Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

[Shashakiro]

sup guys.

[Doug31]

You guys, you were supposed to not post until Tass posted again, to make it so he'd either have to double post or not do what he said he'd do. Anyway, 40 minutes left.

[Tasselfoot]

THE FEW. THE PROUD. THE QUEUEWORTHY.
August by ~Zero~
bbblow by Rebirth0
Blazing (BanYa Song) by eastsideman09
Charlotte (Gaussian Blur) by Rebirth0 - still need to double check that there aren't any 3-framers. if so, might need a tiny tweak.
Clash at the Mountains by SulferDragon
D Gang (BanYa Song) by MixMasterLar
Decisive Battle (standard difficulty) by Rebirth0
Disconnected Mobius by eastsideman09
Distant Land by BDN
Distorted Reality by ~Zero~
Euro Freak by Rebirth0
F by ~Zero~
False Strawberry [note: 1 of THREE files with the word Strawberry in it from this batch to make the queue. wtf?] by BDN
For Your Love by bmah
Frozen Rain by behanjc
Hatten Carnival! v2 by hi19hi19
Idyll v2 by eastsideman09
Infection by dore
Infinite Blue by SulferDragon
Innocent Decay by SulferDragon
Keep on Lovin' You by jimerax
Love Colour Master Spark by Rebirth0
Made in Innocent by dore
Mocha Ocean by MeaCulpa
Never Look Back by MeaCulpa
None Would Escape by BDN
Over the Rave by jimerax
Policy in the Sky by BDN
Prelude to Rites by Silvuh
Riddle Me A Rat's Nest by BDN
Road to You by ~Zero~
Song for All Time by dore
Starman by Scytlock
Stormy by ~Zero~
Strawberry by Silvuh [note: 2nd one]
Strawberry Music by jimerax [note: 3rd. all 3 by different stepfilers and by different musicians]
Switchback v2 by Silver_Brian
Syage by ElectricWerewolf, replacing the old queue'd version by Cyanite
The Cracking Sky by Vote4Nixon
{Colossus} by SulferDragon


38 files in queue, out of 189. Kinda sad, really. AND... of those 40, I see a consistent pattern of stepfile authors. 2 more files "queue'd" but stuck in a seperate BanYa category. And we'll no longer be accepting BanYa files, since I doubt we'll verify that permission.

26 of the 27 files that both jx and I +d are in the queue.
8 of the 21 files that just Tass +d are in the queue. (1 of the BanYa files)
6 of the 19 files that just jx +d are in the queue. (1 of the BanYa files)

Any other statistics that you guys want me to tell you about? Full batch notes from jx, + file batch notes from Shash, and non queue file notes from Tass coming up in my next post.


Oh. PS - 10 of the above files will be in the game in July. Rest will be August or later.

[sammo123]

finally its out

[Doug31]

Cool, and that was a lot less than 1 hour. If 10 of those will be in in July, then everything accepted before that will also be in the game in July, right?

[pokelda]

Originally Posted by Tasselfoot

This is not a democracy. This is the Galactic Empire of Tass. G.E.T.

That's no moon.

[Rebirth0]

5 out of 12 queue'd. hmm

All of the notes on my submitted sims plz

[Tasselfoot]

JX
A-E, 66 files (9 +s)

{Adrinaline Pumper} (ledwix) [?]
@ sync is ok
@ stream patterns of long ones are ok
* rhythms around 200 didn't flow well for me, just for me?
* beginning and enging are a bit overstepped for me.

{Big Boss} (hyperxtrance) [?]
* sync is a bit off (gap early), yellow note syndrome
* rhythms are partially off, 32nds are fine

{Big Boss} (jugglinguy) [?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are mostly good
* awkward stream patterns/doubles, unnecessary 12th minijack

{Colossus} (SulferDragon) [+?]
@ sync is ok
@ rhythms are mostly ok
* want a pattern change between 16th snares and synth part

{Final Aggression} (ledwix) [+] (8)
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are ok

{James Bond Breakbeat Remix} (BLAZZE) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ good rhythms
* almost ok, more variety for stream patterns

{Losing Touch} (ledwix) [?]
@ sync is ok
@ stream
* 8th sections are overdoubled

{Lost Memories} (SulferDragon) [?]
@ sync is good
* I think some of 32nds aren't needed
* some parts are over doubled

{Popo Runaway} (I Like It) [-]
* wrong BPM, oveall offsync
* jacks

~Monster~(Valtrix2) [?]
@ sync is ok
@ rhythms are good
* funny trial for stream patterns, too bad they don't fit the music

*beep* (Silvuh) [?]
@ sync is good
* at the second half, weird 32nds that doesn't go with the music.
* IMO unique, but not a good song choice

4-12+1 (lEndorphinl) [?]
* sync is a bit off(gap is late)
* 8ths with doubles (700-1000ish) were boring for me
* staircase based stream patterns

A Beautiful Wings (Doug31) [?]
@ sync is ok (quite a bit early)
* although steps go with the bell, parts except the beginning are understepped

Affected (MeaCulpa) [?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
* awkward patterns, a lot of spins in the stream

Airbass (BDN) [-]
x auto rejection for multiple difficulty
x withdrawal from the author

Angelic layer (Doug31) [?]
* sync is a bit off (early)
@ rhythms are almost okay
* 2 too long intervals
* awkward stream patterns

Arabesque (Goldenwinf) [+] (6)
@ sync is ok
@ okay rhythms, mini-32nd isn't needed IMO though

Are You Happy (trumaesto) [-]
@ sync is good
* 12ths don't fit the rap zone
* minijack, placement of trills, stream patterns
x withdrawal from the author

August (unkdavar) [?]
* sync is off (gap early)
* rhythms of 16th don't flow well to the music for me
* stream patterns are mostly staircase

August (coolboyrulez0) [-]
* totally offsync, wrong BPM

August (~Zero~) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
* patterns of gallops/streams are a bit awkward

BB Euro (~Zero~) [+?]
@ sync is ok
* rhythms are good, but misses some notes a bit, close though
@ patterns are ok

bbblow (Rebirth0) [+] (8)
@ sync is good
@ rhythms, patterns are mostly good

Be Princess V2 (Rebirth0) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ slightly improved patterns, less 8th jacky.
* Need more changes, only basical diferrences are placement of doubles on the vocal, song length.

