Re: jTWG LXX: Flash Squadron - Game thread
I am going to give a fully fledged reads list here prefacing it with I have been wrong this entire game as I have been basing a lot of my game around funny being mafia so I am having to reconsider quite a bit.
Cold kitten - I called her my top town yesterday and while I wouldn't say she is my top anymore because her over defensive-ness is so much different from her early game play, I still think she is town. Her early posts were very analytical and she was the most active and productive person in the first half of day 1.
J-Rodd - I was reading him as very towny but he is one of the people I need to reconsider on. I really liked how active he was after being subbed in and I liked that he was frustrated being subbed in so late into the day. That being said I am not sure if I got pocketed by him since he hopped on the funny train I made however he did move his vote from her before she claimed. He was very inactive day 1 and so far the only thing he has done today is claim not mason so he is very possibly mafia. I would like to hear your reads list soon.
Reuben-Tate - He is the lurkiest player in the game so far. I don't really remember any reads he has pushed and he has definitely been very quite the entirety of the game. He was also the last person to jump on the funny train granted it was after j-rodd had changed his vote. I need to go back and read the posts he made to flesh out my read on him (if there is a way to look at only one players reads that would be very useful)
Red Blaster - He is the most confident player in this game which is very towny. However it is very possible that he is only confident because he is being heavily town read. Early on in the game he said almost nothing and if YoshL hadn't pushed on him it is very possible he never would have. He also has been pushing on charles heavily who I am reading as town and he started this day pushing on cold kitten then inexplicably backed off when she said "except i'm town so .-.". He then took her out of his 6 people he was reading as possible mafia and has since kept that list of five without mentioning cold kitten at all, even using the fact that he only had 5 possible mafia as a means of getting to auto.
YoshL - I was reading him as mafia mostly based on his push on iironiic but the green check definitely changes it for me. I had completely forgotten that the godfather role was in the game (we never use it in DM) and the fact that he is not only the only one to remind everyone that it is a possibility and that he has done it multiple times is very towny. There is no reason for him to bring out information that will help town and hinder himself if he is mafia.
Charles - I didn't like him much early on but that changed near the end of day 0. I really liked his responses to Jteh pushing on him and he fixed my earliest concern with him (the fact that he gave a lot of null reads in his first reads list as well as being rather quite) by giving a very good reads list with a lot of in depth analysis on the game.
Storn - I had a slight town read on soramimi from giving up but iironiic had just done the same thing and, at the time, it seemed to have gotten rid of all the votes on him so trying to mimic that play is very possible. As for storn the only thing he has done of note is jump on the funny train with little to no backing. His reasoning was very weird and he has said almost nothing both days he has been here. For now he is my strongest mafia read.
cry - I believe his cop claim. Everyone has talked today besides him and reuben and reuben was present for EOD and would have claimed then. I hope he contributes more.
funnygurl - Sorry bro. At least I learned how you play and will be better next time.
Conclusion:
My lynches for today are in order from best to worst are: storn , reuben (going to look back at his play though so update on him eventually), j-rodd, red.
My town in order from most to least are: Cry, YoshL, Charles, Cold
I am going to give a fully fledged reads list here prefacing it with I have been wrong this entire game as I have been basing a lot of my game around funny being mafia so I am having to reconsider quite a bit.
Cold kitten - I called her my top town yesterday and while I wouldn't say she is my top anymore because her over defensive-ness is so much different from her early game play, I still think she is town. Her early posts were very analytical and she was the most active and productive person in the first half of day 1.
J-Rodd - I was reading him as very towny but he is one of the people I need to reconsider on. I really liked how active he was after being subbed in and I liked that he was frustrated being subbed in so late into the day. That being said I am not sure if I got pocketed by him since he hopped on the funny train I made however he did move his vote from her before she claimed. He was very inactive day 1 and so far the only thing he has done today is claim not mason so he is very possibly mafia. I would like to hear your reads list soon.
Reuben-Tate - He is the lurkiest player in the game so far. I don't really remember any reads he has pushed and he has definitely been very quite the entirety of the game. He was also the last person to jump on the funny train granted it was after j-rodd had changed his vote. I need to go back and read the posts he made to flesh out my read on him (if there is a way to look at only one players reads that would be very useful)
Red Blaster - He is the most confident player in this game which is very towny. However it is very possible that he is only confident because he is being heavily town read. Early on in the game he said almost nothing and if YoshL hadn't pushed on him it is very possible he never would have. He also has been pushing on charles heavily who I am reading as town and he started this day pushing on cold kitten then inexplicably backed off when she said "except i'm town so .-.". He then took her out of his 6 people he was reading as possible mafia and has since kept that list of five without mentioning cold kitten at all, even using the fact that he only had 5 possible mafia as a means of getting to auto.
YoshL - I was reading him as mafia mostly based on his push on iironiic but the green check definitely changes it for me. I had completely forgotten that the godfather role was in the game (we never use it in DM) and the fact that he is not only the only one to remind everyone that it is a possibility and that he has done it multiple times is very towny. There is no reason for him to bring out information that will help town and hinder himself if he is mafia.
Charles - I didn't like him much early on but that changed near the end of day 0. I really liked his responses to Jteh pushing on him and he fixed my earliest concern with him (the fact that he gave a lot of null reads in his first reads list as well as being rather quite) by giving a very good reads list with a lot of in depth analysis on the game.
Storn - I had a slight town read on soramimi from giving up but iironiic had just done the same thing and, at the time, it seemed to have gotten rid of all the votes on him so trying to mimic that play is very possible. As for storn the only thing he has done of note is jump on the funny train with little to no backing. His reasoning was very weird and he has said almost nothing both days he has been here. For now he is my strongest mafia read.
cry - I believe his cop claim. Everyone has talked today besides him and reuben and reuben was present for EOD and would have claimed then. I hope he contributes more.
funnygurl - Sorry bro. At least I learned how you play and will be better next time.
Conclusion:
My lynches for today are in order from best to worst are: storn , reuben (going to look back at his play though so update on him eventually), j-rodd, red.
My town in order from most to least are: Cry, YoshL, Charles, Cold
Comment