Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

[krunkykai22]

I'm surprised my chart even got the ratings it did >.> Though it is quite funny:

Fr0zEnPh0eNiX - NRG = 6 (AlexDest), 2 (Kommisar), 6 (TC_Halogen), 7 (Jimerax) = 5.25 ....

[Patashu]

Originally Posted by .Gazelle.

- attention to rhythm at 36.325 is really nice
- From s36.32 to s37.18 is all very wrong. Listen to it on a rate of 0.3 or lower.
?_?

different styles of judging:
judge a) as long as it compliments the song it's great
judge b) every note has to go exactly to something OR ELSE BAD THINGS HAPPEN

[FissionMailed1]

EDIT: nevermind

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by .Gazelle.

- attention to rhythm at 36.325 is really nice
- From s36.32 to s37.18 is all very wrong. Listen to it on a rate of 0.3 or lower.
?_?

it's not incorrect, there are just two missing notes that would otherwise make the burst absolutely ridiculous.

This is what you have:


This is what is correct:


it's negligible at a normal rate.

[XelNya]

Well that's a horrible mistake, please ignore my last post, I just realized I had attached the wrong song in that e-mail and the mistake was actually on my end.

[Reshiram]

8-Bit Purple Comet|8-7-7-6 (7.0)
Neurotoxin|7-9-6-6 (7.0)

Originally Posted by Kommisar

Neurotoxin (9/10)
-m32 I feel like bass drum 16ths could be added in. m54 missed some 16ths. Those two things are literally the only things preventing me from giving this a perfect score. This is everything right about a fun simfile.

Okay. :3

[Choofers]

I read my reviews of robotomy in the car with my mom and we had a hearty laugh.

[.Gazelle.]

with 6/6/5/5 would i be able to send fixes?

[Charu]

Just jumping in from school since I noticed the notes posted, heheh.

7-8-7-6 on Jeh Jeh Slammin'. for an overall average of 7.

I'm very happy with the turn out of this.

I'll definitely get to reading the new fixes and or suggestions.

Colliding Chaos didn't do as well, but I was experimenting with it. Will try to make it better, thank ya judges!

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by .Gazelle.

with 6/6/5/5 would i be able to send fixes?

Without it counting against your submission limit? Unfortunately, probably not.

[bmah]

Originally Posted by .Gazelle.

with 6/6/5/5 would i be able to send fixes?

Can't say yet. As you may be aware, only the top 10 failed submissions are considered resubmissions for the next batch, and we can't determine that until we know the acceptance rate.

[PrawnSkunk]

A Lifetime - 7.7 average (7/8/8/PASS)
dohoho

Rainbow Tylenol - 6.25 average (4/6/7/8)
welp, better submit it again~

[FFR Pro 21]

Wow, I didn't do as well as I was hoping to do in this batch. Oh well, time to make fixes.

[Wayward Vagabond]

Looks like rock over Japan was the only one not to make it. Guess I'll just strip it and make it an easy file

[DossarLX ODI]

Robotomy's reviews are amazing LMFAO

Also Melons I didn't want to overlayer it/make the beginning have a bunch of annoying bursts. When I playtested it several times none of the bursts were messy (at least not in the player's sense, the frames were meh). A lot of 32nds were put out because everyone would just jumptrill it and it makes the file dumpy -- it seems like most of the opposition was to song choice though

Warai seems like another resubmission case, because it looks like a lot of files got good reviews this batch. The comments about cutting it further are pretty ridiculous since the original song was already 6:55 and I managed to get rid of 3 minutes already.

[t-rogdor]

Originally Posted by Niala

btw nobody gives enough of a shit to play your 4k 6 year long arrow dump on a song that sounds like a mad scientist's computer is exploding

yo no beef but saying shit like this makes you seem really immature and entirely unfit to judge

[DossarLX ODI]

Also 6/6/5/5 has no way of resubmission next batch with this batch's average. Even a 7 average would be cutting it close with these reviews. Warai probably will be a resubmission case like I said, since it's 6.75.

[hi19hi19]

All my files got perfect reviews


Get on my level

[TC_Halogen]

One more thing I'd like to address:

Niala - Undiscovered Colors

Undiscovered Colours (TC_Halogen) 8/10 [+]
- True to it's name, the only thing that I kinda don't like is the keytaps are sort of ridiculous because of the somewhat excessive effort to make everything colourful 'cause lolsongname.
- Granted the drums are all over the fucking place...

The only intentionally colored parts of the file were the strings in the first half (once at the beginning of every measure as 48ths) and the piano in the second half (once at the beginning of every measure, occasionally once every two beats as 64ths).

The rest of the file was me simply following rhythms, reducing the amount of steps whenever a burst had a ridiculous amount of notes within a small period.

[MarioNintendo]

~
Sent my reviews.
Delays expecters be disappoint.