Beat of the war 2 (JugglinGuy & MixMasterLar) [?]
* sync is off (gap, early)
* wrong rhythm on some notes
* unnecessary long one-handed trills

Beautiful Synergy (~Zero~) [+?]
* sync is a bit off (gap early)
@ rhythms are mostly good
* partially awkward patterns

Binary Shapes (behanjc+stargroup100) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ good pitch relevant patterns
* rhythms are good, but 8th streams at the end is too long.

Blazing (eastsideman09) [+] (9)
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
@ patterns are mostly good, I think some should be more pitch relevant though

Blue Moss (Silvuh) [+] (5)
@ sync is actually good (felt beginning is off due to the music)
@ rhythms/patterns are good for this song, if there're 32/48ths for the detail it's better

bmv.578 (moches) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are mostly fun
* BPM should be half, most notes are red.
* streams are trills/rolls/spins only, fine for me though.

Bubbleman Stage Theme V2 (SulferDragon) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
* as for 8th streams, I think doubles should be put on the guitar rhythm
* inconsistent difficulty due to ending 16th streams, need to make it harder overall

Burnout v2 (Scytlock) [?]
@ Sync is good
* rhythms are overall a bit random for me compared to the song
* awkward stream patterns, minijacks

Canonized (For Lightwave) (brothaice) [?]
* sync is off (gap early), BPM should be doubled
@ rhythms are fine
* patterns are overall awkward for me

Cant Live Without you(~Zero~) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms, patterns are mostly good
* all trills are up/down, more variation
* wtf a double at the end

Chaos Anthem(Maikelru) [-]
@ sync is ok
* overdouble'd
* way too many unnecessary minijacks
* withdrawal from the author

Chicken Wing (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ mostly okay rhythms/patterns
* continuous 16ths at the middle don't fit the music well
* long one-handed trills

Chik Habit (newblue22) [-]
* sync is a bit off (gap late)
* some rhythms are fine, some notes(12ths, 24ths) are off for me
* overdouble'd
x withdrawal from the author

Clash at the Mountains - Zelda Links Awakening (SulferDragon) [+] (7)
@ sync is good
@ good rhythms/patterns including bursts

Color of Giggles (somerndmguy) [?]
@ sync is ok
* long one-handed trills
* if you put trills like that, make it whole rhythms 16ths.

Contain (dore) [?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are mostly fine
* too many long 8th jacks
* most of those bursts don't flow well and they just make 2/3 framer jacks.

Cruel Whole (Abelcain Remix)(~Zero~) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ cool rhythms
* patterns are ok, a bit awkward at parts
* get rid of double jacks, and a double at the end as always

Csikos Post (jugglinguy) [?]
@ sync is good
* overall understepped for this song
* rhythms should be better

D Gang (MixMasterLar) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
* stream patttern should be different, instead of trills/staircases

Decisive Battle (Rebirth) [+] (8)
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
@ no 3-framers according to Tass

Delirium (BLAZZE) [-]
x steps stolen from Duk's challenge

Delta Beat (0 Vector Remix) (Knoobish) [?]
@ sync is good
* rhythms aren't too bad, but should be better for the music
* awkward stream patterns

Desertion (Valtrix2) [+?]
@ sync is ok
@ rhythms are mostly good
* as for 16th stream patterns, some of them are a bit awkward

Digital Intervention (vemuck) [?]
* sync is off (gap late)
@ mostly fine rhythms
* minijacks

Disconnected -mobius-(eastsideman09) [-]
x auto rejection for mutiple difficulty

Disconnected Hyper (Magnum13) [-]
x auto rejection for freezes

Distant Land (BDN) [+] (9)
* sync is a bit off (gap early)
@ good/fun rhythms
@ patterns on the long 16th stream are a bit awkward, but overall ok

Distorted Reality (~Zero~) [+] (5)
@ sync is good
@ fine rhythms

Dam Dadi Doo (Rebirth) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ good rhythms/patterns
* 16th trills don't match other parts

Dragons Bane (hi19hi19) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
* potential 3-framers on 24th staircases and mini-jumptrill

Drowing (DDR_Mike) [-]
* overall offsync (BPM, gap)
* minijacks, orange note syndrome

Eating Candies (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ monstly good rhythms
* 64th mini-rolls are just like quads on FFR actually, so I don't think they are needed.

Electric Heart 2006 (rshadow8888) [?]
@ sync is ok, BPM should be half
* rhythms don't flow the music well, especially fast sections

Empty Glasses (varmuusketju) [?]
@ sync is ok (quite a bit early gap)
* want more variety for patterns, rhythms.

