Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

[kommisar]

It'd be more organized if each chart was on the same song file like ts does

[psychoangel691]

It would be I just don't think it's something that should stop the idea of more charts.

[kommisar]

If a file has more than one chart we're supposed to automatically reject it since each hart has to be submitted individually no?

[Elite Ninja]

Originally Posted by kommisar

- 2 to 3 mandatory charts per file

I don't like this idea =(

[hi19hi19]

Rather than limiting files and mandating easy charts, just remove the submission cap and I promise I will submit all the easy files you could ever want <3

[Xiz]

Originally Posted by hi19hi19

Rather than limiting files and mandating easy charts, just remove the submission cap and I promise I will submit all the easy files you could ever want <3

^ Same. Like, I have 5-6 files around a 6-20 range that I can submit (That are ACTUALLY good)... however I prefer to submit my other ones first because well... they sound better and are more fun to play (30-45 range)


(And the guy whose music it is wants to see it in game, since he gave me permission) lolz.

[qqwref]

Originally Posted by kommisar

Ideally, I would like to see this maybe someday:

- 2 to 3 files max per person every month
- batches every month
- stricter judging and higher score average for acceptance
- 2 to 3 mandatory charts per file

Wow, kommi, great idea! Probably because it's identical to the one Plan and I have separately suggested before (except for the 2-3 mandatory charts per file, which I disagree with for reasons I'll be happy to explain).

[Choofers]

where was that alternating batches idea, I liked that

easy -> normal -> hard

[t-rogdor]

Originally Posted by kommisar

Ideally, I would like to see this maybe someday:

- 2 to 3 files max per person every month
- batches every month
- stricter judging and higher score average for acceptance
- 2 to 3 mandatory charts per file.

All good ideas except the last one

I'm all for having more easy files for casual players, don't get me wrong, but requiring multiple charts presents a few things I'd say are issues:
1) unless the FFR engine went through a COMPLETE overhaul, having multiple difficulties for every file would make the song list cluttered as fuck
2) by REQUIRING charts, you give people incentive to half-ass easy charts which, when being judged, could bring the file down overall. Again, I'm all for more casual charts, but to penalize a good hard chat just because it has mediocre easy charts is not only a bit unfair but in the long run will make people not want to submit files at all
3) not all songs can be made as an easy file. I mean, think of files that are Hard Pain Sync like your Ars Moriendi file. It was already hard enough to sync, and much of the sync is hard-pattern dependent. Sure, you could make slightly easier charts (like how you did lol) but in FFR those would be worthless and stepping a vastly easier file would be really goddamn hard or nigh impossible

Better than REQUIRING easier charts, you should offer incentives for people who include 1/2 easier charts (I.e. increased submission cap), which would allow for more casual charts without the negatives of forcing it on people

[t-rogdor]

That is, after the engine was modified to allow for easier files without it looking like shit

[FissionMailed1]

Originally Posted by t-rogdor

3) not all songs can be made as an easy file. I mean, think of files that are Hard Pain Sync like your Ars Moriendi file. It was already hard enough to sync, and much of the sync is hard-pattern dependent. Sure, you could make slightly easier charts (like how you did lol)

That reminds me of my Canary Part III file in FFR CP4, and what happened when I tried to make an easier chart for that. Hint: It was terrible. Anybody can go play it and see for themselves.

[SKG_Scintill]

got 2 technical dumps to send, open batch pl0x

[FFR Pro 21]

I'm all set. Batch, open up please!

[DossarLX ODI]

I'm going to be submitting some easier files this time with the exception of Party 4U. It's mostly going to be Nero's Day At Disneyland stuff. I had a few other harder files but I'm not submitting them next batch.

- Rain (Amathyst MSM Gate Mortgage Remix) <--- I did make a pad file for this too
- Party 4U "Future GLOSS mix"

[Coolboyrulez0]

Pretty hyped for Party 4U. I wonder if FFR would be cool with me stepping the full version [or the latter half cut] of the original and then we'd have 5 versions in the game lmfao
(assuming yours were to be accepted)

On a more serious note, I noticed pretty much all of cranky's songs are bms cuts or website cuts. Generally, full versions can warrant v2s even if there isnt a huge difficulty gap from the previous version, right?

[jimerax]

If it's queueworthy and steps aren't too similar with v1 at parts, or the song isn't too repetitive/boring (judge's feeling), yeah.

[Xiz]

<3

[hi19hi19]

[Arkuski]

More hype

[MarioNintendo]

Got nothing to send!

\o/