TWG CXXIV: Super Smash Brothers

[TWG Villager]

hey guys

[TWG Pit]

So you mean a better version of this?

Originally Posted by TWG Pit

Done catching up! Yikes. I gotta head to class soon so this might not be the best update ever, but I'll have some time in an hour so here goes nothing!!!

I really like Link, especially in the long post he made. You brought up some good points about a few players in the game, and I'm okay with Ike now.

Villager is someone I wouldn't want to see gone, mostly because his play seems too weird to be lynch-worthy.

I'm kinda okay with Peach, Her (lol his) reaction post to Wii Fit Trainer's death was a bit weird, but we know who Peach is now so I see that as a reason to keep him around.

I still really don't like Sonic. And Yoshi. I'm pretty sure I know who Yoshi is too.

I find Bowser still a bit off but not someone I'd want gone today.

Pikachu just shouldn't die this phase. Completely useless lynch.

I can hop on a Megaman wagon for pushing on a Mario lynch when really there's other pretty inactive people.

I wouldn't want to see a KiTB between Mario and Pikachu. I thought the rule for D1 was to try to gain information from a lynch.
What would a lynch between those two really give us.

[TWG Pit]

Do you just want me to expand on some people?

[TWG Ike]

yes

[TWG Pit]

Will do!

Give me a minute

[TWG Charizard]

Originally Posted by TWG Ike

give reads give a decent read for a vote
basically, play the game

This seems like forced questioning given that Pit did make a reads-type post less than 20 posts before this.

[TWG Ike]

it was bad

[TWG Villager]

kk not gonna quote this time because lol lots of lengthy posts

agree megaman is contradicting himself between the two but idk how that makes him wolfy imo

hes getting kicked out though of my mason bro club. sry but this group is only for LOCKED CLEAR

[TWG Charizard]

How do you figure?

[TWG Villager]

imo would look at people right now on megaman

what a surprise, bowser is in it, rekt

[TWG Charizard]

Originally Posted by TWG Charizard

How do you figure?

That was directed at Ike, of course.

[TWG Ike]

Originally Posted by TWG Pit

Done catching up! Yikes. I gotta head to class soon so this might not be the best update ever, but I'll have some time in an hour so here goes nothing!!!

I really like Link, especially in the long post he made. You brought up some good points about a few players in the game, and I'm okay with Ike now.

Villager is someone I wouldn't want to see gone, mostly because his play seems too weird to be lynch-worthy.

I'm kinda okay with Peach, Her (lol his) reaction post to Wii Fit Trainer's death was a bit weird, but we know who Peach is now so I see that as a reason to keep him around.

I still really don't like Sonic. And Yoshi. I'm pretty sure I know who Yoshi is too.

I find Bowser still a bit off but not someone I'd want gone today.

Pikachu just shouldn't die this phase. Completely useless lynch.

I can hop on a Megaman wagon for pushing on a Mario lynch when really there's other pretty inactive people.

I wouldn't want to see a KiTB between Mario and Pikachu. I thought the rule for D1 was to try to gain information from a lynch.
What would a lynch between those two really give us.

Villager's play is weird and that's why he shouldn't be lynched(?)
Knowing Peach is Yoshl is apparently enough for him too.
Doesn't like Sonic or Yoshi. Doesn't say why.
Doesn't say why Bowser is off or why they don't want him gone.
Silly read on Pikachu.
Bad reasoning for Megaman which I described earlier, although not exactly related to this vote.
At least a decent mechanical explanation of why a KitB would be bad, first decent point of the post.

[TWG Pit]

I've said this before, but there's a pretty obvious reason why I don't like Sonic.

This is the only post of his that has substance

Originally Posted by TWG Sonic

Hmm, from reading the stuff that I missed, I can't really put much together about anything at the moment.

What I am seeing though, is that Villager seems to have been acting unnecessarily aggressive towards some people here. What is the meaning of this, Villager?

I mean look at this
What is this
what is this

And for Yoshi

Originally Posted by TWG Yoshi

Good morning guys and welcome Marth to the game.

Pikachu I suggest that you get a translator soon because you're literally being dead weight to the team. The only thing that is of use is your votes but looking at them and your "reasoning" for them, it's almost like it's bullshit.

Pikachu might be villager, but unless we get a good wolf lean, he's the best kill in my opinion.