Epic Giraffe Storm (Wavanova) [-]
* sync is off (gap early)
* rhythms are ok but missing some notes, stream patterns are awkward
* jacks, long slow-double-jacks
* I don't think this song is good for stepping

Epidermis (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
* potential 3-framers in the burst
* long 8th jacks/16th trills at the middle

Epidermis (debit13) [-]
x auto rejection for freezes

ESC (Amplified T Squared Mix) - Ben Speirs [?]
@ sync is good
* rhythms are ok, long 8ths section is a bit boring though
* a lot of minijacks in jumpstream

Estatic (Virtual Mix) (Coolboyrulez0) [-]
* wrong BPM, wrong rhythms
* minijacks

Eternal Dragons (SulferDragon) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
* patterns are mostly good, but 8ths section at the beginning is a bit overdoubled

Euphoria (bmah) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are mostly good. although some of 32nds are going for nothing, they fit.
* 3-framers in some 32nd patterns, some 12ths are overdoubled

Euro Freak (Rebirth) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ patterns are good
* rhythms are ok but arond 700-800 is a bit repetitive for me.

F-K, 37 Files (13 +s)

Gaussian Blur (Rebirth) [+] (11)
@ sync is good
@ rhythm/patterns are fine for this song, high FMO file.
@ It's at midpoint between AP's and A0's, ok cause I like them

Hypnosis (customstuff) [?]
@ sync is good
* For this level of song, 16ths trills, most of mini 16ths, mini 32nds aren't needed.
* some 8th patterns(jacky ones) are weird

F (~Zero~) [+] (7)
@ sync is ok
@ rhythm is good
* 153 bpm 12th jacks(potential 3-framer), last doubles aren't needed, not a big deal though.

False Strawberry (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+] (8)
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good

Fantasy Impromptu (ElectricWerewolf) [+] (9)
@ sync is good
@ streams fit the piano, good patterns

Fascination MaxX (K2 Chaos Remix) (eastsideman09) [+?]
@ sync is good
* overuse of chains

final audition episode 1 (jugglinguy and Mixmasterlar) [?]
@ sync is ok
* roll/staircase 16th patterns, ending part should have more 16ths.
* if you want to make an easy file for it, 16th streams aren't needed.

Final Fantasy 6 The Sveldt OC Remix (Knoobish) [-]
* sync is off (gap early)
* rhythms are off at some parts
* jacks

Final Fantasy 7 Battle v2 (hi19hi19) [?]
@ sync is ok
@ rhythms are fun including 24th burst, a bit inconsistent though.
* 12th long jacks (3-framer)
* didn't like the music cut

Firestorm (Knoobish) [?]
@ sync is ok, but blue note at 4th note.
* problems on double placement
* 32nd bursts are fine, 24ths are a bit weird for me.
* jumpstreams for no good reason

Fleeting Fantasy (Rebirth) [?]
@ sync is good
* decent stream file, but basically only 2 patterns (8th jumpstreams and 16th index-streams) over 1748 notes, painful for repetitiveness.

Flower Forever (Cyanite) [+] (8)
@ sync is ok
@ rhythms are fine
@ patterns are ok, partially a bit overjumped

For FFR v2 (Knoobish) [-]
* sync is off (early)
* as for rhythm, at least need to go with the music better than V1
* stream patterns are awkward

For Your Love (bmah) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ overall good, at the middle part, beginning of piano part should be stepped as 12ths
* doubles on yellow notes, patterns of 24th/32th at the piano part, others are fine

Four Vents (dore) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are basically good
* 32nd trills, 64th bursts are a bit weird

Frozen Rain (behanjc) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ nice rhythms, good use for 32nds
* streams are a bit awkward, over-staircase'd

**** Jason (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [?]
@ sync is ok
@ rhythms are fine
* overuse of jacky patterns, jacks, doubles in the burst, not bad as a sm file tho
* f-word in the song name

Galaxy9(Flooger) [-]
* totally off, didn't even see what rhythms are

Genophobia (Rebirth) [+] (7)
@ sync is good
@ overall decent rhythms

Going on spring wind (~Zero~) [+] (11)
* sync is ok, 4th notes start as blue notes
@ good rhythms, patterns
* queueworthy except for this problem, low-FMO file

Green Greens (JUNO FORCE!) [+?]
* sync is a bit off (gap late)
@ decent rhythms, some 8ths should be gallops
@ patterns are good

H.I.A.P.C (Valtrix) [?]
* sync is a bit off (gap early)
* step the whole song
* rhythms aren't that bad, needs more 16ths for the detail of rhythms
* long trills, 8ths patterns with doubles

H.T.I.J (~Zero~) [+?]
@ sync is good
* try to avoid YNS by using stops or BPM changes at the middle
@ good rhythms

Happy Rainbow (bmah) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are mostly good
* patterns are a bit too repetitive, a bit awkward 16th streams

Hatten Carnival! (hi19hi19) [+] (5)
@ sync is good
@ good rhythms, patterns

Horizon Remix (Final Cut) (rshadow8888) [?]
* sync is a bit off (gap early)
* rhythms are off at parts for me, some are ok
* overuse of trills with no good reason

I Love Voltage (ElectricWerewolf) [?]
@ sync is good, BPM should be doubled
@ rhythms are mostly good, partially should go better for music(synth)
* overall overdoubled/repetitive for me

Idyll v2(eastsideman09) [+] (7)
@ sync is almost ok (a bit gap early)
@ rhythms/patterns are ok

in grey (reloaded) (SulferDragon) [+?]
@ sync is ok
@ rhythms are good
* streams patterns

In Memory (BLAZZE) [+?]
@ sync is ok
@ mostly ok rhythms
* 8th pattern at the ending is boring

