Solar Eclipse Pad Pack

[TC_Halogen]

Ratings will be labeled from 1 to 10, 1 being the worst and 10 being the highest. Scores of 7 or higher are required for acceptance.

Reviewed Files

* Bold text in this area denotes an accepted file.

8-14-09
Mystic Oriental Love Consultant (Buizel) [5/10]

8-19-09
BABY P (Revolver) [9/10] NEW!
Beautiful Angel (Revolver) [8/10] NEW!
Colors of Sorrow (Gundam-Dude) [6/10] NEW!
Daite Señorita (~Zero~) [6/10] NEW!
Dead End (Revolver) [9/10] NEW!
Destination (Wyde) [?/?] NEW!
Far East Speedcore (Kommisar) [7/10] NEW!
Flowers (Gundam-Dude) [6/10] NEW!
Impronta ~vague.3rm~ (Revolver) [5/10] NEW!
Kono Spoon, Suteki Desu Ne (Revolver) [7/10] NEW!
Marisa Stole the Precious Thing (Revolver) [7/10] NEW!

Reviewed Files

Mystic Oriental Love Consultant (Buizel) [5/10]

- Chart gets late from bar 49 all the way to the ending.
- Excessive freeze/mine usage?
- bars 82/86--16th triplets beginning with a jump?

BABY P (Revolver) [9/10]

-This file is cute. The freezes and hands line up very nicely in every pattern and they make for a fun chart. Rhythms are nice, patterns flow very well throughout the whole file as well. Very nice.

Beautiful Angel (Revolver) [7/10]

- Double-step gimmick is nice. It's repeated a lot and the indications are the same, so if the player misses it the first time, they'll eventually catch it.
- I think the 12th notes begin at bar 68, if that's the case, then that measure is mis-quantized. That's a no-no.
- There's a lot of potential for a great climax at the ending too.

Colors of Sorrow (Gundam-Dude) [6/10]

- All of those jumps chained to the end of the 16ths aren't really necessary accents. While only at 143 BPM, you could say that it's doable, but it just feels too forced and not flowing.
- Patterns are repetitive throughout the chart.
- Not fond of the mini-freezes either.

Daite Señorita (~Zero~) [6/10]

- Outside of the chorus, the chart feels pretty empty. I understand that the chart is meant to be a 9, but don't make it a boring 9. There were quite a few spots that could be filled and even more so that could have some nice accents.
- The double-stepping gimmick is a nice touch. It's indicated nicely. Leave it in.

Dead End (Revolver) [9/10]

Who says hard files can't be fun? Another great example of a nicely made, difficult, and very replayable file.

- Chart is VERY accurate, and it has a high replay value not only because of chart difficulty, but because of how technical it is.
- Very bouncy in the main areas, and extremely difficult to score on because of the swing 64ths.
- I had planned on making a chart for this as well, and then main thing I was looking at was from your bars 32 to 41--you followed the bass rush's panning perfectly and then changed it up for each set of sound changes. Very nice job.
- My only little problem with this chart are those mean little 8th note jumps that are non-chained, but the difficulty of this chart gives you reason to do it. Also--to everyone else, this is a 13, not higher, not lower.

Destination (Wyde) [-/-]

- I don't know about this file. It's hard for me to make a good non-biased opinion because I happen to like Renard's chart for this too. This chart just seems plain to me. I don't know what else to say about it.

- I for one think that the song is fast paced enough to merit the 2x BPM, but I'm not going to take off for that because that's only an opinion.

Far East Speedcore (Kommisar) [7/10]

- End of bar 140: 2nd freeze has to be changed otherwise the player will get absolutely murdered by the next 8th run. Simple edit can be done to change it to a right or up arrow and nothing else.
- I agree with Wyde about this being a tiny bit overstepped.

Flowers (Gundam-Dude) [6/10]

- Same problem as Colors of Sorrow with the jumps at the end of 16th runs, and at this speed, it's not even arguable. It's not acceptable.
- Chart is repetitive pattern wise (I see a lot of 123423 and 432132).
- The hard chart has much too many jumps--and that intro is way too hard for someone who's expecting to only play an 9.

Impronta ~vague3.rm~ (Revolver) [5/10]

- WAY WAY WAY WAY WAY too repetitive. Obviously not your fault, but those 16th triplets just last TOO long. 35 measures of 16th triples with an occasional run interruption is pretty boring.
- Ending was pretty nice with the rolls, but it's going to take a pretty big change for this chart to get accepted.

Kono Spoon, Suteki Desu Ne (Revolver] [7/10]

- LOL
- LOL
- Ok. Serious review. LOL--this chart is absolutely hilarious. No doubt about that.
- Mines are a bit overused.
- Also, that 7 step 16th set at the end of bar 24 is the only crossover with 16ths in the entire chart, so it poses a consistency issue.
- Bars 12-14 versus bars 47-49, same sounds, but freezes only on second set?
- I seriously laugh everytime I play this song. xDDD

Marisa Stole the Precious Thing [Revolver] [7/10]

Nothing problematic, nor notable. Pattern usage does just enough to prevent the player from being bored and flows well.