fucking leg.

goddamn this is the best post i've read today

[Charu]

Originally Posted by FreezinIce

Stop being a weiner

I kind of view it as when backpack accidentally let loose that 3/5 call for the first event. I was secretly hoping the wolves wouldn't do anything, but I think once they saw backpack, it all but confirmed their suspicion that everyone that would try, well... tried.

Just another bad town move due to rashness.

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by FreezinIce

You have a way to confirm someone is not lying about their role and confirm them

That's just the thing, him answering Ewan wouldn't have proven ANYTHING at all. If he had made up ALL of those lore-specific lies to get them to be precisely Ewan, he would've just answered Ewan and been done with it.

Instead, he literally quotes where it says sharing character names is bad and gets shot for it. He's right for not answering, too, because the item that lets you kill [specific character name] still exists and he did have a responsibility to protect his role. Instead, irrationality, bloodlust, and mob thinking got the better of all of you and you bumrushed him like a bunch of [insert expletives here]. That's on you.

Originally Posted by FreezinIce

Come at me

This is going to divert thread if I keep arguing it (and I'd keep arguing it) so we can save it for another time. This is my last post on the topic.

[Charu]

Originally Posted by FreezinIce

3 vests.

I rest my case. You guys have some serious hindsight bias

Haku stated this after two 15% shots went off.

Come on.

[Xelicopter]

Originally Posted by FreezinIce

3 vests.

I rest my case. You guys have some serious hindsight bias

well gee seems like some people didn't trust our confirmed player

wonder why that is

[Xelicopter]

I mean, I can think of a reason or two

I mean it's not like it was me in that slot

it's fucking dbp

i'mma go facepalm in a corner

[Xelicopter]

god I am such a prick rn

i'm making myself laugh

[Charu]

Originally Posted by ShadoWolfe

This is going to divert thread if I keep arguing it (and I'd keep arguing it) so we can save it for another time. This is my last post on the topic.

I should follow suit, maybe...

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by Xiz

Hi

Hi

[Celirra]

I dont think I ever even got a good reason on the tamb read lol

[blindreper1179]

Originally Posted by ShadoWolfe

That's just the thing, him answering Ewan wouldn't have proven ANYTHING at all. If he had made up ALL of those lore-specific lies to get them to be precisely Ewan, he would've just answered Ewan and been done with it.

Instead, he literally quotes where it says sharing character names is bad and gets shot for it. He's right for not answering, too, because the item that lets you kill [specific character name] still exists and he did have a responsibility to protect his role. Instead, irrationality, bloodlust, and mob thinking got the better of all of you and you bumrushed him like a bunch of [insert expletives here]. That's on you.


This is going to divert thread if I keep arguing it (and I'd keep arguing it) so we can save it for another time. This is my last post on the topic.

We also protective roles and the chance to take that item. And the main wolf with that power ALREADY died. Haku had nothing to be afraid of.

[FreezinIce]

Originally Posted by Charu

Haku stated this after two 15% shots went off.

Come on.

Woooooooshhhhhh