Infection (moches) [+?]
@ sync is ok (a bit late gap)
@ rhythms are ok
* patterns towards ending are repetitive, 16th streams

Infection (Shad0wlord) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are mostly ok
* chains/8th j-stream don't fit the music, IMO

Infection [dore] [+] (5)
@ sync is good
@ decent rhythms/paterrns, good for an easy file

Infinite Blue (SulferDragon) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ good rhythms
* overall a bit overdoubled, like doubles on every 4ths

innocent decay (SulferDragon) [+] (10)
@ sync is good, BPM should be doubled
@ nice rhythms on the hard part, patterns are good

Inverse steps by newblue22 [+] (7)
@ sync is good
@ good rhythms, stream patterns

keep_on_lovin_you (jimerax) [+] (6)


L-R, 47 Files (13 +s)

LONLY LONLY (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms/patterns are good
* although I felt some parts are repetitive
* the section after the middle part should go with the vocal

Love Coloured Master Spark (Rebirth) [+] (9)
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
@ pattens are good, double-single-double parts are a bit over but ok

Made In Innocent (dore) [+] (8)
@ sync is good
@ good 24th rhythms
@ patterns are ok, doubles are fine for me

Mechanical Bull Fighter (By The Horns Mix)(~Zero~) [+?]
@ sync is good
* Rhythms mostly go with music, want a bit more variety.

Megawatt (newblue22) [+?]
@ sync is ok
@ rhythms are good
* patterns are ok, but overrall a bit overdouble'd

Metalman Stage Theme (SulferDragon) [+?]
@ sync is ok
* Although it's a different version of music, steps are a bit too similar to ingame one

Midnight Dragon (unkdavar) [?]
* sync is considerably off (gap early)
* some rhythms don't match the music

Midnight Dragon-behanjc [+?]
@ sync is mostly ok
* rhythms are fine, a bit off at parts for me
* as for stream patterns, some are picth relevant, some are weird

Midnight Electricity (eastsideman09) [+] (8)
@ sync is ok
@ rhythms are good
@ as for patterns, jumps are a bit overused at parts but ok

Midnight Electricity (wickedawesomeful) [<]
* sync is a bit off (gap early)
* rhythms are ok but a bit odd for me, missing some notes at parts
* stream patterns are a bit awkward
* estsideman's is better

Minute Rave (unkdavar) [?]
@ sync is ok
@ streams at this speed is fine
* stream patterns are awkward

Mocha Ocean (MeaCulpa) [+] (3)
@ sync is ok
@ nice rhythms for a beginner file

Monolith (newblue22) [+?]
@ sync is good
* as for melody part, triplets aren't too bad but streams are better
* double placement on triplets is a bit weird for me

Mostrous Turtles! (MacGravel) [+] (10)
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
@ stream patterns are good, a bit continuous though

Mr. Larpus (MooMoo_Cowfreak) [-]
* sync is good, it's stolen from kilga's file though.
* over double'd, trills
* we don't need this song for some reason.

Mur-Q - Vospi (Cyanite) [+?]
@ sync is ok
@ rhythms are good
* awkward stream patterns

My Darkest Hour (hyperxtrance) [?]
* sync is ok, off on some parts
@ rhythms are ok
* didn't like set of minijacks, those are 4-framers so ok though.

My Darkest Hour (unkdavar) [+?]
@ sync is ok
@ rhythms are good
* overall, overdouble'd

Necrofantasia (Neonatrias) [?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are ok
* long 8th jacky patterns, 24th staircases

NEGIMANIAX (Shad0wlord) [?]
@ sync is ok
* mostly ok rhythm, triplets are a bit overused
* pattern of 8th triplets with double, stream patterns

neoMAX V2 (~Zero~) [-]
@ sync is ok
* not better than V1, and rhythms are still similar to V1.

Never Look Back (MeaCulpa) [+] (7)
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
@ spins in mini-streams, but ok

ninja (psychozerosk8er) [?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are ok
* overall mini 8th jacks/jumptrills aren't good patterns for this music, IMO

Ninjitsu(who_cares973) [-]
* sync is totally off (wrong BPM)

None Would Escape (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+] (11)
@ sync is ok
@ nice rhythms for this style
@ many doubles but they fit the music

Omeganitros's OP (Silver_Brian) [+] (9)
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
@ patterns are fine, overdouble'd at parts but ok

Orchestral Angels (Valtrix) [+?]
@ sync is ok, but no need to use 284 BPM
* rhythms are ok, missing a few notes(streams start with yellow note), middle jumpy part don't flow very well for me
@ patterns are ok

Otter's Dance (Hotroot Mix) (Silvuh) [+] (7)
@ sync is good
@ rhythms could go with percussion parts but good for easy files
@ patterns are ok

Over The Frail Dream (moches) [?]
@ sync is ok
* ok 8th rhythms, but felt missing some notes
* 8th jacky, trilly patterns

overtherave (JX) [+] (10)

Paradise Girl MADORIN (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [?]
* sync is a bit off (gap early)
* streams in the middle don't match well to the music IMO
* long 32nd burst, ending is overall overdouble'd

Party On (jecht3009046) [?]
* sync is off (gap early)
* rhythms are ok, but a bit repetitive

Piano Concerto No. 9 (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythm is ok
* double placement is ok, stream patterns are a bit awkward
* permission from performer?

