TWG 150: Undertale

[TWG Mad Dummy]

Originally Posted by TWG Temmie

posting who you think is who with that list?

I mean... I'll take what I can get but shouldn't that be nonalignment indicative?

[TWG Tsunderplane]

Originally Posted by TWG Temmie

posting who you think is who with that list?

why does that have any indication on his alignment whatsoever

[TWG Tsunderplane]

Originally Posted by TWG Mad Dummy

I mean... I'll take what I can get but shouldn't that be nonalignment indicative?

HEY

GET OUT OF MY HEAD, BAKA

[TWG Alphys]

Originally Posted by TWG Temmie

posting who you think is who with that list?

[TWG Temmie]

...okay, my logic is terrible again >_>

[TWG Mad Dummy]

Originally Posted by TWG Temmie

...okay, my logic is terrible again >_>

maybe try and explain why it led you to being ok with me?

[TWG Napstablook]

Originally Posted by TWG Mad Dummy

maybe try and explain why it led you to being ok with me?

:eyeroll:

[TWG Napstablook]

[TWG Temmie]

Originally Posted by TWG Mad Dummy

maybe try and explain why it led you to being ok with me?

well, it seemed like you know what you were doing and trying to make some progress if you went through re-reading everything to make a list
actually I just realized that if you said figuring out who's who isn't really relevant then you sort of contradicted yourself

[TWG Mad Dummy]

Originally Posted by TWG Temmie

well, it seemed like you know what you were doing and trying to make some progress if you went through re-reading everything to make a list
actually I just realized that if you said figuring out who's who isn't really relevant then you sort of contradicted yourself

that list was made in notepad just for my own personal amusement through the course of the game. I usually do this in anon games.

Trying to figure out your identity specifically no longer matters because you're confirmed Monster. I think its at least somewhat important to figure out other people's, if possible, but I have to admit that I haven't had a clue on you and now I don't particularly care to find out unless it happens to come to me out of nowhere.

[TWG Mad Dummy]

At risk of giving a stroke, my reread of the thread is very quickly turning into a case on Undyne

[TWG Mad Dummy]

of giving Alphys a stroke*

[TWG Tsunderplane]

Originally Posted by TWG Mad Dummy

At risk of giving a stroke, my reread of the thread is very quickly turning into a case on Undyne

would you like to share your case with the rest of the class

[TWG Alphys]

nah not yet, he's got plenty of time

[TWG Mad Dummy]

Originally Posted by TWG Tsunderplane

would you like to share your case with the rest of the class

right now, its based on three things. The first is the string of posts from #398-401 is a bit weird in regards to reacting to Mettaton's world. Undyne has dropped a vote as the phase has ended for the first three phases (I am including the phase where Sans was insta'd). This feels like it has to be prepared. His response to Mettaton at the time was "Lol why would I not vote at EOD," which contradicts the rest of his play, especially considering he even made a post at one point which was along the lines of "Who should I vote for at the last minute this time guys?" (I haven't gotten to that post yet in my reread but I distinctly remember this.) Their reasoning for voting Sans the day So Sorry was lynched is also pretty bad: "I just wanted to see what would happen" is pretty lolworthy.

Post #549 doesn't make sense. They call Muffet out for not giving a lean on Monster Kid, but Muffet does give a lean on Monster Kid.

The way they came into today still happy with the state of the game doesn't feel like it comes from a townie mindset to me. Alphys and Tsunder both came in pretty much cursing the day, which is what I would expect from a town there. Undyne was still content with the state of the game, which I find pretty awkward, though this is predicated on the fact that Flowey essentially saved us from ourselves.

[TWG Mad Dummy]

Originally Posted by TWG Alphys

nah not yet, he's got plenty of time

You're starting to annoy me. You know I'm doing work, so posts like these are pretty hard for me to ignore.

[TWG Mad Dummy]

Originally Posted by TWG Napstablook

For what it's worth I'm pretty sure (like 90% sure) Sans is Charu, or at least someone trying to impersonate him, after looking back over his posts. So does Charu do stuff like this as a wolf normally? We've really seen no sort of defense on his part - just this sort of blasé posting style..I can't recall any of his wolf games off the top of my head but this doesn't seem like the behavior of a caught human to me.

This post kind of makes me feel a bit better about Napsta. The way they start it out with "I'm like 90% sure Sans is Charu" doesn't feel like they're talking about a partner, I think.

[TWG Mad Dummy]

tl:dr of Sans reads

Monsters:
Alphys "Good head on her as usual"
Flowey "I like how our floral friend has been attacking new ideas instead of going with ones existing"
Mad Dummy "He's still the one instigating folks and that's all the reason to not really look at the dummy."
Mettaton "I really, really like his call out as of recent against so sorry... we're connected bones there."
Muffet "Anyone saying she's human must be off their knockers."
Temmie "Her triggering makes me believe she's frustrated and is usually signs of monsterhood in general."

Nulls:
Doggo "Time will tell"
Monster Kid "Despite the increase in content and presence, I still have him as null"
Papyrus "He's a big null"
Undyne "I'll be straight... she's the one person I haven't really paid too much attention of."

Humans:
Napstablook *Lots of post quoting, doesn't understand their thought process"
So Sorry "Your posts have been coming off from this viewpoint as someone that's trying to do damage control."
Tsunderplane "You seem to be... just following what's on the plate at the moment and going with it.... I'm watching you..."

Fmpov, Sans literally only gave accurate townreads. I would assume that this means I can put down the idea that he was in mindfuck mode at that point, and was just posting as his normal self. This also suggests that he did not think Alphys was the seer, because he probably would've gone into mindfuck mode if this was the case.

I think, and I know that this goes against my points on Undyne previously, that Sans is most likely to have his two living partners in his scumreads. Rereading this post basically killed the world of Undyne+Papyrus ever being viable because the Charu I know has to be bussing at least one partner in addition to So Sorry

[TWG Mad Dummy]

I suppose I could see it being one in the nulls and one in the scumreads, but I will never believe the team is Papyrus/Undyne for the rest of the game.

[TWG Undyne]

Originally Posted by TWG Mad Dummy

His response to Mettaton at the time was "Lol why would I not vote at EOD," which contradicts the rest of his play, especially considering he even made a post at one point which was along the lines of "Who should I vote for at the last minute this time guys?" (I haven't gotten to that post yet in my reread but I distinctly remember this.) Their reasoning for voting Sans the day So Sorry was lynched is also pretty bad: "I just wanted to see what would happen" is pretty lolworthy.

Yes, I did joke about switching my vote in the last minute, because I had been making late votes. I acknowledged that I could see how the first one looked weird, but I explained why I was doing it each time:

- I switch from Monster Kid to Asgore first phase because Asgore said he would be there at EoD and wasn't. I pointed out that I'm switched off MK because Sans (a wolf) movement to that wagon spooked me and I didn't like it.

- I switched from Papyrus to Sans second phase. I didn't like my vote being on Papyrus and I did like my vote being on Sans. I wish I had been more vocal about So Sorry, because I didn't like him either, but that's why I put my vote on Sans instead of just piling on - because So Sorry was still in a position to die and there was the potential to evoke players into making more votes to read into. Imagine if wolves moved votes to save their Godfather?

I have truth and justice on my side. When I come for the scum you will know I mean fucking business. I have a pool of to 2 in 4. I am going to sniff out you slimy liars and