TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

[Hakulyte]

..and that paints you as the vilain from calling her out for that very exact thing.

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

I really have nothing better than "she seems genuine" with 9 posts.

Exactly my point.

So, would you agree that it'd be a lot easier to read her if she would post a bit more?

[Hakulyte]

Well, go for it I guess.

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

What I see is a tilted town raeko who's tired of being wolf read from being called "UTR".

Look..

What I see is a tilted raeko who's tired of being wolf read based on activity.
I also see an excessively defensive raeko who specifically called me wolfish for saying "and mellonxcollie" in response to you saying you wanted to see more of Jade Harley.
I see that same raeko leaving after leaving a couple of seemingly genuine comments outlining how upset she is. If there's one thing she excels in, it's posting seemingly genuine comments about an event that affects her.

The way I see it:
a) she can start sharing her thoughts and posting some stuff in thread
b) she can continue to fixate on people wanting her to post more, leaving defensive comments, and disappearing after doing so
c) she can say she's busy, post a little tidbit here and there, and stay largely UTR

In cases b and c, I'm 100% fine with keeping my vote and seeing her lynched.
If case a starts to happen, I'll likely be moving my vote.

It's literally that simple.

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

Well, go for it I guess.

What're your thoughts on sunfan so far, if you don't mind me asking?

[Hakulyte]

I'm liking sunfan this game. I'm normally more wary of him, but I don't see anything strange about him. He's doing what I would expect a "town sunfan" to do.

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

I'm liking sunfan this game. I'm normally more wary of him, but I don't see anything strange about him. He's doing what I would expect a "town sunfan" to do.

What do you expect a "town sunfan" to do?

[Hakulyte]

- Make a post with general reads.
- Disagree with my bs.
- read me right pretty early.

[Hakulyte]

He hasn't done anything that I would consider weird at this point.

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

- Make a post with general reads.
- Disagree with my bs.
- read me right pretty early.

Is there anything on that list that you think a scumfan wouldn't do?

[Hakulyte]

He would null read me more.
He would sound more strange with how he's treating me.
His reads would look a bit less natural.

[AragakiAyase]

to build on 706, here are some recent examples

first one is the 2nd most recent turbo where I was cop, note how he thinks charu has done townie things but isn't great at reading him

Originally Posted by thesunfan

I have no opinion on juckter

Charu's done two townie things in a row (things I think he does as town) but I'm not great at reading him d0.

I'm gonna reread the beginning of the thread to see how I feel about the scumread I left on him earlier.

Originally Posted by thesunfan

after review I'd probably have my list like

Haku
Charu

Lar

Neee

-----

mellon
inDheart

above post is *very* interesting because it's the same order as this game wrt the top 3. just something to note, sunfan was a wolf in that game (time travel turbo)

[AragakiAyase]

fwiw I think sunfan's read list is fine, but there are some inconsistencies with how I think he approaches the game that I want him to clear up

[AragakiAyase]

shado can you point out specifically which things you think are generalizations by sunfan in his big post?

(also unrelated: VOTE IN THE TWG AWARDS IF YOU HAVE NOT)

[XelNya]

Originally Posted by ShadoWolfe

Ah. I'm p sure I covered that already. Looking forward to seeing more of Xel now that he's on.


Me asking her to post more is trying to work out her alignment. She chose to scumread me for it. How is that not her being defensive?
She agreed that it was defensive herself, so you can say I'm "shading" her if you want, but maybe consider what kind of responses from mellon are possible from calling her out as such. I literally generated content from a player who has, so far, only been in thread to say "hiyo" and defend herself by calling everyone who's noted her absence or mentioned her history of trying to go UTR a wolf.

Would like to calmly remind everyone that expecting in depth posts from me between 4 to 1 am server sunday through wensday is a good meme

[Hakulyte]

@sunfan

Page 7

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

Does anyone knows if Jade Harley is from another site or something?

Page 31

Originally Posted by thesunfan

ps Haku's right Harley is FreezinIce

Why did you wait that long to say so if you knew from the start?

[XelNya]

Originally Posted by ShadoWolfe

Unvote
Say what you'd like about lame/annoying metareads, but my vote's going on mellon if she doesn't start posting.

In the game she won as SK by being UTR, she told "her haters" to suck it up 'cause it worked out for her. The following game (FE), she was wolf again and won by replacing an inactive Zenith and remaining mostly UTR for the rest of the game. While I applauded that at the time, both times, what tends to happen when you play back-to-back UTR strats is that you neatly get that added to your meta. If you don't like it, play a couple of active wolf games to change your meta. As it is, I don't care how high the horse is you're trying to be on by saying that reading you by activity is annoying. Post, or get lynched.

Also welcome to my town pile

[Hakulyte]

Originally Posted by thesunfan

the other 3 are more "fry-squint" than scumleans

AA has said some things that I really didn't like, followed by explanations that make me feel a bit better about him. He initially posted about going afk because he felt a tunnel developing on shado, which I thought made no fucking sense for AA to do, but I think I misread what he was saying there. There was another one that I don't remember rn. He's not matching my expectations of him this game, basically. My weakest of the "fry squints," and if he's town I expect to be able to read him correctly sooner rather than later.

Xel is being underwhelming again but its again too early to say for sure. I don't care too much about his string of posts about queuing in Overwatch, but I do want it known that he would ABSOLUTELY do it as a wolf even though he was scumread for it last game.

Shado I've talked a little bit about already. The thing I dislike the most about him was where, honestly, it felt like he was trying to flip the table on me. He more subtly-than-not equated two things, one of which I said and one of which I didn't, and threw that back at me, relating sense of humor to personality. After seeing Shado wolf last game and during Secret Hitler in lTWG, I think that I have a much better grasp of his wolfgame than I did before. I think I even texted AA as such.

jesus this post took longer to type than I thought it would

Originally Posted by thesunfan

ps AA/shadowolfe being together is unlikely imo based on the interactions they had earlier today

That sounds funny.

[XelNya]

Originally Posted by thesunfan

Xel is being underwhelming again but its again too early to say for sure. I don't care too much about his string of posts about queuing in Overwatch, but I do want it known that he would ABSOLUTELY do it as a wolf even though he was scumread for it last game.

There's a really bad assumption about the overwatch queue post. And that's that you're even reading into it. It's a shit post mate. I'd make out of the field posts town or scum.

You'd also be considering me scum if I seem super invested in a game. There's a history.

Maybe it's just me but ever since that super invested early wolf game I got modkilled in I haven't had a strong d0. I actually tend to get lynched early on lately. Not that I sorta don't deserve it.

Anywho.

[XelNya]

Ps theres a lot of self meta there

Just denote frustration and move on.