Keyboardsmash Phase I: Legacy Submissions Open

[James May]

Originally Posted by Gundam-Dude

Kirlian Shores
· In the intense sections of the song, it'd be beneficial to layer in the percussive jumps rather than leaving the majority of it single notes.
· I feel hand usage in the file would also be beneficial for further supporting the climactic parts of the song and even simple cymbal crashes, even if it's overall a seemingly mellow.
· No real complaints otherwise. Because of the length of the song, I'd suggest reworking the intense sections of the song to be more densely layered and I think this would be good to go.
Maybe

Minute A Fond La Caisse
· Mine usage is rather overused although I can understand the sections where the chart practically turns into dodgeball. I think toning the mines overall would be beneficial to the chart.
· Well layered with nothing major to note. The song itself doesn't offer anything interesting to work with though and being a fairly long chart, I don't think this captivates the player demographic enough to sit through the entire thing. For that reason I'm rather indecisive about this one.
Maybe

Pepper Steak
· Once the song picks up and you start using hands for the percussion and mines here and there, I feel this section would be better if you layer in the 16ths you intentionally ignored. The progression in layering would be a much better transition in my opinion.
· Well layered with nothing major worth noting. Song's super repetitive and I think that's what really kills the chart overall because you layered everything it had to offer essentially. Again, another case where I don't think this captivates the player demographic well enough so I'm indecisive about this one.
Maybe

The Divine Comedy Reverse (Revision)
· I'd definitely look into simplifying the 32nd jacks in general because it's pretty damn fast to hit.
· File's well layered. There are a few tiny nitpicks for some layering decisions but I'm willing to pass this off as is.
Yes

@Kirlian Shores: the main reason why it felt much simpler in the layering part was essentially it was going to be a 3-person collab between wafles (who released his chart in yolo2), caliber (which I don't know where his chart went whoops) and mine being the easiest of the three for choof's Kirlian Selections pack. I'll fix up the chart and beef up the difficulty a bit.

@Minuit: I'll tone the mines down.

@Pepper Steak: This is like the 5th revamp I had done with file lmfao. I guess if it doesn't go through I might as well just make a single release out of it :/

@Divine Comedy Reverse: I'll tone down the jacks. Maybe making them into graces or mini roll freeze would suffice?