Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

[who_cares973]

super spy hunter is fmo enough

[bmah]

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

bmah, you're very picky. :3

Rest assured that I won't go into such details from now on. I only had the time to do so this batch since I had nothing to do.

[bluguerrilla]

Oh and does this next batch close next Monday or earlier?

Ohey you posted that it'll probably close next Sunday, cool.

[TC_Halogen]

Tageri / Sabrepulse / TC_Halogen
rating: [+?]

- m7,31: missed a 16th (fixed)
- m27,30,33: missed a 4th (I don't hear it. )
- m34-38,62-63,77,79,82-84: missed a lot of steps, mainly on drums
- m49: last 32nd not needed (fixed)
- m68: jump on the emphasized 4th? (fixed)
- m71: extraneous 8th (fixed)
- m87-89,91: step more to percussions (fixed)
- m93: should be more 32nds (fixed)
- m108-109: one-handed trills not the best patterns to use (fixed)
- m111-119,121-125,127: feels underlayered; check over these parts carefully
- m121: fun if you added more jumps to emphasized drums
- m127: last arrow should be an 8th (Sounds like an echo to me, but fixed.)

Just need to fix a bit more.

[bluguerrilla]

And you'd better not be lame and not do the fixes and forget about the file like that Venetian Snares song you stepped. I liked that file and I never got to see it again.

edit: hmm, maybe that wasn't you. Whatever.

And you think that's a lot:

Originally Posted by bmah

Red Wings Over Baron (FFIV Medley) / Powerglove / bluguerrilla & HighAndr0id
rating: [+?]

- m9-10: 24th up arrows nonexistant
- m14-22: step guitar more accurately; offsync in some places (e.g. right before m15 or m16)
- m37-40: incorrect steps; drums not playing to that many 16ths; also, layer the guitar melody more
- m45: more jumps for guitar melody?
- m56-58: incorrect steps; guitar and drums not playing to that many 16ths; also, there should be 12ths/24ths near end of m57 instead of a 32nd
- m67: start off with a jump
- m72,75: some 16ths nonexistant
- m78: incomplete layering
- m80,98,110,214,245: step more accurately to drums
- m95-96: optionally, you might want to step some quick bursts according to orchestral strings
- m152: needs better PR
- m165,209: forgot a jump
- m168-170: should be all jumps according to your previous layering
- m178-182: some 8ths should be removed; ignore unimportant hi-hats
- m185: incomplete layering
- m198: step more accurately to guitar
- m199: would be fun if you stepped to drumroll; you should offset the timing with a pause so that the oncoming section won't have 8th arrows on 4th-note beats
- m238-242,275-281: don't hear all those 16ths
- m253,257: should be 16ths near the end, not 12ths/24ths

summary: Extremely long song, but it's varied enough to keep people playing the whole way through. However, there are still too many errors. Keep on going!

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by bluguerrilla

And you'd better not be lame and not do the fixes and forget about the file like that Venetian Snares song you stepped. I liked that file and I never got to see it again.

edit: hmm, maybe that wasn't you. Whatever.

I don't remember stepping a V-Snares file that was worth fixing--Concrete Dandelions was pretty bad. xD

I did abandon Midnight Shooter though.

[bluguerrilla]

I don't know, it was some Venetian Snares song that had like no drums in it. Whatever.

Edit: fix midnight shooter you tool, jx +.'d it.

[who_cares973]

champion freeverse i decided to send to an sm pack so i replaced it with a handless super spy hunter

[Xandertrax]

rofl... i did not expect winter wind to get in. at all.

I have a lot of work to do tomorrow = (

[championanwar]

1 more file conditional'd ;DDDDDDDDDDDDD <3 Tiza!
-
I'll fix up Experiment per notes, and weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by bluguerrilla

I don't know, it was some Venetian Snares song that had like no drums in it. Whatever.

Edit: fix midnight shooter you tool, jx +.'d it.

ffffffffffffffffffffff fix it and then re-send it as a collab so I don't have to do work. I'm really surprised that got +. because the PR was HORRIBLE. xD

[CyclopsDragon]

Okay...
Primitivism
[+.], [?], [+?].
Sunset Dept.
[+.], [-], [+?].
Ultema, the Perfect Body
Frankly, I don't care.
AGH! THE VARIATION IS CONFUSING ME!
Oh well. I guess if you can't please everyone, just try to please someone. (thank you for being relatively pleased, bmah)

[Xandertrax]

p.s. thanks blu for liking worse. Tass just doesn't understand.

[TC_Halogen]

m111-119,121-125,127: feels underlayered; check over these parts carefully

Last thing left, and I'm completely stumped. This is one of the main reasons why I don't stray too far away from DNB because I can't layer for crap.

[Tasselfoot]

halo, for the record, you don't need to listen to EVERY thing that is told to you by the judges.

[Bluearrowll]

Mourning Heart (Bluearrowll) [+.]
-I don't think you could've synced that any more weirdly while still being correct lol

I burst out laughing at this. This was the first sim I made for FFR and i'm doing my best to get it in.

@ Blu: It's an interlude from Ensiferum.

I'm going to keep resubmitting this until it's in the game cause well. Ensiferum isnt' a band thats in game yet, we have permission and why the hell not.

I may ditch one of the other 2 projects though to make room for another.

[customstuff]

Done the FGO.

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by Tasselfoot

halo, for the record, you don't need to listen to EVERY thing that is told to you by the judges.

For the most part, I'm alright with everything bmah said. But the thing about it being underlayered at the end was a problem I was hoping wouldn't, but did get brought up. I had a feeling that the ending was going to give me issues because I wasn't even sure how to step it myself.

[championanwar]

Just wondering, will it be the same judges next time around?

[who_cares973]

yes