Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

[N.T.M.]

Originally Posted by DarkAdrian

btw N.T.M. that Inside the Winter Storm reconfigured file u made the video of looked sick, usually i dont say that about dragonforce files cause alot of them are really generic ****, this one i can probably actually enjoy, keep up the good work.

Really glad to hear that. I was hoping that after cutting out all that "filler" it'd be more appealing. I guess I succeeded ^_^. Thanks.

Oh and I just resent my revised TSoT file. You guys said it'd get accepted if I layered more. Well I did exactly that. Read the e-mail description.

*edit* I'm gonna resend my Chokehold file too cuz nobody got that either. I need to make sure it's the right version though. Oh and Trumaestro should correct his errors after I send it.

[buizel8888]

Originally Posted by alexdestructions

Review on my Car Sax?

Originally Posted by the judges in general

getting better
but still p. bad

Originally Posted by N.T.M.

What was wrong with my So Sexy Robotnik file?

The song created a ton of issues, but is there anything I could still change so it could get accepted?

Originally Posted by the judges in general

work on pitch relevancy. Totally ignored in the places where it is most obvious that it's indeed being ignored.
patterns are kinda choppy, sync on colored notes is close but not quite on
freeze patterns aren't very good

rejected

there

[skyfox_]

and sooooo...
how was my file...if theres any good in it ill keep working on it.

cut the intro/outtro(the out was slightly offsync when i replayed it again so ill have to fix that>.>)

im sure threres more, but ill let you guys explain...

[N.T.M.]

Originally Posted by buizel8888

there

I'm pretty sure I know what PR section you're talking about. Often times I layered with jumps. There were two different sounds (with different pitches) layered. Also, I stepped all those colored parts in .3x with the assist tick. I even found some errors in GLoVE's The Dance of Eternity file, so it's kinda strange that it'd get rejected for that. w/e though. Doesn't matter.

[trumaestro]

no file will ever be perfect, but the closer you can get to perfect the better.

[N.T.M.]

Originally Posted by trumaestro

no file will ever be perfect, but the closer you can get to perfect the better.

He speaks the truth^^^.

BTW I submitted my TSoT file again cuz nobody got it the last time after I revised it.

[moches]

I sent a fix on ELECTRICAL PARADE, anything on it trumaestro?

[trumaestro]

Originally Posted by trumaestro

yea well my parents seem to think that i need to see the internet with a PG-13 view and the filter they're using blocks the pack mail and i'm too lazy to figure out how to bypass it so =/

other than that, I give it a CAPS LOCK/10

[buizel8888]

Originally Posted by moches

I sent a fix on ELECTRICAL PARADE, anything on it trumaestro?

take a look at your jump placement again, especially near the end

Originally Posted by skyfox_

and sooooo...
how was my file...if theres any good in it ill keep working on it.

cut the intro/outtro(the out was slightly offsync when i replayed it again so ill have to fix that>.>)

im sure threres more, but ill let you guys explain...

yeah you're gonna have to cut the beginning of the song off and do a complete overhaul on the rest of it

[Djr Rap dancer]

If you got useless comments on my simfile,feel free to blablabla to me.

[buizel8888]

Originally Posted by Djr Rap dancer

If you got useless comments on my simfile,feel free to blablabla to me.

really repetitive with a lot of missed sounds

[Djr Rap dancer]

Originally Posted by buizel8888

really repetitive with a lot of missed sounds

Repetitive,i saw a lot more repetitive than this :S
and for the missed sounds,i dont think that we got all the same way to step a file :S

Personally,i know that a lot of my simfiles are chit,but i know when a simfiles is good.But you must be more good than me :/

So , find me a short song, and you will be happy.

[buizel8888]

missed sounds means that sounds that would have actually made the file fun if you stepped it, you skipped over. Also don't judge your own files because everyone, and I mean everyone sucks at that

[Djr Rap dancer]

Originally Posted by buizel8888

missed sounds means that sounds that would have actually made the file fun if you stepped it, you skipped over. Also don't judge your own files because everyone, and I mean everyone sucks at that

I don't judge my files, but lol its a file....normaly if you enjoy make if, and you can AAA the fingers in the nose...

If i judges files of some rank1 simfilemaker, lol its like play with barbie.


Edit:i will send a last simfile for this.
it's not repetitive a lot but got some jacks.
Kommisar OP from Kommisar eventually.
if you want me to changes some things, let me know.

[N.T.M.]

Originally Posted by buizel8888

missed sounds means that sounds that would have actually made the file fun if you stepped it, you skipped over. Also don't judge your own files because everyone, and I mean everyone sucks at that

I resubmitted The Sound of Truth with the changes whatever judge it was wanted. I made an oni chart for that additional layering.

IDK, maybe it was already added to the list. I haven't checked yet.

[buizel8888]

i played it. still waiting on other opinions tho

[N.T.M.]

Originally Posted by buizel8888

i played it. still waiting on other opinions tho

I was just told that it was understepped at parts so I created an oni chart to layer the drums more. Just standard drum layering: jumps during streams and a single note during a hold. I noticed GLoVE layered drums that way so I figured I couldn't go wrong =P.

[buizel8888]

tbh i dont see any notes saying anything about file being understepped. the only notes in the thread with that file are mine, saying to look at that 48th note section again and to LOOK OUT FOR PITCH RELEVANCY

oni isnt bad, but those 2 things werent touched. dont think i ever mentioned it here tho due to lack of other judgements

[skyfox_]

hmm, was there anything else in specific i need to do with my file, like...pitch revelancy, repetitiveness, other stuff i prolly dont understand>.>

personally, i did like the intro, however its too long too keep soo...

[N.T.M.]

Originally Posted by buizel8888

tbh i dont see any notes saying anything about file being understepped. the only notes in the thread with that file are mine, saying to look at that 48th note section again and to LOOK OUT FOR PITCH RELEVANCY

oni isnt bad, but those 2 things werent touched. dont think i ever mentioned it here tho due to lack of other judgements

Oh yes, nobody ever said anything about that here. And play those 48ths at .3x. They're correct. As I recall they're clearly outlined by 12ths with a very pronounced 48th preceeding each. The remaining middle 48ths are almost inaudible at .3x until near the end of the 48th section where they're very clear.