TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

[bugkid666]

Re: TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

Is calling for a lynch that'll give us information versus mislynching a potential scum read that'll give us 0 information really throwing? Am I that wrong here?

Nah, just providing other perspectives. It could go either way

[mellon_collie]

Re: TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

mislynching a potential scum

slip theory? lol

[cedolad]

Re: TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

slip theory? lol

How so? It says potential scum read btw lol

[flashflash account]

Re: TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

Also by Xiz calling me town, that makes me think he’s town bc clearly you all think I’m sus or at the very least hard to read lol and it’d be easy for xiz to just claim I’m a wolf or whatever else if he was a wolf himself. But that could also be bs

this is an insightful post and it would have a lot of merit for non-xiz players
xiz could be town reading you for a ton of reasons though

[mellon_collie]

Re: TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

How so? It says potential scum read btw lol

lmao i cant read ignore me

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

Is calling for a lynch that'll give us information versus mislynching a potential scum read that'll give us 0 information really throwing? Am I that wrong here?

The short answer is yes because wolves could spend the entire game not giving information.

Look at WV. 3 posts. How do you catch that ? How do you get info out of that ? You can't.

[cedolad]

Re: TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

The short answer is yes because wolves could spend the entire game not giving information.

Look at WV. 3 posts. How do you catch that ? How do you get info out of that ? You can't.

That would be a bad lynch and I wouldn't endorse his lynch as he gives no information, because as you've said, he only has 3 posts.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

That would be a bad lynch and I wouldn't endorse his lynch as he gives no information, because as you've said, he only has 3 posts.

Yes, but if the entire wolf team plays like WV they autowin against what you're proposing.

[SubaruPoptart]

Re: TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

sunfan is definitely the alien but I don't care

OK but what is this supposed to mean and how do you know they're alien? Like what kinda tells does an alien even give here

[flashflash account]

Re: TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

OK but what is this supposed to mean and how do you know they're alien? Like what kinda tells does an alien even give here

I'm never lynching them so it doesn't matter whether they're 3p or not

[cedolad]

Re: TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

Yes, but if the entire wolf team plays like WV they autowin against what you're proposing.

You're surely not implying that I play everyday like d0. Tomorrow we have way more information to work with.

I must be dense or something.

[SubaruPoptart]

Re: TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

also Shadow_God_10 I honestly forgot what I was doing when you mentioned my thoughts bout page 17, but I have some atm. The whole "who gives the most info when we lynch them" thing's not been making sense to me. I can understand getting someone out so we have a basis on where things are with the flip but what if they're town and then we lose an extra town member we didn't need to lose? Cuz if we hit a vanilla townie what information does that give? It just says they were a good person and then that's kinda it, from what I understand of the game. That's why I'm kinda hesitant to lynch someone for the sole purpose of information because it could backfire super hard.

[bugkid666]

Re: TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

I agree with hope here tbh but I’m assuming the rebuttal will be “well obviously we won’t lynch THOSE people” ok but then who?

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

You're surely not implying that I play everyday like d0. Tomorrow we have way more information to work with.

I must be dense or something.

I kind of think in reverse for the info lynch tbh.

I feel like we should lynch someone that is too hard to get info from.

[SubaruPoptart]

Re: TWG 197 - TWGood End 2

Also flashflash account I just realized, why are you never lynching the sun fan exactly? I may have missed it in the prior pages but I don't remember many of you two's interactions.