TWG CXXIV: Super Smash Brothers

[TWG Marth]

Originally Posted by TWG Pit

Most likely sleeping now. Good night if I really end up sleeping

[TWG Charizard]

This is only a hunch and not something that I'm super serious about pursuing right now, but in between the originally scheduled EOD and the hour-later one I saw Sonic and Wii Fit Trainer show up in the thread at around the same time as one another. I don't recall either of them being in the thread in the hour or two leading up to EOD either. Normally I wouldn't consider this to be anything at all, but then there's this post:

Originally Posted by TWG Wii Fit Trainer

Sonic because autism

Also interesting is that Wii Fit Trainer didn't use the twgv tags for his vote, implying that he may be a newer player (unless I'm wrong and not everybody uses the twgv tags?). I think voting for a teammate right out of the gate would be the sort of thing a newer wolf would do.

But, like I said, three posts out of Sonic, five out of Wii Fit Trainer, and a couple of hunches aren't worth pursuing right now when we have much more to go off of elsewhere.

[TWG Charizard]

Originally Posted by TWG Marth

It was more so that to me is sounded like you were trying to make something out of nothing regarding the "where he brought that point up" aspect. Yeah, his post was much different that the topic being discussed at hand, but sometimes it's good to take a step back from the main discussion to see the big picture. Perhaps I'll take another read though, just so I can better understand your reasoning.

My reasoning was that it's a lot easier for a wolf to look human by saying that we should investigate [any given inactive] than it is for them to provide actual analysis on what's already been said. Pointing fingers at you for inactivity contributed nothing as your inactive status was already understood by everybody in the thread.

[TWG Charizard]

Starting things off with Yoshi since all of his pushes have been towards popular targets (early pushes on Pikachu, reads post with Mega Man, Pikachu, and Falcon as his main three for relatively unoriginal reasons [Mega Man for contradictions, Pikachu for blank posting, Falcon for contradictions on the talking down bit], reading Link as human) and adding onto the Falcon wagon with promises of showing up for EOD that never went fulfilled.

[TWG Marth]

Originally Posted by TWG Charizard

My reasoning was that it's a lot easier for a wolf to look human by saying that we should investigate [any given inactive] than it is for them to provide actual analysis on what's already been said. Pointing fingers at you for inactivity contributed nothing as your inactive status was already understood by everybody in the thread.

Fair enough. I caught up up on all the posts in the thread after reading about Falcon's death so I did have that bias when reading. I was also under the belief that I was the least active poster at the time, but taking a closer look at the post counts, there are other inactives that have either posted less or have they've posted more but with little content. So I apologize for my bad judgement.

Personally, I wouldn't have haggled falcon regarding an inactive's activity, but I guess that you used your best judgement to make your decision to do that.

[TWG Marth]

Oops, I was out of character, let me fix that:

[TWG Bowser]

Originally Posted by TWG Pit

IThat also looks like a kill that I would do, so I'm not surprised that it happened.

Maybe even the kill that you did do?

[TWG Pit]

Originally Posted by TWG Bowser

Maybe even the kill that you did do?

[TWG Yoshi]

Originally Posted by TWG Charizard

with promises of showing up for EOD that never went fulfilled.

well a) now everyone knows who i am lol and b) it's not my fault that eod lasted so long. I was there but didn't see anywhere to post and I got really confused when it hit midnight server time because I didn't know if we could post or anything like that. Everything else is valid tho :3

Originally Posted by TWG Ike

I recall from last game that if the wolves don't make a kill random.org makes it, I think?
I'm leaning towards that being what happened b/c I can't understand that kill.

On an off note here, I think it would be hilarious if that's actually what happened and all the wolves are the inactives.

Making reads list now will be posted in a few years k bye.

[TWG Yoshi]

I gotta go right now I'll just post what I had and then finish it later #Procrastination but no I'll try to get it done when I get back from tutoring people. Btw in parenthesis are the post counts as of my last post.

2) TWG Captain Falcon Town (Lynched Day 1) - Dug his own grave. I have something to say though; I know that it looked like he was pulling a red (and some speculate that it was red) and digging himself under like that, but this is an anon game and I don't think we should speculate too much into metagaming, but look at what's in this thread. It's too easy to misread someone's identity and play the game with an incorrect assumption.

10) TWG Mario (7) - Hasn't done anything but fluff. His first post was a joke vote on Bowser. He says stuff like "omg why am i so popular" and really doesn't say anything of substantial value. His second vote was a vote on Mega Man when everyone else was voting Mega Man. The only thing he added to that post was a picture of a troll-like Mario. I'd just say inactive neutral but the vote on Mega Man seemed somewhat wolfy to me.

15) TWG Pikachu (15) - I don't know about this guy anymore. If he keeps up the gimmick then... I don't know. Just wait for someone to use a gun I guess? The two posts that were actually of any value are his two votes, which happen to be on Rosalina and Mario, which both happen to be inactive. Overall, neutral.

17) TWG Rosalina (3) - Hasn't posted anything since irl day 1. Nothing interesting, just an inactive. Neutral.

19) TWG Shulk Town (Killed Night 1) "Attacked" villager in his 2nd of five posts. It's ridiculous to have that as any reasoning behind his death or villager being a wolf.

20) TWG Sonic (3) Said hi right at the start, posted a picture of some Sonic the Hedgehog x Bowser fan art, and then said that Villager was trying and it was wolfy. Neutral I guess.

tl;dr everyone here is neutral except mario who i have a slight red lean on.

[Xiz]

King Dedede has replaced Pacman.

[TWG King Dedede]

[TWG King Dedede]

ZELDA, YOUR USAGE OF "US" AND "THEY" SEEMS LIKE IT MIGHT BE FORCED. WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT THE NIGHT 1 KILL? caps

[TWG Ike]

Originally Posted by TWG Pit

I don't mind that they took out am inactive. Shulk would have been hard to read anyway. That also looks like a kill that I would do, so I'm not surprised that it happened. Wonky kills are great for throwing off the town.

Last post about the kill I'll make I promise.
Hitting a power role is infinitely more useful than "confusing the town."

[TWG Pit]

Originally Posted by TWG Ike

Last post about the kill I'll make I promise.
Hitting a power role is infinitely more useful than "confusing the town."

What has Shulk done that made him look like a PR?

[TWG Ike]

I'm starting to think we might be getting Martha'd

Or more accurately, I kinda want that to be the case for some reason...

[TWG Ike]

Originally Posted by TWG Pit

What has Shulk done that made him look like a PR?

never said he did. I'm not even arguing that that's what they were trying to do, I'm just saying in my experience that the first couple of nights the wolves generally *should* try to find power roles

[TWG Pit]

Originally Posted by TWG Ike

never said he did. I'm not even arguing that that's what they were trying to do, I'm just saying in my experience that the first couple of nights the wolves generally *should* try to find power roles

Since this thread is dominated by a few people, it really is a shot in the dark when thinking about most players and their roles.

Though I said what I did as a reaction test. Nice job. That sounded pretty town IMO.

[TWG Ike]

ok angel boy

[TWG Zelda]

Originally Posted by TWG King Dedede

ZELDA, YOUR USAGE OF "US" AND "THEY" SEEMS LIKE IT MIGHT BE FORCED. WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT THE NIGHT 1 KILL? caps

Forced? Nothing I've done has been forced this game.

As for the night kill, I feel they shot in the dark for a power role the same as we did for the lynch for a wolf.