PMU Amadeus (i love you) [?]
@ sync is
@ overall rhythms are ok, some parts aren't going well with the music
* some stream/triplet patterns aren't comfortable for me

Policy In The Sky! (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+] (4)
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are fine

Polynator (MeaCulpa) [?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good, although should be a bit less repetitive
* overall, patterns are awkward

Prelude to Rites (Silvuh) [+] (6)
@ sync is good, but any reason for making it 150 BPM with purple arrows?
@ rhythms are good
@ minijacks are 4-framer so ok for a piano song

Pure My Heart (MetalMethodMan) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ good, fun rhythms, ok stream patterns
* minijacks (3 framer)
* jumpstreams, partially overdouble'd

Purple (dore) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ good rhythms, patterns are ok for 230BPM stream
* IMO jumpstreams at the end aren't needed (or should be shorter)

Resonance (T3RR3N) [?]
* stnc is off (gap early)
@ rhythms are ok, it's better if it has more variation though.
* stream patterns, double placement

Revival Day Impoetus (Knoobish) [?]
@ sync is good
* rhythms are basically good, but repetitive (same rhythms for like 300+ notes)
* stream patterns (spin-like)

Riddle Me A Rat's Nest (BDN) [+] (3)
* sync is ok
* rhythms are good, long 4ths are a bit boring but ok for this difficulty

Road To You (~Zero~) [+] (8)
@ sync is almost ok (a bit gap late)
@ rhythms are good
@ patterns are almost ok

Road to you (i love you and i hate you) [<]
* sync is a bit off(gap early)
@ rhythms are overall ok
* long trills for no good reason, a bit awkwaed streams
* zero's is better

Robot Army (MeaCulpa) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
* stream patterns (many crossovers/spins)

ROM-eo & Juli8 (BLAZZE) [-]
x auto rejection for multiple difficulty

Rottel-da-STAR (i love you) [?]
* sync is a bit off(gap early)
@ rhythms are overall ok
* patterns of jumpstream at the ending are awkward
* minijacks
* permission?


S-Z, 45 Files (12 +s)

Sail AwaY (Rebirth) [+] (9)
@ sync is good
@ rhythms/patterns are fine
* basically quite similar to hi19's, discuss

Sail AwaY(~Zero~) [<]
@ sync is good
@ good rhythms
* stream pattern is a bit awkward at parts, last double isn't needed
* rebirth's is a bit better for me but discuss

Sasoribi - Fether (Cyanite) [?]
@ sync is good
* had some issue on jumpstreams, bursts(32nd + double, 32nd + 24th)
* there're some parts that streams are better for than 8th alternate doubles

SGX - Lo-Fi Attitude (Cyanite) [?]
* sync is a bit off (gap early)
* I know there're corresponding rhythms in the song, but beginning is overstepped for me.

Shin Trigger (SulferDragon) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are ok
* double placement of some parts (second half) are a bit weird

Shind Bad for ffr (dore) [?]
@ sync is good
* rhythms aren't repetitive, but a bit too random
* stream patterns are good, double placement is odd for me though

Sky Dragoon - X4 (SulferDragon)

Sly (Vote4Nixon) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ good rhythms
* a bit double'd at parts, some stream patterns

Smitty's Downfall (darkshark) [?]
@ sync is good
* minijacks
* no need for stepping streams as like all trills for synth strings

Smittys enTRANCE (ledwix) [?]
@ sync is good
* rhythms are a bit repetitive, and difficulty inconsistency
* middle parts are overstepped for this song

Smitty's Uprising (adlp) [?]
* sync is a bit off (gap late)
* rhythms are repetitive/boring at parts
* jumpstreams, jack patterns for no good reason

Snipertime (u84) [-]
* overall offsync
* jacks, some rhythms are weird

Snowball Fight! (unkdavar) [?]
* sync is a bit off (gap early)
@ rhythms are ok
* 8th jacks, awkward 16ths, trills, overall uncomfortable

Song For All Time[dore] [+] (6)
@ sync is good
@ overall good rhythms/fine patterns

Sought Freedom (Matrixdude) [-]
@ sync is almost ok (a bit gap early)
* YNS at the second half
* stream patterns are awkward/trills

Star (Yohman) [?]
@ sync is ok
* missing the rhythm at 24th zone
* ending 12th d-jack should be removed

Starman (Scytlock) [+] (7)
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
* short streams patterns are a bit odd for me but ok

StealthMan [?]
* sync is a bit off (gap early)
* rhythms should go with music better using 16ths
* minijack

Stormy Wing (MeaCulpa) [?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are fine
* stream patterns are awkward

Stormy(~Zero~) [+] (5)
@ sync is good
@ nice easy song

Strawberry (Silvuh) [+] (5)
@ sync is ok
@ minijack is acceptable

Strawberry Music (jimerax) [+] (9)

Surface [?]
@ sync is ok, BPM should be doubled
* some places streams are better for me
* overdouble'd, 8th jacky patterns

Switchback (FFR Edit) v2 (Silver_Brian) [+] (7)
@ sync is ok
@ rhythms are mostly good
@ patterns are a bit weird at parts but ok

Syage (ElectricWerewolf) [+] (9)
@ sync is good
@ good rhythms/patterns, trills are ok

Szamar Madar (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [-]
* said in previous batch, this file won't make it without music-cut

The Cracking Sky (Vote4Nixon) [+] (5)
@ sync is ok
@ rhythms/patterns for this difficulty

The Doomsday (MrPopadopalis25) [-]
* sync is off, YNS
* minijacks

The Entertainer (sc979) [-]
x deletion by Tass

The World As We Know It (hyperxtrance) [<]
* overall offsync (gap early), 4ths start with blue note
@ rhythms are fine with fixed sync
* unk's is better

