Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

[Brilliant Dynamite Neon]

Let's see here

Chicken Wing (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ mostly okay rhythms/patterns
* continuous 16ths at the middle don't fit the music well
* long one-handed trills

ONE long one-handed trill. The long streams go fine with the music, I'm not taking those out.

Eating Candies (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ monstly good rhythms
* 64th mini-rolls are just like quads on FFR actually, so I don't think they are needed.

Fine by me.

Epidermis (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
* potential 3-framers in the burst
* long 8th jacks/16th trills at the middle

.

Would that section be okay without the trills?

LONLY LONLY (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms/patterns are good
* although I felt some parts are repetitive
* the section after the middle part should go with the vocal

I'll just take Tass's advice.

Piano Concerto No. 9 (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythm is ok
* double placement is ok, stream patterns are a bit awkward
* permission from performer?

I'll contact ObserveR.

Turkey March (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are ok
* bursts in the stream

I'll take them out, although I think they might spice up the file for some people.

[HammyMcSquirrel]

Originally Posted by Tasselfoot

Wish (Reprise) (HammyMcSquirrel) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
@ felt a bit overdoubled, but ok they are going with music
* better stream patterns

Wishnes ? awful patterns

Which patterns? Just in general, or the stream patterns that Jimerax mentioned?

[Tasselfoot]

brothaice: this batch was only up to the 9th. 10th or later is in the next batch.

Ben: Shash played all the files that at least 1 of us +d. At least, as far as I can tell he did.

BDN: don't bother fixing up Chicken Wing or Turkey March. both are BanYa songs. And Piano Concerto... I sent you an email way back on the 9th asking about that permission and never heard back from you. Did Observer do the remix of it?

Hammy: yea. by patterns, i mean stream patterns. although i guess it is possible that i meant in general... since i did just say "awful". i don't recall. needless to say, the file needs some work based on the comments.

[Silver_Brian]

Oh sweet Switchback v2 made it. Expect a large email with 5+ files sometime this week. I've been busy

[BEN.(SPEIRS) 7.5]

I think Shash didn't play my ESC

Maybe it's because it had +? as it's rating? I don't really know!

[Tasselfoot]

+ = queueworthy
+? = needs minor tweaking
? = needs work
- = wtf, you suck

[BEN.(SPEIRS) 7.5]

Originally Posted by Tasselfoot

+ = queueworthy
+? = needs minor tweaking
? = needs work
- = wtf, you suck

Ah ok he didn't play it cos it needs minor tweaking. Thanks! I'll go take a look and submit to the next batch or summin.

[hi19hi19]

ALl of my files are pretty ****ty lolz someone should probably redo Otaku Speedvibe before it gets in the game and everyone complains

wait too bad the song has like zero potential for FFR whoops

also k im redoing Trisextion becuase its a good song
maybe ill talk to digitaltsucker or w/e lol

also Dragons Bane is really fun its like the only fun file I've made recently, if it has 3 framers in that minitrill just change the gap and add like 0.1 seconds of silence to the start of the song, no big deal.


EDIT- Hatten carnivale v2 is pretty dumpy don't know why it got in

Final fantasty battle is the same music cut thats in the game now, rofl

I'm also going to redo my melonman OP or ask Digitalseraphh to do it becuase mine is dumpy

also seriously otaku speedvipe is like worse than an aborted elephant fetus, probably remove it from the queue or something...



also cant wait for reviews on my final couple of files that arent as dumpy. Mama is a sweeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeet file, the best thing to happen to FFR in 3 years.

[ledwix]

lol thank you for update. i wonder why i submitted that stupid smitty's entrance file XP i will refrain from doing stuff like that in the future.

[newblue22]

so if there is a + next to the song does that mean its eventually going in the queue? that part i didnt get

if not then im not even mad because there are many terrible files on ffr and i guess it needs to be amazing or terrible to get in. seriously wtf hi19 said he thought hatten v2 was dump!?!? i thought all of my files were good and i loved them. he says its bad and gets in.

[hi19hi19]

On second thought, I'm not redoing Melonmans OP becuase itll be dumpy to all the SM/ODI crew and theyll all hate me for it, but the average FFRer with no taste will probably find it fun so w/e

[Doug31]

Well, their idea of good is pretty much:
-Well synched.
-Not over or understepped and equal throughout.
-No patterns that aren't index-friendly or otherwise ridiculous, like really fast jacks where there shouldn't be.

That's mostly it, I think.

[newblue22]

ok..what does + mean exactly tho

[Doug31]

+ means they thought it was good. If either of JX or Shash give a song a +, it goes to tass. If tass gives it a +, it goes into the queue.

[newblue22]

ok thanks doug. sorry for flaming tass/jx/shash im just pissed off right now

[dore]

I've fixed 3/4 songs from this batch and also cut Back In the Day (I think it's 2:50 or so now, 2:35ish which has steps). I'll work on Shind Bad tomorrow.

[Rebirth0]

I still want to know what you're going to do about Cold Breath. I think 3 months of waiting is enough.

[Coolboyrulez0]

O well my first 2 simfiles ever were crap. So what.
The next 7 or 8 I submited will be alot better

cßr

[Cyanite]

Originally Posted by Rebirth0

I still want to know what you're going to do about Cold Breath. I think 3 months of waiting is enough.

Didn't they say they couldn't decide your version or mine?

Just put rebirth's version in, I'm not that happy with mine.

[Tasselfoot]

ok... so, for this batch.... and future batches.... limit of 2 new songs per week from artists who we deem "questionable".

basically, these people are NOT questionable:
Silver_Brian
Shash
Rebirth
Kit-
jx
hi19
Exag0n
dore
Cyanite
BDN

and i'd put pokelda, macgravel, Mead, Psycho, Silvuh, MeaCulpa, eastsideman, ~Zero~, and SulferDragon into a middle category.


if you aren't mentioned above... you WILL be capped at 2 new submissions per week. Unlimited number of re-submits on +? or ? files, 1 re-submit per week on - files.

To put it into perspective... you'll get capped at 6 new submissions for this batch if you aren't on the above list. Anything beyond 6 will get put into a folder for the next batch. I'll make sure to post in here letting those people know that some of their files are being help over. On a FIFO basis (last song you submit will go to the next batch).

OK? Good.


-Tass, Shash, jx. The Triumvirate of G.E.T.


EDIT: clearly there are more non questionable people, but they don't submit files anymore, so no point listing them. or they submit 1 file every 3-4 months. etc etc.