XOON 4 submissions open

[moches]

definitely got my work cut out for me. let's get this crap done guys

astro man stage
-nothing wrong (other than some weird jumps), but not much right either.
-no replay value; blame it on the song. you usually make files I love but this isn't really it
creativity: 2/5
fun: 4.5/10
technicalness: 4.5/5
replay value: 3/5
14/30
no

(chris) evans
-nice stargroup freeze theory at the very end there :P
-file is much better than Linus's imo, flows quite well.
-people need to use mines the way they should be used instead of as tacky decorations though >.<
creativity: 3/5
fun: 7.5/10
technicalness: 4/5
replay value: 6/10
20.5/30
sure why not

lunar restep
-lmao nice alias
-pretty fun overall. I don't get the part with the blue jumps though, what were you trying to emphasize there?
-solo rules

creativity: 4/5
fun: 8/10
technicalness: 3.5/5
replay value: 6/10
21.5/30
yeah

metal squad
-started fun, then turned..yeah
-nothing in the file that warrants fun factor or replay value
-technically pretty good however
creativity: 1.5/5
fun: 3/10
technicalness: 5/5
replay value: 2/10
11.5/30
bad

moon child
-I like this song even though it's been stepped a lot
-file is good overall, but those minifreeze jacks are annoying as hell to read and there's a few inconsistencies as well.
-good sync
creativity: 3.5/5
fun: 8/10
technicalness: 3.5/5
replay value: 7/10
22/30
oh yeah

open the world
-best file in this batch so far
-I enjoy this file quite a bit even though it's easy
-doesn't need any of the melody minifreezes though, I'd like to see those removed but whatever this file is cool either way
creativity: 3.5/5
fun: 8.5/10
technicalness: 4.5/5
replay value: 7.5/10
24/30
hell ye

lumpy
-whatever it's good enough
-some freezes could be a lot shorter and a few parts could use some cool mine effects though
-about time you made a good file like this
creativity: 3/5
fun: 6.5/10
technicalness: 3/5
replay value: 6/10
18.5/30
accept if you fix this dude

river flows in you
-i'll assume this is good. not in the mood to play a piano song right now
song choice: 5/5

robotica
-what is this I hear about another Korean stepartist
-file's cool dude and quite original
4/5
7.5/10
4/5
7/10
22.5/30
okay

shrek theme
-stargroup would hate this file
-same thing all the way through
-song choice is a little bit TOO weird dude
5/5
2.5/10
5/5
2/10
14.5/30
nuhuh

the dark blowhole
-best DARK Phoenix file...ever
-piano chords could have been stepped in the beginning, some hands feel too intense for emphasis, rest rules though
4.5/5
9/10
4/5
8/10
25.5/30
what do you think

justice ray
I'll play this later brb homework