New Song Artist's Special Batch - Submission Closed

[PrawnSkunk]

extremely excited and kind of disappointed by the 16/20.. since it's a conditional file, does that mean it might have a chance to be published to FFR after all the 17/20 and above files have been sorted through?

[I like it]

Free kommi
free kommi
free kommi
free kommi
free kommi
free kommi

[Niala]

I'm not sure, but I thought we had decided to make 4/4/4/4 an accept?

[00Razor00]

I think half of these judges don't realize that a [?] is usually reserved for poorly made and offsync files yet, they give them out as if they were [+?]'s.

[psychoangel691]

[?] [Light Reject, 2/5] The file has potential, but needs significant reworking in order to be good enough for FFR. Not close to acceptance.

^^

[PrawnSkunk]

Originally Posted by Niala

I'm not sure, but I thought we had decided to make 4/4/4/4 an accept?

If that was the case, i'd be immensely relieved. like razor said, I guess there's a bit of confusing with the judging structure this batch...

[Plan_Bsk81127]

Originally Posted by Niala

I'm not sure, but I thought we had decided to make 4/4/4/4 an accept?

My file in the easy batch got rejected with this grade layout :P

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by I like it

Free kommi
free kommi
free kommi
free kommi
free kommi
free kommi

Not funny, and skating around the "free < ... >" rule by posting it rather than creating a thread isn't going to prevent action from being taken on you.

@ Niala: I was hoping to see 4/4/4/4 as an accept too, since all judges DID accept it. That should be the only 16-point variant allowed to pass, with anything at 15 points being considered for borderline. 17/20 should be an immediate pass.

EDIT: wait, is 15 a borderline in this instance? Cutthroat actually stands a chance, lmfao.

[NeoMasterPie]

oh no AJ quoted a rule-breaking post

[Niala]

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

Not funny, and skating around the "free < ... >" rule by posting it rather than creating a thread isn't going to prevent action from being taken on you.

@ Niala: I was hoping to see 4/4/4/4 as an accept too, since all judges DID accept it. That should be the only 16-point variant allowed to pass, with anything at 15 points being considered for borderline. 17/20 should be an immediate pass.

EDIT: wait, is 15 a borderline in this instance? Cutthroat actually stands a chance, lmfao.

I completely agree it makes a lot of sense-
wait cutthroat
NEVERMIND STUPID IDEA

[00Razor00]

Originally Posted by PrawnSkunk

If that was the case, i'd be immensely relieved. like razor said, I guess there's a bit of confusion with the judging structure this batch...

More like, mass confusion. Especially coming from Niala who uses his own judgment scale to rate files (when there's already one in place, lol?) and iironiic who's just a flat out retard when it comes to rating files (Rating GD's file a +? after 3 +'s), rofl.

Anyway, grats on the accepted files br0s.

[MarioNintendo]

Originally Posted by 00Razor00

[...] and iironiic who's just a flat out retard when it comes to rating files (Rating GD's file a +? after 3 +'s), rofl.

That's not very polite. I'm sure there was a better way of phrasing that thought.

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by Niala

I completely agree it makes a lot of sense-
wait cutthroat
NEVERMIND STUPID IDEA

:>

It was a feeble attempt at me getting an R1 Music Producer title, haha.

Razor: I understand that you're trying to make a point about the judgment structure, but sitting there calling a judge a retard is definitely not going to help your case. You've been acting like a real prick in the forums lately and I'm not going to warn you again.

[nois-or-e]

Originally Posted by Silvuh

Elektrik Shiivers +. +. +. +. = 16

Originally Posted by Niala

[++]=25/25
[+]=22+/25
[+.]=19+/25
[+?]=17+/25
[?]=13+/25
[-]=5+/25
[--]=0+/25

ELEKTRIK SHIIVERS - (nois-or-e) [+.]

4/5
10/10
4/5
3/5
----
22/25

Is one of these numbers a typo Jeff? I see's a 22, but I also see numbers adding up to 21. Not too worried cos it got 4/4/4/4, but still curious xD

[TC_Halogen]

If the next batch is a special batch, I don't think anything will be counted as a resubmission. If I remember correctly, the Hard Songs batch had a limit of three submissions per person, just like the Easy Songs batch did.

[Niala]

Originally Posted by nois-or-e

Is one of these numbers a typo Jeff? I see's a 22, but I also see numbers adding up to 21. Not too worried cos it got 4/4/4/4, but still curious xD

ya that 22 is supposed to be a 21.

btw razor I came up with the system in an attempt to keep myself honest on the simfiles and elaborate how I judge your files. It's not like it's there just because "well my way works better than FFR's so I'm doing it my way herp-derp."

EDIT: Halogen I thought the Hard Songs Batch was just going to be used if we were going to do an official tourney, but I might be wrong about that.

[samurai7694]

I'm sorry but, how can you give a [?] just for patterns? (referring to iironiic's review on Pussy Pump).

- The patterns on 37.797s ・38.328s are slightly incorrect.
- Similarly, the patterns on 47.355s ・47.886s are slightly incorrect as well.
- I don稚 think the 4th on 51.602s is worthy to be a jump considering the jumps preceding that jump.
- The part between 56.381s ・64.877s has some questionable steps, but more importantly, patterns that won稚 be liked by the community once converted on FFR. Keep in mind that the community would rather have fun files over technical.

I really think this was a bullshit call, especially about how specific patterns get screwed up from FFR conversion. It happens to any other file. IMO As long as the file is overall decent with layering and rhythm, then it should be fine on FFR, and PR or pattern choices shouldn't necessarily be an excuse to give such a ludicrous rating.

I'm still lol'ing at how it got + +. +. ?

[psychoangel691]

The funny thing is kommi mentioned in the other batch discussion thread that he judges files similar to the way you do. He just doesn't physically post it that way.

[00Razor00]

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

Razor: I understand that you're trying to make a point about the judgment structure, but sitting there calling a judge a retard is definitely not going to help your case. You've been acting like a real prick in the forums lately and I'm not going to warn you again.

Oh no, mod threats. What ever shall I do? As for your second point, I'm not trying to make any point. I gave my honest opinion on the notes/judges/ratings and you simply white knighted. Stop pretending to be so oblivious to the fact that the 2 judges I called out have absolutely no idea what they're talking about.

[leonid]

Dove is too modern for FFR xd Maybe one day people will understand!!!!!!