The World As We Know It (unkdavar) [+] (7)
@ already in the game

through out the world(sammo123) [-]
* totally off, jacks

To Zanarkand (u84) [?]
* sync is off at parts
* rhythms go with the music, but difficulty inconsistency

Turkey March (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are ok
* bursts in the stream

Utopia (BLAZZE) [?]
@ sync is good
@ overall good thythms
* I think 32nd bursts aren't needed, partially overdouble'd

Venetian Spirit (moches)

Viennacore (newblue22) [+] (9)
@ sync is ok
@ Rhythms are good, it's better if 24ths are in the stream (accordion part)
@ patterns are ok

Vook (Jugglinguy) [?]
* sync is a bit off (gap early)
* rhythms don't flow well to the music
* too many staircases for stream

WiFO (dore) [-]
@ sync is good
* overuse of 8th jacks, bursts, those are a bit wrong way to make it difficult for FFR.

Winter (brothaice) [<]
@ sync is good
* almost fine, I didn't get the rhythms/double placement near the end though
@ patterns are almost fine
* rebirth's is better

Winter (Rebirth) [+] (9)
@ sync is good
@ good rhythms/patterns, trills are fine

Winter Shiki (Rebirth) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are fine
* Ending would be better with some doubly patterns with the music than whole streams
* I doubt this version is needed with winter full ver

Wish (Reprise) (HammyMcSquirrel) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
@ felt a bit overdoubled, but ok they are going with music
* better stream patterns

X (MeaCulpa) [?]
@ sync is ok
* rhythms are almost ok, beginning should be better with the music
* minijacks, stream patterns

Zen 2k5 (brothaice) [?]
* sync is a bit off (overall early)
* rhythms are ok, a bit odd at parts
@ patterns are fine





SHASH
Batch 7:
A Beautiful Wings +? (Understepped in general, also ends a little too far into the fade-out)
Affected +? (Stream patterns)
Arabesque +? (Rhythms could be better, the little accent 48th is not necessary at all)
August +
bbblow +
Blazing +
Blue Moss +? (Beginning is offbeat, kind of boring in general)
Can't Live Without You +? (This would work a LOT better with pitch relevancy, also lose that last note wtf)
Charlotte (Guassian Blur) +? (I'm almost certain those 32nds bursts cause 3-frame potential, + otherwise)
Clash at the Mountains +
D Gang +
Decisive Battle +
Desertion +? (A couple too many staircases, also the running men at the end aren't really necessary)
Disconnected Mobius + (no idea what jx is talking about, I only see oni)
Distant Land +
Distorted Reality +
Empty Glasses +? (More consistent jump use throughout please)
Euro Freak +
F +
False Strawberry +
Fantasy Impromptu ? (Song really needs a more pitch relevant file)
Fleeting Fantasy - (This is almost the same thing as Vertex Beta, and as such there's really no reason to have it)
Flower Forever +
For Your Love +
Frozen Rain +
Genophobia +
Going on Spring Wind +? (Blue 4ths at the beginning)
Happy Rainbow +? (I don't really hear the three-jump-jack things in the music)
Hatten Carnival +
Idyll v2 + (I don't remember the original at all, this is only based on this file...if it's too close to the original then it's not a + of course)
In Memory ! (Blazze)
Infection (dore) +
Innocent Decay +
Inverse +? (Wasn't sure about some of the rhythms, especially the stream then 4th notes at the beginning)
Keep on Lovin You +
Love Coloured Master Spark +
Made in Innocent +
Midnight Electricity ? (Song is just way too repetitive, doubt anyone could make a good file from it)
Mocha Ocean +
Monstrous Turtles +? (A little more variety in the rhythms would be nice, like maybe cutting the stream in the middle somehow or something)
Never Look Back +
None Would Escape +
Omeganitros's Op +? (File is fine, only worrying about Kenji Ito permission...if that's settled than +)
Otter's Dance +? (Kind of understepped throughout, also many of the rhythms seemed either inconsistent with each other or just not very good)
Over the Rave +
Party On ? (Jump use is totally random, music-relevant patterns would help a lot)
Piano Concerto 9 ! (Permission issues)
Policy in the Sky +
Prelude to Rites +
Resonance ? (More pitch relevancy would be nice, sync is off, stream doesn't make any sense where it is)
Riddle Me a Rat's Nest +
Road to You +
Robot Army +? (Stream patterns wtf)
Sail Away ! (Without two +'s I'm just not going to play another one of these as there's no point, plus there doesn't seem to be a consensus that it's better than Hi's)
Song for All Time +
Starman +
Stormy +
Strawberry +
Strawberry Music +
Switchback v2 +
Syage +
The Cracking Sky +
The World as We Know It ! (No need to bother, it's in)
Viennacore +? (I think I saw a potential 3-framer near the end, one of those accent 64ths and a 12th)
Winter +? (Minor thing: I don't like the yellow jumps, everything else is good)
*beep* +? (Some of the 32nds don't seem to go to anything)
{Collossus} + (Some of the little yellow note rhythms nearer the end didn't seem to go with anything, very minor though)
{Final Agression} +? (In the mid-beginning part, a couple places seem to have too many jumps, plus the 32nds aren't very audible)
{James Bond Breakbeat Remix} ! (Blazze)
{Losing Touch} v2 ? (Streams go to nothing, lots of the rhythms are awkward, the 16ths after the quiet part start WAY too early, at least a full measure or two before I could hear anything with a reasonable volume level)



