TWG CLXXIV - Sounds Like You've got a Problem. - Game Thread

[MixMasterLar]

Originally Posted by Wineandbread

Can you see why, in this situation, IC doesn't get killed? I think they would value cutting down blue numbers over the thread of IC on wolves in day phases.

You're not going to like my answer

Originally Posted by Wineandbread

Your vote logic doesn't seem sound to me. Why wouldn't they just shoot their own target instead of yours if they know they are 100% town, regardless of how towny you are? If she read the thread I'm sure she can form her own opinions, ie. inD.

Was InD her first pick?

My theory doesn't hinged on her sheeping me so this is a moot point anyway. I'm just saying that she had time to read the thread and make a shot and if we wanted to read deeply into it said shot hints that there could have been thought into it based off reading---that it wouldn't necessarily be random. The idea that Funny was a random shot when there where votes within the 1 vote range of most voted and one of her strong towns suspected funny doesn't mesh if we assume that Star DID IT.

Originally Posted by Wineandbread

If the top vote was 2 votes, wouldn't everyone even out of the votes be viable then? There were a lot of people that didn't vote. I don't think having a low vote top lynch necessitates lynching within the pool.

That could be a viable viewpoint for her to take. In our theory we know she chose Funny because Funny died. Unless she didn't shoot and wolves killed her.

But damn, there's that thing about wolves probably going FOR THE CLEAR FUCKING SLOT that makes me feel like we have a doctor/jailer/your role here and that someone else killed Funny so you know....