"Play/Test/Judge my simfile" thread

[gamer4ever]

Originally Posted by Patashu

I was lazy and played on resonance so I won't comment on the sync. (It's easy to check the sync yourself: Play through parts of the song on a low rate and it's obvious if things aren't lining up. If it's not, turn assist tick on.) Listening to the song however, there should have been no stand-alone yellows, but I noticed one or two in the later half.
My main problems with this chart are:
1. It's basically the expert chart from guitar hero 3 only mangled around. This isn't guitar hero, be innovative. Step the drums too, step the vocals too.
2. When you're stepping the guitar with the jumps ala guitar hero 3's expert chart you can't seem to decide how to arrange them. They should all be ABBBB but you change it seemingly randomly; keep it consistent.
Also, no step flow. You use patterns that would lead to cross-overs or double stepped if played on a pad as often as you don't. It's awkward, try not to.


Again, resonance-played.
Difficulty level is extremely disproportionate. If you're going to throw in those huge 32nd bursts, make the rest of the file similarly difficult to match; layer, jumpstream, work in the drums, whatever. Again, this is not guitar hero on expert mode, you do not have to step the lead guitar exactly as it is in the song and do nothing else.

I see, thanks for your opinions. For "Duncan Hills Coffee Jingle", I might used the 32nd noted chart for the Oni/Edit difficulty. Plus, I did notice that the steps during the 16th note parts were kinda awkward to step to, they didn't feel normal as a normal flow would've been. At first, for the heavy mode, I had some part to the drum, the part where it bridges to the solo and the drum kicks in small gallops of 32nd. For Mississippi Queen, I used assist tick, but some parts wern't PERFECTLY on sync, so I messed around and finally got it to. Next time, I might do what you said a step to more than one "Instrument"/part. However, the reason I do the step charts ala Guitar Hero III is the fact that most of the "rock" songs I download, they mostly chart only the guitar parts. Thank you for your opinions and feedback! By the way: Is it okay to upload an OFFICIAL Konami song BUT have a completley original note chart?