TASS
4-12+1 - ? - boring as hell. cut it. not best song for stepping
A Beautiful Wings + little understepped
Affected + one or two small changes to streams @ end
Angelic Layer +? fix up ending stream, 16th jumps offsync?
Arabesque +
August unkdavar ? offsync, doesn't flow, notes missing
August coolboyrulez0 - bpm is wrong, didn't play
BB Euro +? fix up stream @ 300ish. also, remove random quad @ end
Be Princess v2 - too similar to v1
Beat of the War 2 ? trills in beginning, offsync, bpm issues
Beautiful Synergy not as good as Shash's or dore's
Binary shapes +? could use touching up. 16ths near end, remove 32nds, too difficult for file
Blue Moss +? 1 note missing near start
bmv.578 - didn't play, bpm wrong
bubbleman v2 +? remove the 2 8th streams, fix pattern of 2nd 16th stream
burnout v2 - quit out halfway. minijacks, 8ths where there shouldn't be, bad stream patterns
canonized +? bpm is 200. file could be better overall. better stream, jumps in emphasized places
arashi +? section before 1st trill, both trills, inconsistency in 32nd sections
Can't Love w/o You + little repetitive, random quad @ end? possible few sounds missing
chicken wing +? left hand trill
color of giggles ? trills, especially left and right ones
contain +? remove the spam rolls @ end
cruel whole +
csikos post +? few 8ths w/ 3-space-1 that should have 5
Hypnosis ? song is awful, notes missing like crazy, notes don't flow w/ song
Delirium v2 - way overstepped. just no.
delta beat +? bursts in beginning to non-dominant sound. jack @ end of trill
desertion + repetitive
digital intervention ? minijacks, offsync in beginning
disconnected hyper - didn't play, has freezes
dom dadi do +? trill is out of place
dragon's bane +? 320 - 4 jumps & ending 12th jumps
Drowning - fix the bpm, quit out right @ start. also a minijack.
Eating Candies +? are the rolls needed?
Electric Heart 2006 - quit out. bpm is doubled. runningmen.
Empty Glasses + repetitive
Epic Giraffe Storm - YNS, 8th jump section, jacks, awful song
Epidermis BDN ? trill section, 1 handed trills, runningmen
Epidermis debit13 - didn't play, has freezes
ESC +? remove minijacks
estatic - bpm wrong? notes don't go to music
Eternal Dragons +? some of the 16th jack/gallops not right sounds?
Eternal Nocturne ? too long, around 400 8ths not dominant sound, opening offsync?
Euphoria +? 32nds, beginning overstepped
Fantasy Impromptu +? many streams need to be broken down, runningmen, pitch relevant
Final Audition Ep1 ? understepped
Final Fantasy 6 The Sceldt ? steps missing, steps added, some 12ths, jacks
Final Fantasy 7 Battle v2 +? jacks fit, remove at least the long one
Firestorm ? overstepped. 32nd rolls, 24th staircases, jumpstream, 8th chains not chains
Fleeting Fantasy + maybe a few less jumps
Flower Forever ? step the whole song. possibly slightly understepped too.
For FFR v2 ? in trying to be different from v1, you skipped many dominant sounds
Four Vents +? end of song, can't hear music notes are going to
**** Jason ? jack syndrome & song name
Genophobia +? trills out of place w/ rest of file's difficulty
Going on Spring Wind ? offsync, have jumps where there should be trills
HIAPC +? trills out of place w/ difficulty of file
HTIJ +? fix the YNS for the 2nd half
Happy Rainbow +
Horizon Remix ? doesn't flow at all, notes don't go w/ music
I <3 Voltage ? overstepped
in grey +? boring file. bland, repetitive, middle felt off
in memory + lol, blazze.
Infection noches +? missing some notes, no chains
Infection shad0wlord +? beginning overstepped
Inverse +? awkward. check notes non 4/8/16 to make sure you use correct notes
Galaxy9 - whole file offsync
Lonly Lonly +? no 8th chains
Mechanical Bull Fighter +? runningmen / triplet jump section
Mega watt ? jumpstream overstepped
Metalman Theme +? many notes to very faint sounds
Midnight Dragon behanjc +? little too much on non 4/8/16 notes, 12th stream no 12ths
Midnight Dragon unkdavar ? understepped, missing non 4/8/16 notes
Midnight Electricity wickedawesomeful +? boring, needs more breaks
Midnight Electricity eastsideman09 +? boring, needs less jumpstream - song is boring
Minute Rave ? song sucks, stream makes no sense w/ music
Monolith ? doesn't flow. permission?
Monstrous Turtles! ? overstepped
mr larpus - you destroyed an amazing song
my darkest hour hyperxtrance +? fix the bpm issue in the 2 green sections
my darkest hour unkdavar ? other is better, halve bpm, some spots offsync, flow off in places
Necrofantasia +? 8th chain jacks, left hand trill
Negimaniax ? boring as hell, parts offsync
neoMAX v2 - way too similar to v1, v2 not even needed
ninja ? 16th jumps overstepped, repetitive as hell, goes offsync
Ninjitsu - bpm is wrong
Omega's OP ? permission? runningmen, some jumpstream
Orchestral Angels +? halve 280bpm section, less trills
Otter's Dance ? missing a lot of notes, few sections not right w/ music
Over the Frail Dream +? 8th jacks + trills
Paradise Girl Madorin +? little less streamy, 32nd rolls, possibly ending 8th jumps
Party On +
Piano Concerto No 9 + permission?
Polynator +? too repetitive @ end, also where is the sound for the 3-3-7?
Pump Me Amadeus +? way streamier instead of the triplets
Pure My Heart ? jacks, some jumpstream
Purple ? 3-framer hell. no 230bpm stream, plz.
Resonance + light
Revival Day Impoetus ? 400ish 8th chains, slow down offsync
Road to You i love you & i hate you trill, less stream
Robot Army +
ROMeo & Juli8 +? 32nd roll, lol blazze.
Rottel-da-STAR ? jacks, overstepped, permission?
Sail Away rebirth0 > not good enough to switch
Sail Away ~zero~ +? stream patterns, too much stream
Sasoribi ? too many jumps, wtf staircases
Lo-Fi Attitude ? overstepped. stick to main sounds
Shin Trigger +? more notes than music
Shind Bad ? near beginning 8th jumps w/ 16ths, 24/32/48 jumps, sped up section
Sky Dragoon +? VERY boring
Sly +? some jumpstream too much
Smitty's Downfall ? jumps in triplets, minijacks, trills, stream patterns boring
Smitty's Uprising +? inconsistent jumpstream once, no jumpstream another time. fix 3-note jack & ending jack
Smitty's enTRANCE ? were you listening to the song? doesn't go to music, jacks, overstepped, parts offsync
Snipertime - quit @ jacks. fix bpm too.
Snowball Fight +? fix jump use in beginning
Sought Freedom - quit out @ YNS
Star +? fix 8th patterns, are the gallops really 24ths?
Stealth Man ? boring, flow, minijack, 8th jumps near end, cut song.
Stormy Wing +? repetitive, less jumps in 2nd half
Surface ? cut music, too many jumps too many jacks, transition seemed off
Szamar Madar +? cut beginning & end.
The Doomsday - fix YNS, quit out.
The world as we know it hyperxtrance quit out, offsync
To Zanarkand ? YNS, minijack, 64th bursts
Turkey March +? 48ths in stream, runningmen
Utopia +? 32nd rolls, jumps in 1st stream
Venetian Spirit +? minijack, runningmen
ViennaCore +? runningmen, ending 12ths
Vook ? stream patterns, 32nd triplets, 8th jumps, ending
Mur Q +? didn't flow
WiFO - 3 framer nightmare. quit out.
Winter brothaice +? jumpstream
Winter Rebirth0 +? one handed trills into runningmen
Winter Shiki +? one handed trills
Wishnes ? awful patterns
X +? 2nd half of file
Zen 2k5 +? 8th section offsync, not as good as some other versions
*beep* +
{Adrinaline Pumper} +, maybe
{Big Boss} Heavy10 - YNS & 48th Syndrome
{Big Boss} Light1 +? a lot of sounds missing
{Final Agression} +? 8th jumps
{James Bond Breakbeat} + lol, blazze
{Losing Touch} v2 +
{Lost Memories} +? 8th jumps, notes over 16ths
{Popo Runaway} - quit out. 3framer potential
~Monster~ +? non-index friendly stream





