TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

[mellon_collie]

Re: TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

@wild question for game 2

Should you guys mass claim ? I'm asking this because it looks like you guys can only die one at a time and night kills doesn't seems to exist.

This should outweight the danger of dying and help game 1 progress faster (?)

This is a really interesting idea...

brb driving to the getty

what's the getty?

I am liking the energy of Xiz's re-entrance today so far. At the very least it's generating some good discussion

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

I'll be reading the thread for the next few hours. It will be slow. I won't be able to go any faster. If you intend on actually solving my role, please re-link for me. If your convinced im a wolf just vote me, and i'll skim past your posts prioritizing other players thoughts.

At best this is bad play
At worse, in effect, what you are doing is justifying not engaging with players who don't read you as you would like. You are acting like these players are being unreasonable and my very short, likely not super helpful answer to that is "they are".

Dispite what Haku implies, no one is voting you becauseyou work alot; no one is voting you for being a loving and attentive boyfriend; no one is voting you because of schedule timing: you are getting votes for lack of input and content in past phases. It is not you're fault that you were busy, but it is not our fault either. We vote with what we have, in thread, and not what could have been.

[Xiz]

Re: TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

This is a really interesting idea...



what's the getty?

I am liking the energy of Xiz's re-entrance today so far. At the very least it's generating some good discussion

A museum

[Xiz]

Re: TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

At best this is bad play
At worse, in effect, what you are doing is justifying not engaging with players who don't read you as you would like. You are acting like these players are being unreasonable and my very short, likely not super helpful answer to that is "they are".

See all of Benguin’s posts, your right but wrong at the same time, but I understand what you are saying

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

the people in the post above are part of my never lynch pile.

Regarding the xiz discussion from last night, I really don't see an issue with those posts. You can say what you want about everything else he's done this game, but I don't think xiz is the type of person who'd lie about having to complete a sprint for a big project he's been working on, or even embellish how taxing that sprint's been on him just for the sake of giving himself slank cover. So, to me it's NAI. Those posts would've been made no matter what alignment he'd been given.

As I said in last post, these are not the reasons in and of themselves. Xiz has done very little with his time and we can only vote with what we have.

I have an idea about that, but I'll save it for when OOTC turns back on.

I wish you wouldn't, but I will not press this issue

I am liking the energy of Xiz's re-entrance today so far. At the very least it's generating some good discussion

I don't think I agree with this. Can you further explain what kind of energy? What mindset do you think this energy is coming from? Are these assessments different or the same between his tone and his reads/gameplan?

Raeko, you have a habit of writing a post like this, talking about discussions but then rarely contribute to them in thread past a few sentences that just observed. I want to believe you were the pure one on that wagon, and I need your help in solving the game. No number of thoughts is too many. Help us read you and find our footing in where we go next

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

See all of Benguin’s posts, your right but wrong at the same time, but I understand what you are saying

Let's say I am wrong in my assumption on other's willingness to cut you slack. And I make this hypothetical in the best of intentions I promise

How is your behavior/response to it helping the game state for town? Is it as mechanically/townsided of an action as picking up from here and just earnestly trying to solve the game state as time allows?

To solve the gamestate, should you need be as informed as time allows?

~

This is important to convey so let me give it it's own line

It doesn't matter to me if you solve the game or arrive at the right answer so long as I can believe you attempted with the time and resources you had

I just need to believe you tried to solve what you could in good faith.

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

I .... don't know why one of my lines is gone

When Xiz said he wasnt lyncing those above him, the only alive player was Cel. So Cel is his one "no lynch"?

[MixMasterLar]

Re: TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

If this helps you save time, Xiz, then I want to remind you we are less interested in solving anyone who lynched Storn.

While I'd love reads on everybody for future reference, this phase we only focus on the players that could have been trying to save him: yourself, Kappa, Raeko and Cel.

If time is tight, these are the players you'd really need to articulate thoughts on today.

[Xiz]

Re: TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

How is your behavior/response to it helping the game state for town? Is it as mechanically/townsided of an action as picking up from here and just earnestly trying to solve the game state as time allows?

To solve the gamestate, should you need be as informed as time allows?

~

This is important to convey so let me give it it's own line

It doesn't matter to me if you solve the game or arrive at the right answer so long as I can believe you attempted with the time and resources you had

I just need to believe you tried to solve what you could in good faith.

Its kind of a loaded question since your asking me, I feel others should answer this more than me. The only hard information we have is there are red and green flips. That’s it. I’m progressing based off of that. Rest is pure speculation. Also, I think mood is a huge part as well in how people have been posting this game. Any of the people I said in the big post, or even like roundbox and haku

[Xiz]

Re: TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

I .... don't know why one of my lines is gone

When Xiz said he wasnt lyncing those above him, the only alive player was Cel. So Cel is his one "no lynch"?

It carries over to game 2 if I end up there

[Xiz]

Re: TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

If this helps you save time, Xiz, then I want to remind you we are less interested in solving anyone who lynched Storn.

While I'd love reads on everybody for future reference, this phase we only focus on the players that could have been trying to save him: yourself, Kappa, Raeko and Cel.

If time is tight, these are the players you'd really need to articulate thoughts on today.

It’s not that I’m less interested, I think there are enough people trying to solve storns wagon, we got enough people why not explore other ideas?

[Xiz]

Re: TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

However, if you want me to focus on that I will

[Celirra]

Re: TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

If this helps you save time, Xiz, then I want to remind you we are less interested in solving anyone who lynched Storn.

While I'd love reads on everybody for future reference, this phase we only focus on the players that could have been trying to save him: yourself, Kappa, Raeko and Cel.

If time is tight, these are the players you'd really need to articulate thoughts on today.

If I was trying to "save" storn, I would've voted for ben. Wolf chat would've been like "CEL VOTE FOR BEN @@@@@" and I would've hobbled to my keyboard and shitted out some stuff.

Did I want to save storn? yes. Did I do anything about it? no.

also there's a chance that literally both ben and storn are a hit. We can't confirm the former, so wagonomics aren't really that simple. Sounds like an easy and convenient way to clear your slot though.

[Celirra]

Re: TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

It doesn't matter to me if you solve the game or arrive at the right answer so long as I can believe you attempted with the time and resources you had

I just need to believe you tried to solve what you could in good faith.

You're full of shit with this. You'll never be satisfied that some people did enough with the time that they did have.

[Celirra]

Re: TWG 200 Game Thread: Dichotomy

@wild question for game 2

Should you guys mass claim ? I'm asking this because it looks like you guys can only die one at a time and night kills doesn't seems to exist.

This should outweight the danger of dying and help game 1 progress faster (?)

I don't think mass claim is a good idea. We can't actually validate much of it let alone cross-check by nature of it being a closed bastard game, and it might falsely "clear" people.