TWG CLXV - The Wine In Front Of Me - Game Thread

[thesunfan]

Originally Posted by Charu

Hey uh, the TRUE GAMER here could've told you all about BotW, jerk.

sry I'm a filthy casual I don't care for the TRUE perspective

[thesunfan]

I should have a better opinion on Yoshl and roundbox now that they're here BUT I DON'T

the only thing that stood out to me and this is pretty thin but I thought Yoshl's read on Freezin was like
more town than not because it had like, the perfect amount of annoyance mixed with reluctance in the read. I think wolf Yoshl could find that balance, but it happens a lot less often than town Yoshl finding that balance

that read might make no sense but idc

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by roundbox

shado I'd like to hear your thoughts on my re-entry as you were one of the people questioning my alignment due to absence

@raeko too I guess

Still judging tbh. Not exceedingly impressed with your ketchup quotes list, but I liked your reads and reevaluation. Also liked your regret at not having voted inD yesterday.
What do you think of inD being wolfread by basically everyone? Is that a determinant in your read of him?

[roundbox]

Originally Posted by thesunfan

I'm talking about how do you feel about the fact Shado backed down from his wolfread on Haku

I'm doing the same thing with Haku so I don't have a major problem with his approach tbh
I didn't realize shado also used arbitrary percentages in his reads as well. also not a fan of it as there's no need to quantify confidence

[roundbox]

Originally Posted by ShadoWolfe

Still judging tbh. Not exceedingly impressed with your ketchup quotes list, but I liked your reads and reevaluation. Also liked your regret at not having voted inD yesterday.
What do you think of inD being wolfread by basically everyone? Is that a determinant in your read of him?

it's not a determinant, nor does it really sway my opinion at this point
I'm not the biggest fan of my reads but I'm definitely not in the PARANOIA mindset nor will I be any time soon

[Litodude]

Stop hating on percentages they're real numbers theoretically

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by roundbox

I didn't realize shado also used arbitrary percentages in his reads as well. also not a fan of it as there's no need to quantify confidence

Lol I got it from Lito this game and will continue using them and encourage everyone else to do so as well.

We already attempt to quantify confidence arbitrarily using flawed, less precise measures. We list people by scumminess and use words like LOCK, read, lean, slight, strong, etc..
Listing people is flawed because there could be a huge gap in how scummy you think two people are, but their names being next to each other would indicate only that you think that's the order in which they should be lynched. YoshL ran into this problem earlier when he the me as 2nd scummiest (still find that weird but w/e). I asked him why, he said everyone but the bottom name was actually either null or townread.

Using words like read/lean, strong/slight is flawd because you end up with several people under the same category, some of whom you're more sure of than others,and the requirement of fitting everyone in one of those boxes/labels causes pressure to place people in places "because that's where they fit best".

Percentages, while arbitrary, at least clearly show how you feel about each player, and how confident you are. Where, brfore, you might say "null, slight scum", you could now say "55% wolf"
Where before you could get away with iffy read placements and just "null", you now get truly individualized reads and can indicate extremely slight differences between players.


TLR what we're doing now is just as arbitrary, and less accurate.
EVERYONE SHOULD USE PERCENTAGES!

[Charu]

I think ShadoWolfe is 5/7

[Hakulyte]

Originally Posted by Charu

Speaking of Haku, where he at? He's always so active when viewing the thread.

I bet he's guesting like a stalker!

I just woke up. You probably don't realize, but I was the only one posting all night until the morning.

Also, hi.

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by Charu

I think ShadoWolfe is 5/7

A perfect score?!
Wow dude, I don't think perfection is possible in humans but thank you <3

[Hakulyte]

I'm seeing a lot of paranoia right now.

I'm happy.

[Charu]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

I'm seeing a lot of paranoia right now.

I'm happy.

And why are you happy about that, sweet'ems?

[Charu]

By the by, you are NOT a 5/7 like Shadow

Tsk tsk

[FreezinIce]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

I'm seeing a lot of paranoia right now.

I'm happy.

dont be, a lot of it is directed at you for good reason

[Hakulyte]

Originally Posted by Charu

And why are you happy about that, sweet'ems?

You guys have been saying a lot of funny things, but I don't see any new game solving components.

Makes me believe I was right.

[Charu]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

You guys have been saying a lot of funny things, but I don't see any new game solving components.

Makes me believe I was right.

Yeah?

[Hakulyte]

Originally Posted by Charu

Yeah?

That's it.

[Charu]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

That's it.

Well okay, sweet'ems, you're wrong, but I respect your opinion nonetheless.

I'll just keep pretending I'm a wolf for you, how's that sound?

[Charu]

Kay fam, brb, driving home from work.

[Hakulyte]

Originally Posted by Charu

Well okay, sweet'ems, you're wrong, but I respect your opinion nonetheless.

I'll just keep pretending I'm a wolf for you, how's that sound?

Why am I wrong?

I made like 3 giant walls dedicated to you all 3 and I'm having trouble to not make it work.