Enjoy!

[pokelda]

in before wtf

[l Endorphin l]

4-12+1 has been chunked haha.
I don't even like the file or song anymore.

Also, does a file have to be fully pitch relevant?

[Tasselfoot]

Endorphin: no, it doesn't.... but it should fall into 1 of 2 categories: pitch relevant or fun. usually pitch relevant files are not as "fun", but are technically accurate. fun files are.... fun to play.

[Knoobish]

I have to ask, what exactly is an 8th chain? Two of my files had them in Tass' notes as being bad things.

[pokelda]

accept only fun to play, for god sakes.

[macgravel]

Originally Posted by Jimerax

Mostrous Turtles! (MacGravel) [+] (10)
@ sync is good
@ rhythms are good
@ stream patterns are good, a bit continuous though

Cool.

Originally Posted by Shashakiro

Monstrous Turtles +? (A little more variety in the rhythms would be nice, like maybe cutting the stream in the middle somehow or something)

Cool? I'll look at it and see what I can do.

Originally Posted by Tasselfoot

Monstrous Turtles! ? overstepped

Oh wait sorry brb adding in jumps everywhere even though I didn't. No, it isn't overstepped >_>

[Rebirth0]

Reject my winter files because of one handed trills and running men.

I've told you before (well..at least tass), the running men are clearly in the music and it's easy to tell if you slow down the music and listen. The one handed trills... WHO THE **** CARES. One one handed trills? Then you better have rejected every single file with some one handed trills. Either that or don't play spread. Even though they're one handed trills, it gives more variety of trill patterns...come on

Dam Dadi Doo (Rebirth) [+?]
@ sync is good
@ good rhythms/patterns
* 16th trills don't match other parts

ok tell me when you remove the 16th beats from the song which you can clearly hear, then it's alright to say that

[SulferDragon]

4 out of 11? =/ I shouldn't have even submitted some of those files.

Well, I'm really happy to see Clash at the Mountains, and especially {Colossus} make it. I'm disappointed none of my ZeRo-BaSs stuff made it, but I blame MacGravel (At least for one of them).

I also can't wait for Over the Rave to be in the game. Release it NOW!

P.S. hi MacGravel.

[macgravel]

Originally Posted by SulferDragon

but I blame MacGravel (At least for one of them).

What did I do O_O

[Rebirth0]

Also... come to a conclusion on Cold Breath because I submitted that months ago and it should be one of the skill tokens this month since it's been... "being talked about" for MONTHS

I submitted it back in early March... come the **** on

[SulferDragon]

Originally Posted by macgravel

What did I do O_O

Hey, you played Sky Dragoon for me, and said it was good.

lol, I'm just joking though!

[DrugstoreCowboy]

If shash and JX both +'d, and you +? Genophobia, why isnt it in queue?