-- Yoshi~

Sees an easy target, votes, hopes for traction, ducks out.

Originally Posted by TWG Yoshi

As much as I hate to admit it, you're right, pikachu isn't the best lynch. unvote

I feel villager is villager right now.

I have to watch les miserables brb

Quick retraction after seeing that Pikachu is becoming a less attractive lynch

Originally Posted by TWG Yoshi

And Mega Man you say that you want a vote on Mario because he's "rubbing you the wrong way." Link is soo right about what he says about a vote on Pikachu vs. Mario. If you wanna play this game with reasoning like that, I might as well leave my vote on Pikachu.

Parroting off of Link

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

I was writing that up when I saw your post.
Did you not read the first two sentences of my post.

[TWG Ike]

I mean I read everything.
And meh
that was better I'd like to hear some other people's thoughts on you though

[TWG Charizard]

Originally Posted by TWG Ike

Villager's play is weird and that's why he shouldn't be lynched(?)
Knowing Peach is Yoshl is apparently enough for him too.
Doesn't like Sonic or Yoshi. Doesn't say why.
Doesn't say why Bowser is off or why they don't want him gone.
Silly read on Pikachu.
Bad reasoning for Megaman which I described earlier, although not exactly related to this vote.
At least a decent mechanical explanation of why a KitB would be bad, first decent point of the post.

So then why didn't you ask him to clarify those specific items or tell him that his previous reads list was poor instead of saying stuff like this:

Originally Posted by TWG Ike

give me something to read you off of

Originally Posted by TWG Ike

give reads give a decent read for a vote
basically, play the game

Originally Posted by TWG Ike

I didn't ask for a list
I asked for reads
I'm not asking you to copy what Link did I'm asking you your thoughts on the game.
Surely, you have some players who lean one way or another in terms of alignment. This is the part I'm interested in.

You asked for any reads, not better reads. You asked him to play the game as if he didn't just make an effort to. You said, "Surely, you have some players who lean one way or another in terms of alignment," when you just now criticized the reasoning for his leans, leans that were already posted before you started pressuring him for them.

[TWG Ike]

I felt like it was lackluster
yeah my wording wasn't great it never is people get annoyed by it every game.
You'd think I just learned English or something but yeah.

[TWG Ike]

and I would argue that I really didn't have a read off of him from that post due to the minimal amount of content in it
did you get one?

[TWG Zelda]

Pit is fine to me thus far, you giving him so much shit is a little concerning though. Totally understand pressuring him, you are just going a bit overboard.

[TWG Pit]

I mean I'm still going...

There's a reason why I found YoshL pretty off at the beginning of the game

Originally Posted by TWG Peach

Everyone popping onto Bowser w/o a second thought feels weird.On the other hand, we have 23 people, 12 to insta means that's near no pressure at all.

More votes please

I mean no shit

Over the game though his play became less ??????????

I don't think it's charu either.

either way, it's annoying as fuck. I'd rather not waste a lynch on them though, but they're definitely going to need to die if they keep it up

I dunno, I liked this.

massive dumbtell on ike

so dumb

Would a wolf say this?

megaman stinkss omething rotten

First person to point out Megaman's behavior IIRC

-----------------
Are you guys still talking about me? Cool!

[TWG Samus]

Originally Posted by TWG Fox

In the first part, you use 'may'
The second youre inferring absolute.
Which is it?

*heh* I was actually trying to imply that you were being an absolutist in how you were dealing with the Ike situation. But seeing the rest of the reply below:

Originally Posted by TWG Fox

If i thought ike was a Wolf, id call him out for it. Im merely suggesting that it is a possibility for both town and wolves to do that to appear town. You seeing the situation and basically saying only humans do that is suggesting covering up or blindsighting onto only one possibility, which is also harmful to us.

Like: bowser was suspicious to several people early on, but he was also part of the how many wolves are there discussion. Does that mean hes for sure a town because he was confused about the number, not bringing importance to any other points of suspicion that could be on him? No.

Seems to indicate that you're venturing into a more middle ground mindset reguarding the early confusion on the number of wolves. Essentially you're saying not knowing how many wolves there are is a role neutral thing.

Thats fine, just undersand other people consider it a slight village lean when the situation doesn't feel forced.